Mafia TBT Newbie Mini Mafia II: On The Run (Game Over/Town Win)

[fairyring]

hi dears! been gathering my thoughts here haha. i did choose to stay in because i hate not finishing things i've started. i apologize if i'm a little slow but now that mean girls mafia has ended i can focus on the remaining two i'm in and not be so busy haha.

anyway! doing a bit of agreeing here but one huge thing i noticed is that crazy-gamer seems to avoid creating any opinions of their own, and doesn't even really try to restate opinions in their own way. they just latch on to whatever opinion is popular at the time and go "i agree with this" or just state the same opinion everyone else has had. to be fair, though, they also did a fair amount of that in mean girls mafia, though no one called them out on it in that one. i can't tell if they're just not a strong player, or if they're trying purposefully to blend in so hard that it's making them stand out. either way, i will have my eye on crazy-gamer.

honestly though so far no one really sticks out to me. it may be because everyone in this game is basically a newbie and so most people are, well, acting like newbies. xD

- - - Post Merge - - -

to add to my post above, i also do not believe aerious and moron acted scummy by pushing so hard for a murray lynch. if anything i would look at some of the people who pushed but didn't push AS hard since mafia would be trying not to make themselves noticed this early on.

 

[Crazy-Gamer]

hi dears! been gathering my thoughts here haha. i did choose to stay in because i hate not finishing things i've started. i apologize if i'm a little slow but now that mean girls mafia has ended i can focus on the remaining two i'm in and not be so busy haha.

anyway! doing a bit of agreeing here but one huge thing i noticed is that crazy-gamer seems to avoid creating any opinions of their own, and doesn't even really try to restate opinions in their own way. they just latch on to whatever opinion is popular at the time and go "i agree with this" or just state the same opinion everyone else has had. to be fair, though, they also did a fair amount of that in mean girls mafia, though no one called them out on it in that one. i can't tell if they're just not a strong player, or if they're trying purposefully to blend in so hard that it's making them stand out. either way, i will have my eye on crazy-gamer.

honestly though so far no one really sticks out to me. it may be because everyone in this game is basically a newbie and so most people are, well, acting like newbies. xD

- - - Post Merge - - -

to add to my post above, i also do not believe aerious and moron acted scummy by pushing so hard for a murray lynch. if anything i would look at some of the people who pushed but didn't push AS hard since mafia would be trying not to make themselves noticed this early on.

i not a big fan of shareing on my opinions

 

[Geoni]

Sharing your opinion is part of mafia. If you don't learn how to do it you won't learn how to play Mafia.

Anyways, I know Pom is active because she just posted some delicious looking bread on my profile, but I haven't seen her speaking up here. She seems to have a lot of avoidance in her activity so far. I still don't want to take my eyes off the other three I listed previously, but right now Pom is the one that is beginning to stand out.

 

[Capella]

Are you suspecting me because of this post

Yeah isn't that sus

Aerious and Moron were pushing Murray and look who died today.

I do agree it was impulsive of me, but it sounded logical at the time.

- - - Post Merge - - -

btw u just got breaded!!!!

 

[Geoni]

You're not defending yourself with a lot of effort. You're still first sus on my list for that and other reasons. The other reasons being your inactivity/lurking and this post:

It's scummy that moron left out a detail that I had to correct?

There's still an undertone of you feeling threatened in this post.

 

[Crazy-Gamer]

Sharing your opinion is part of mafia. If you don't learn how to do it you won't learn how to play Mafia.

Anyways, I know Pom is active because she just posted some delicious looking bread on my profile, but I haven't seen her speaking up here. She seems to have a lot of avoidance in her activity so far. I still don't want to take my eyes off the other three I listed previously, but right now Pom is the one that is beginning to stand out.

oj i know how to i just dont

is best to agree eveyone or at lest me

 

[Capella]

You're not defending yourself with a lot of effort. You're still first sus on my list for that and other reasons. The other reasons being your inactivity/lurking and this post:



There's still an undertone of you feeling threatened in this post.

I wasn't trying to sound threatened.
And this is kinda of an off topic question for you moron but have you played mafia games outside of tbt?

 

[Geoni]

Mhm!

- - - Post Merge - - -

This and frozen are my first forum mafias though.

