Other than wondering what the jailer saw in Andy to want to jail him, I don't have much else to discuss at the moment. Rereading everything is kind of annoying due to the spam. Finding a serious post in this thread is like finding a needle in a haystack. If Andy survives (which I think might happen) or is still around now, I want to ask him how the conversation with the jailer went and what defense he gave to the jailer.
Also I believe Superpenguin when he says he made those claims so that he can stay alive. He's really annoying and I think mafia often wants to shut him up quick by killing him, because there's often a point to his annoying behavior.
Was pretty curious of that myself, but after reading what
AndyB said I guess I'm kind of convinced. I guess letting him go means Andy is pretty much confirmed town? That or the Jailer just didn't see any reason to kill him, though they probably should have just to be safe.
Honestly I don't get why Nick (
SP) is so dead set on being annoying in these games lately. Rebelling against the 48 hour days still?
Great. We lost a doctor.
I can't help but wonder WHO targeted Miss Noodle. Judging by her will, she says that Oath and Capella knew her role.
I think oath would be smarter than that, like it has been said. Capella, well, I don't understand why MissNoodle would PM them. Provided her helpful role to town, if she trusted oath, I would understand due to him being known as a strong player. But Capella? I don't get. I guess she went with whoever she felt best in the player list.
If the DT checks/or we lynch one of them, and that person turn up scum, based what was said in her will, they're both scum. If they don't turn up, then neither are. I'm assuming that's a 99.1% chance.
I wouldn't recommend doing any of this just yet because day just started.
*Gunsmith or whatever it's called
THE NAME CAUGHT ME OFF GUARD.
Capella seems the most likely of the two to be mafia, though I think Oath is smart enough to realize we'd brush off that. There's always the chance that
MissNoodle was a random kill as well, go for the people less likely to be protected Night 1 compared to trying to take out all the strong players.
Okay, so I have a thought and I'm wondering what other people think. Now Cory was targeted by a few people early on in the game, however it seemed to later die down. Now I feel the person that was most adamant about getting Cory gone was Tom and now Cory's dead so obviously he was targeted for a reason. Perhaps it's a coincidence but it's worth noting.
I'm not that dumb. Besides, as much I think Cory is a dirty liar I'm not going to kill him off and face backlash.
I honestly believe Tom is town. I guess someone on the scum team killed Cory for personal reasons or they truly believed he was a watcher (even though he said he wasn't later). He wouldn't have killed Cory as scum, that would've been silly.
Daww. <3 There's also the fact the two others who were on Cory were
Oath and
Superpenguin.
Ninja'd. I was just going to say something about that as well, but I still feel it's something worth noting. Tom has been really quiet lately I feel.
Just posting my thoughts :x
Mostly because my sleep cycles is all sorts of wonked out and yesterday I had two doctors appointments across town. Told Oath about that last night, plus I had a health scare around 1-2 AM in which my breathing was labored. I'm fine now, so I will be trying to contribute when possible.
Tom helped to lead the no lynch, which could be scum trying to slow town down. People bandwagoned pretty quick on it (in one hour!? Seriously???), which makes me believe that there will have been scum hiding among the voters. Not sure where he's disappeared to, but I'm on the fence at the moment. He does seem town-like looking at his posts.
Shiny, where have you been? Am I missing something here? I'm pretty sure you usually post more than this, and all I'm seeing looking at your post filter is one-liners. I was kind of leaning towards bored townie, however I'm still not sure.
Ashtot seems townie-ish, but I haven't really got many thoughts on him so far.
I tend to play pro-town day one as scum, so leading a no lynch would draw unnecessary attention to myself. Also see reply to
Benmjy. As for
Shiny, he's been unnaturally quiet even compared to POI Mafia where they were a blue. But
Ashtot has me confused. He doesn't seem mafia, but he doesn't seem town. Like for the most part he's just meekly agreeing with people? I don't think I've seen an original thought from him yet? We've talked in the IRC, but I still really haven't gotten a read from him. Maybe I've just been out a few games too long.
Oh, and if Aerious is actually the new EXALT Rookie and they get shot tonight by a Vig, we at least earn ourself some Meld for Dr. Vahlen's research! Silver lining!
I don't get why everyone thinks
Aerious is EXALT now? But yes, that would be a wonderful silver lining if that is the case.
I don't see how someone jailed is confirmed town.
They're not, the Jailer just didn't feel like killing them off it seems.
Sataric is also making me suspicious. I don't remember this kind of bravado and snideness from him before. Again, will post in depth at home. I do read the thread at breaks and try to formulate my thoughts as best as I can on my tiny phone. Excuse spelling mistakes.
The snideness is probably from getting used to SP's annoying new demeanor and just being disliked by a majority of "veteran" players for "trying to hard".
Capella, I know the screenshot thing scared you off, but I'm still not content with the exchange that you shared. You talked to Noodle for like 6 lines. I really can't see why Noodle would've included that exchange in her will unless she literally made her will as she was sending the first message to you or something... Oath was very open and clear with all of the pms between himself and Noodle and still can't shake the feeling that there is more to your conversation.
I really do feel like
Capella is withholding, either because they fear getting caught in a lie or because their role doesn't match up. I mean sure you talk about other things with friends, but if you two are playing mafia you tend to talk about it for more than six lines.
Yes, I am his friend but that's not why I'm defending him. Moron keeps extremely quiet when he's scum and doesn't post anything. He hasn't been like that at all this game. It's entirely obvious that his play style is more town oriented.
Frozen Mafia,
Moron was scum and literally didn't try at all. Unless he/she/they learned their lesson, I'm inclined to side with
Aerious and
Moron.
