Mafia TBT Mafia XIV - Majora's Mask Redux - End Game

[Ashtot]

The 3 I think would be the best to lynch on day 1 would be Mew and Ryan88. Mew because she pretty much just posts "okay well to sum that all up" every couple pages in every game without actually giving any real insight, and has a reputation for being inactive and Ryan88 because he makes no sense and doesn't do anything.

- - - Post Merge - - -

2*

- - - Post Merge - - -

And I just don't like no-lynch because I'd rather kill an inactive/noob then leave them in the game to screw us over.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

The 3 I think would be the best to lynch on day 1 would be Mew and Ryan88. Mew because she pretty much just posts "okay well to sum that all up" every couple pages in every game without actually giving any real insight, and has a reputation for being inactive and Ryan88 because he makes no sense and doesn't do anything.

- - - Post Merge - - -

2*

- - - Post Merge - - -

And I just don't like no-lynch because I'd rather kill an inactive/noob then leave them in the game to screw us over.

Reasonable enough, especially with Ryan. I think we'd be better off having someone who sums things up and posts than someone who votes and leaves.

 

[MrPicklez]

Hello everyone. I completely forgot this game started today so I'm gonna go back and read a few pages.

 

[Alice]

Reasonable enough, especially with Ryan. I think we'd be better off having someone who sums things up and posts than someone who votes and leaves.

Capella kind of finds her way into that niche every game too, it seems. Basic, barely relative posts and then bandwagon votes.

 

[Minties]

Hey all, checking in here because work. I will post my collected thoughts when I return home in 8 hours. I'll be reading throughout the day.

 

[oath2order]

I would strongly suggest everybody reads their role PMs in full.

 

[epona]

Okay, hi, I only got home a few minutes ago and just caught up with all the posts. Tina's right, a lot of us are GMT timezone or thereabouts, which means quite a few of us don't have that much time to decide what our votes are before sleepy timez (for those of us who have normal sleeping patterns that is; I've got until 6am )

ryan88
Sid2125
BerryPop
Dolby
Mewmewmewm
Capella

If we don't come to a decision let's lynch one of these people.

I don't like this idea; if we follow through with it we will more than likely end up lynching town. Even if they are useless players in your eyes, there's no logic in lynching them simply for the sake of a lynch. Regardless of whether they are inexperienced or ding dongs (as you so poetically put it), a living town aligned player is a living town aligned player is a living town aligned player. Blindly lynching for the sake of it will most likely have a detrimental outcome for town. Granted, at least one of these players could be scum, but there is literally no evidence at all to show that and I'm not going to lynch anyone without reasoning. It's dumb.

And I just don't like no-lynch because I'd rather kill an inactive/noob then leave them in the game to screw us over.

I also don't see how leaving them in the game will screw town over. The only two meanings I can derive from that statement is that they will 'screw us over' by A) dying or B) claiming a blue role and then dying, resulting in the loss of a useful blue ability.
Both scenarios are still invalid.
A) If scum end up killing one of the players you mentioned, it means they're using a kill on one of them, and not on somebody else. If we lynch one of the aforementioned players and they turn out to be town, that means mafia will use that kill on another player, resulting in an extra, avoidable, town aligned death.
B) If one of them claims a blue role, someone's probably just going to steal their mask anyway, so no harm done.

I'm relatively inexperienced and crappy too idk why I'm not on your deadpool




ANYWAY
Do all players with the same alignment have the ability to steal masks on the same nights? Or are the nights different for every individual player?

 

[oath2order]

Okay, hi, I only got home a few minutes ago and just caught up with all the posts. Tina's right, a lot of us are GMT timezone or thereabouts, which means quite a few of us don't have that much time to decide what our votes are before sleepy timez (for those of us who have normal sleeping patterns that is; I've got until 6am )


I don't like this idea; if we follow through with it we will more than likely end up lynching town. Even if they are useless players in your eyes, there's no logic in lynching them simply for the sake of a lynch. Regardless of whether they are inexperienced or ding dongs (as you so poetically put it), a living town aligned player is a living town aligned player is a living town aligned player. Blindly lynching for the sake of it will most likely have a detrimental outcome for town. Granted, at least one of these players could be scum, but there is literally no evidence at all to show that and I'm not going to lynch anyone without reasoning. It's dumb.



I also don't see how leaving them in the game will screw town over. The only two meanings I can derive from that statement is that they will 'screw us over' by A) dying or B) claiming a blue role and then dying, resulting in the loss of a useful blue ability.
Both scenarios are still invalid.
A) If scum end up killing one of the players you mentioned, it means they're using a kill on one of them, and not on somebody else. If we lynch one of the aforementioned players and they turn out to be town, that means mafia will use that kill on another player, resulting in an extra, avoidable, town aligned death.
B) If one of them claims a blue role, someone's probably just going to steal their mask anyway, so no harm done.

