Mafia TBT Mini Mafia II: Catch Scum or Catch Scurvy [Game Over/Town Win]

[Superpenguin]

I don't think FireNinja would vote for himself if he were scum, though. I mean, with the majority lynch in place, he already sent himself well-off on the path of walking the plank.

 

[Dolby]

I'll be the first to cast my vote.

I firmly believe Dolby is scum.

Could you please provide reasoning (if it's just because I defended Trundle I understand)

 

[BellGreen]

What doesn't make sense to me is how FireNinja attacks Waffles for giving us useless information yet FireNinja has yet to share anything worthy of reading.
If you're just going to act desperate, then do it right.

 

[FireNinja1]

I don't think FireNinja would vote for himself if he were scum, though. I mean, with the majority lynch in place, he already sent himself well-off on the path of walking the plank.

I voted so I wouldn't be modkilled. It's a placeholder.

 

[Dolby]

Hm, I think I may know why Beary was killed. This is just a thought, so I could be wrong.

Anyways, out of Beary's post, she had 4 people she was suspious of, Lunatic, who is now dead, FireNinja1, iLoveYou, and ITYW.

Later on into the game she made a post explaining why she thought FireNinja was a pirate:



Even though her post was a "fail", she still was suspious of FireNinja.

And now she's dead.

Since she accused FireNinja of being a pirate twice, I've been getting the feeling that she was killed so she'll stop bringing attention to FireNinja, who she and now I believe is a Pirate.

##VOTE: FireNinja1

(Sorry if this doesn't make any sense, I have problems with explaining things...)

Hikari, Lunatic was killed earlier in the game, he suspected Blu rose and the mafia killed him, Blu rose is a vig, I think that the mafia are just trying to frame people at this point in the game. (But it does make sense)

 

[Superpenguin]

Hikari, Lunatic was killed earlier in the game, he suspected Blu rose and the mafia killed him, Blu rose is a vig, I think that the mafia are just trying to frame people at this point in the game. (But it does make sense)

So do you think Beary was only killed just to get suspicions on someone else?

 

[unravel]

I don't think FireNinja would vote for himself if he were scum, though. I mean, with the majority lynch in place, he already sent himself well-off on the path of walking the plank.

That is what I think as well, and also fireninja please stop FOSing the noobs for no reason. goddamnit I don't even understand what were you thinking? vote himself. if its a placeholder then I understand.

- - - Post Merge - - -

(This looks aggressive)

 

[Dolby]

So do you think Beary was only killed just to get suspicions on someone else?

Yes and no, she could have been killed because she worked with Blu rose, and through her, possibly, iloveyou, and was pretty much confirmed as innocent to the town

 

[oath2order]

What doesn't make sense to me is how FireNinja attacks Waffles for giving us useless information yet FireNinja has yet to share anything worthy of reading.

Preach it. Throughout this game, FireNinja hasn't really contributed much.

 

[iLoveYou]

This could have been an attack to either frame me or FireNinja1. FireNinja1 was a huge suspicion already.

This is exactly why I needed the Detectives to inspect anyone on my list. For this exact reason. Now we have 3 suspicious names floating around, with the chance of only 1 of them being an actual Mafia member.

I'm going to have to vote to lynch Dolby today.

Last night Dolby sent me this PM (about 2 hours after Trundle got lynched and exposed as Godfather):

I am fairly confident that you are in contact with the medic and I am completely confident that you are in contact with the detective, with this in mind I have made a list for the medics to protect... of one person

Beary509

Why her, well she has admitted to working with you and Blu rose and you have pretty much confirmed contact with a detective, in one post which you posted you implied that you were the veteran (I'm here to absorb kp). Blu rose is a vig and you have admitted to having contact with a detective meaning that the mafia could reason that beary is the detective because you probably had contact with her through Blu rose, that said, I hope this pm makes sense.