 

[Capella]

Mhm!

ok I knew it because your play style is really good for a noob

 

[Geoni]

Since this is a must lynch game and somebody is going to have to take the rope, I went ahead and voted for Pom, as my suspicions have only grown. The others I'm suspicious of I'm a little unsure about.

 

[Aerious]

Since this is a must lynch game and somebody is going to have to take the rope, I went ahead and voted for Pom, as my suspicions have only grown. The others I'm suspicious of I'm a little unsure about.

From what I've read I'm also highly suspicious of Pom at the moment.

- - - Post Merge - - -

My placeholder vote will be for her until anyone else seems sus.

 

[in-a-pickle]

It's a simple deduction, we gotta consider everything and that is a possibility. I'm not saying it is or isn't true, I don't have all the cold hard facts (As does anyone), but it isn't wrong of anyone to entertain the idea.

I dunno, shinkuzame's relaxed back-ground play style seems a bit scummy to me. especially since reverse-reverse psychology clearly is confusing everybody.

- - - Post Merge - - -

so...that's really my main sus for now. until further evidence shows up :/

 

[Capella]

From what I've read I'm also highly suspicious of Pom at the moment.

- - - Post Merge - - -

My placeholder vote will be for her until anyone else seems sus.

Can you explain to me on why I sound sus?

 

[Kammeh]

Can you explain to me on why I sound sus?

I looked through your posts, and I have to agree with the others, you DO sound suspicious. You haven't really made a decent attempt at defending yourself, and instead try and change the subject whenever someone gets suspicious of you.
I'ma hop on the bandwagon and vote Pom for lynch as well.

 

[Crazy-Gamer]

AHHHHGGG i hate voteing for friends
i guess i will vote for pom as a placeholder

 

[Capella]

Read this before voting for me

I looked through your posts, and I have to agree with the others, you DO sound suspicious. You haven't really made a decent attempt at defending yourself, and instead try and change the subject whenever someone gets suspicious of you.
I'ma hop on the bandwagon and vote Pom for lynch as well.

You want my defense ?
I'll go over my posts and give some thoughts

Post number one ​

Yeah isn't that sus

Aerious and Moron were pushing Murray and look who died today.

The main reason on why you guys think I'm scum no?
I briefly stated before, it was rash and quite foolish of me to do so, but at the time it seemed like the best option.
I see now that it was obliviously a mistake for doing so, as moron pointed out.
If it was a mafia kill on Murray they tried and failed to get Aerious or Moron lynched.

Post 2
​

It's scummy that moron left out a detail that I had to correct?

I didn't mean for this post to come off as harmful, I was just not sure how to phrase it, sorry.
I was just trying to ask crystal a question
Okay so the changing the topic thing.
I was just very curious on whether moron has played other games because he seemed he has, not trying to change the topic
I should have vm'd but tina said no outside thread communications.

- - - Post Merge - - -

omg sorry about the edit i accidentally hit enter

 

[Lio Fotia]

Sorry Pom, I love you, but you do seem very sus to me, so I'm sorry I jumped on the bandwagon on this one, but I have to agree with the others. ;; Pls forgive me.​

 

[Capella]

Sorry Pom, I love you, but you do seem very sus to me, so I'm sorry I jumped on the bandwagon on this one, but I have to agree with the others. ;; Pls forgive me.​

omg did my defense post do nothing

- - - Post Merge - - -

is my defense that bad

 

[epona]

lot of bandwagoning again, it seems
i'm voting for C r y s t a l

- - - Post Merge - - -

also, aerious, i'm going to ask again as you avoided the question the first time: how do you know Crazy-Gamer is town-aligned? the amount of bandwagoning they are doing, even still after we warned them it was suspicious, isn't exactly helping their case

 

[gnoixaim]

Holy crap, look at all the bandwagon votes. LOOOL.

I would really like for someone to explain why Pom is so suspicious? (I feel like I'm missing something)

Crazy-Gamer - WHERE IS YOUR COACH? Like seriously.......I don't think your coach would leave you this helpless.
JellofishXD voted for themselves, so I'm pretty sure they're town. I think if they were mafia, they would try harder vs. voting for themselves.

Anyways, I'll be voting for shinkuzame. I feel like they've just been posting enough to slide right through everyone. They haven't contributed anything useful and have been pretty wishy-washy of bringing any new names up other than Moron/Aerious.