I'm relatively inexperienced and crappy too idk why I'm not on your deadpool




ANYWAY
Do all players with the same alignment have the ability to steal masks on the same nights? Or are the nights different for every individual player?

Nights different for each player

 

[Pathetic]

B) If one of them claims a blue role, someone's probably just going to steal their mask anyway, so no harm done.
[/COLOR]

There are no blue roles.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Unless you mean some certain masks count as a 'role'.

 

[epona]

There are no blue roles.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Unless you mean some certain masks count as a 'role'.

I meant it in the sense that some masks count as a role, e.g. Mask of Truth is essentially cop role, Great Fairy's Mask is doc etc.

 

[Pathetic]

I meant it in the sense that some masks count as a role, e.g. Mask of Truth is essentially cop role, Great Fairy's Mask is doc etc.

That's what I meant.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I also don't see how leaving them in the game will screw town over. The only two meanings I can derive from that statement is that they will 'screw us over' by A) dying or B) claiming a blue role and then dying, resulting in the loss of a useful blue ability.
Both scenarios are still invalid.
A) If scum end up killing one of the players you mentioned, it means they're using a kill on one of them, and not on somebody else. If we lynch one of the aforementioned players and they turn out to be town, that means mafia will use that kill on another player, resulting in an extra, avoidable, town aligned death.
B) If one of them claims a blue role, someone's probably just going to steal their mask anyway, so no harm done.

I'm relatively inexperienced and crappy too idk why I'm not on your deadpool

Leaving a player like Ryan88 in will generally leave us confused about their alignment because they don't post complete thoughts and tend to only vote and leave. Easily persuaded to bandwagon and some of their past votes never made sense. Thing is, scum won't kill someone like Ryan or Capella because they serve a purpose of keeping town confused and in the dark. So ideally lynching one of them would be in our interests now rather than later.

 

[Jeremy]

Leaving a player like Ryan88 in will generally leave us confused about their alignment because they don't post complete thoughts and tend to only vote and leave. Easily persuaded to bandwagon and some of their past votes never made sense. Thing is, scum won't kill someone like Ryan or Capella because they serve a purpose of keeping town confused and in the dark. So ideally lynching one of them would be in our interests now rather than later.

It's definitely better than voting for no one. Who are the other candidates then?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

ryan88
Sid2125
BerryPop
Dolby
Mewmewmewm
Capella

If we don't come to a decision let's lynch one of these people.

These are the people Ashtot brought up as possible lynch candidate Jer. Personally I think we should exclude Dolby as he's beneficial to town if town aligned. That then leaves us with five inactive players. I think if we had to choose someone off the list, Ryan would be a prime candidate in my eyes.

 

[radical6]

He mostly wants them dead because they're inactive so it's hard to get a read on. They will "screw" town over by not contributing and bandwagoning. At the end of the game when most players are dead and they're the only ones left, town will be doomed because they won't be able to find scum.

Though I feel like it's fairly easy to tell when Ryan88 is town, so if you guys don't want to no lynch then I'd rather lynch someone else. Would rather not have the same Ryan88 lynch in Mount Olympus mafia you know.

 

[Jeremy]

He mostly wants them dead because they're inactive so it's hard to get a read on. They will "screw" town over by not contributing and bandwagoning. At the end of the game when most players are dead and they're the only ones left, town will be doomed because they won't be able to find scum.

Though I feel like it's fairly easy to tell when Ryan88 is town, so if you guys don't want to no lynch then I'd rather lynch someone else. Would rather not have the same Ryan88 lynch in Mount Olympus mafia you know.

Has Ryan been scum before? His play style confused us in Minties' unofficial game, but he turned out to be town all along. It certainly wasn't easy to tell he was town.

 

[radical6]

Has Ryan been scum before? His play style confused us in Minties' unofficial game, but he turned out to be town all along. It certainly wasn't easy to tell he was town.

He was scum in Nick's brief Makar Mafia, but I could tell something was a BIT off about him. He did get lynched because of a roleclaim, but yeah. I could tell he was town in Minties' unofficial game.

 

[ryan88]

Has Ryan been scum before? His play style confused us in Minties' unofficial game, but he turned out to be town all along. It certainly wasn't easy to tell he was town.

I have been scum once. In Makar mafia.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

I have been scum once. In Makar mafia.

Hi Ryan, any thoughts on the game so far? c:

 

[Byngo]

Has Ryan been scum before? His play style confused us in Minties' unofficial game, but he turned out to be town all along. It certainly wasn't easy to tell he was town.

Tbh Ryan is always kind of scummy looking (no offense)

I think he's been lynched twice now as a townie? I'm not sure