Now, the reason why I didn't have Beary509 protected was because there were stronger players who needed to be protected. I also already knew Beary509 was a Townie (she roleclaimed to me) so I felt like it was not worth protecting that role instead of a more important blue role. So yes .. Beary509's death COULD have been prevented & I'm sorry Town that it wasn't. I didn't take the PM seriously enough to prevent that kill from happening.

Yes I did confirm that I am in contact with a blue role: Blu Rose the Vigilante. I actually do not know who the Detective is and that is 100% fact. The reason why I went so strongly after both Kuma + Trundle was mainly because of their posting differences, the way Kuma was so eager to vote on innocents and the Mafia bait we left for Trundle in Mumble (a voice program for TBT) + IRC. It had nothing to do with Detectives. I am not in contact with any Detectives because no one trusts me enough to tell me who the Detective is. Fair enough.

Dolby essentially called out Beary509 being killed before it happened & I feel like he wanted us to protect Beary509 to kinda pass off as an innocent Town member preventing kills from happening. This is way too much of a coincidence.

Dolby: if you die an innocent Town member .. I am really sorry. :l We have no other leads & it's either you or FireNinja1 who are going to get lynched today it seems.

 

[unravel]

What doesn't make sense to me is how FireNinja attacks Waffles for giving us useless information yet FireNinja has yet to share anything worthy of reading.
If you're just going to act desperate, then do it right.

It is actually useless (for us huehuehue) and he hasn't contribute at all all he did was FOSing player idiots in game.

Shoutout for beary for posting in irc!!
[08:55] <beary509> Godammit FireNinja makes me facedesk

 

[FireNinja1]

beary509 was known to be a village idiot, by not just me, but by many, from her performance in previous games. As we all know, she casted her suspicions on me. Then she was killed, and now there is a 99% chance that you have suspicions on me. I would like to point out that her post against me was not backed up with sufficient evidence, and was merely telling everyone that she thought of me as suspicious. Mafia, in my understanding at least, are not to be aggressive, rather, be more agreeing. And it has shown true that I am being aggressive this game.

 

[Blu Rose]

Alrighty, so who should we bring up for lynch today? I notice Trundle and Waffles mentioned. I can totally understand Waffles. Why Trundle though? I mean, there was Superpenguin's post on nominating Trundle for lynch, which he backed off of soon after. Should we still go off of that for Trundle?

Oath, please explain, defending for Trundle.

 

[EpicGamer12]

beary509 was known to be a village idiot, by not just me, but by many, from her performance in previous games. As we all know, she casted her suspicions on me. Then she was killed, and now there is a 99% chance that you have suspicions on me. I would like to point out that her post against me was not backed up with sufficient evidence, and was merely telling everyone that she thought of me as suspicious. Mafia, in my understanding at least, are not to be aggressive, rather, be more agreeing. And it has shown true that I am being aggressive this game.

*Trundle's ghost arises*
You look like the village idiot now, not just to me, but to many
*oooooohhhh*

 

[Beary]

*Trundle's ghost arises*
You look like the village idiot now, not just to me, but to many
*oooooohhhh*

WHOOOOOO

I agreee whoooooo
Don't call me an idiot whoooooo

*vanishes*

 

[Chris]

Oi, ghosties, be gone. Shoo!

 

[FireNinja1]

*Trundle's ghost arises*
You look like the village idiot now, not just to me, but to many
*oooooohhhh*

To many, incl. myself.

 

[oath2order]

Oath, please explain, defending for Trundle.

That's not a defense? That's me asking "should we go after him or Waffles, which is a better lynch candidate?"

And that post was made before I had some IRC chats which definitely changed my position on him.

 

[Blu Rose]

That's not a defense? That's me asking "should we go after him or Waffles, which is a better lynch candidate?"

And that post was made before I had some IRC chats which definitely changed my position on him.

Oh. I should probably go on IRC more often. I really need to consider doing that...

 

[oath2order]

Oh. I should probably go on IRC more often. I really need to consider doing that...

Eh, they were private chats anyways.