Mafia TBT Nub Mafia IV: Hijinks in Sugar Rush (Game Over/Third Party Win)

[Pathetic]

Hello lovely people!
I'm still playing Siren's Call mafia so I might be a litttlee quiet at the start, reading the thread now. =)

- - - Post Merge - - -

I say we should lynch Crazy Gamer, in-a-pickle, or ryan88
Not so much Ryan, as he really needs practice in nub mafia.

 

[ryan88]

Hello lovely people!
I'm still playing Siren's Call mafia so I might be a litttlee quiet at the start, reading the thread now. =)

- - - Post Merge - - -

I say we should lynch Crazy Gamer, in-a-pickle, or ryan88
Not so much Ryan, as he really needs practice in nub mafia.

why? i'm one of the more active ones in nub mafia

 

[Axeler137]

Hello lovely people!
I'm still playing Siren's Call mafia so I might be a litttlee quiet at the start, reading the thread now. =)

- - - Post Merge - - -

I say we should lynch Crazy Gamer, in-a-pickle, or ryan88
Not so much Ryan, as he really needs practice in nub mafia.

Any reasoning behind those three? Or just because?

 

[skaro]

The only person who seems suspicious to me so far is dalandanator. He's really emphasizing the fact that he's a townie. I still think we should give it more time before we lynch, though.

 

[Capella]

Anyways, there are quite a few that haven't posted yet. I'm not sure if some remember they even signed up for the game. We can go about voting 2 ways, look at game tactics from previous players that HAVE played mafia and evaluate from there OR lynch an inactive (which tends to be always townie, but an inactive townie is a useless townie). As of now, I'll be looking up previous games of some players and decide from there : )

okay for the people that haven't posted yet,

I think crazy forgot about this game tbh, but they haven't been on since the 29th so eh. I know callaway and in-a-pickle are busy irl, but idk about kawaii cupcakes and cherry blossoms, they're active elsewhere so they probs forgot about this game too. If plan A doesn't work out then yeah we should lynch an inactive :/

&& if mafia really believed that I was townie, why would they vote me off or kill me? Wouldn't they want to eliminate people with more important roles such as healers or detectives?
.

So they can get rid of a player on the opposite team, and get day over with.

 

[Saylor]

If crazy-gamer, callaway and in-a-pickle are busy or forgot about the game then they might get modkilled eventually so if we decide to lynch an inactive I think it should be one that's just posting the bare minimum rather than one that won't show up at all.

 

[Axeler137]

If crazy-gamer, callaway and in-a-pickle are busy or forgot about the game then they might get modkilled eventually so if we decide to lynch an inactive I think it should be one that's just posting the bare minimum rather than one that won't show up at all.

I would have to agree with this. If they forgot about this game, then let's pray that they will either remember to play or they don't have an important role. I'd rather lynch someone that is being more suspicious than being inactive.

 

[f11]

Guys day just started. I think we should wait before we lynch them. I find it weird how alise says we should lunch those people without caring if they are blue or townie.

 

[Capella]

Not so much Ryan, as he really needs practice in nub mafia.

Um everyone needs practice, that shouldn't be a reason for not lynching him.

i'm one of the more active ones in nub mafia

Debatable

 

[Zigzag991]

Guess things are starting to pick up! I have to go to the movies so I won't be back for another 3 and a half hours or so. As for lynching, I think Dalandanator is acting a little wonky, so I'll have to agree that we should keep an eye on him.

 

[Axeler137]

Not so much Ryan, as he really needs practice in nub mafia.

This should not exclude him from the possibility of being a suspect. I'm sure scum isn't going to be easy on newbies just because they need practice.

 

[ryan88]

I'm not a newbie. I have played many games. With me playing sirens call I will be there most of the time.

 

[Capella]

I'm not a newbie. I have played many games. With me playing sirens call I will be there most of the time.

You sure act like a newbie, in every game you've played in almost all of your posts have been one liners, and you always bandwagon. Just because you've played more games doesn't mean anything. Sorry if this sounds harsh :/ (lol i know this is hypocritical but w/e)

 

[Mahoushoujo]

can i obs or is it too late ogod

 

[Oldcatlady]

So they can get rid of a player on the opposite team, and get day over with.

That makes no sense to me. If I was a mafia member, I'd vote off anyone besides a newbie claiming to be a townie. That's a role that doesn't help much especially if they're new and isn't familiar with everything yet.
There are roles more important they could try to get rid of first. A newbie townie might even get a false lead and accidentally vote off someone with a better role, such as detective, since they don't get any clues aside from observing what other people say.

 

[Pathetic]

This should not exclude him from the possibility of being a suspect. I'm sure scum isn't going to be easy on newbies just because they need practice.

A reminder that this a nub mafia, scum WILL be easy on the newbies. This is for nubs.

 

[gnoixaim]

okay for the people that haven't posted yet,

I think crazy forgot about this game tbh, but they haven't been on since the 29th so eh. I know callaway and in-a-pickle are busy irl, but idk about kawaii cupcakes and cherry blossoms, they're active elsewhere so they probs forgot about this game too. If plan A doesn't work out then yeah we should lynch an inactive :/

Kawaii Cupcakes and cherry-blossoms have been VERY active in other parts of the forum and forgetting they signed up is a pretty bad excuse. If either of you see this, please state your opinions of what we should do for Day 1. Should we lynch an inactive? Who do you find suspicious? What's your reason for not posting in the game?

 

[dalandanator]

Probably busy irl, or scum too scared to give away too much or just plain forgot. In which case just let them get modkilled for inactivity.

 

[Oldcatlady]

Kawaii Cupcakes and cherry-blossoms have been VERY active in other parts of the forum and forgetting they signed up is a pretty bad excuse. If either of you see this, please state your opinions of what we should do for Day 1. Should we lynch an inactive? Who do you find suspicious? What's your reason for not posting in the game?

A friendly reminder for them (if anyone sees them in other parts of the forums) to post if they don't want to be lynched might be good? It is possible that they did forget about the game.
Newbies scum tend to just avoid posting, and vote for whoever has the most votes from my experience in mafia games on other websites (I did that too the first time I was a bad guy... XD) So the less active people are definitely on my suspicion list.
I would also look people who post too carefully. Not sure if this is going to work though since there's no edit option.

 

[Capella]

That makes no sense to me. If I was a mafia member, I'd vote off anyone besides a newbie claiming to be a townie. That's a role that doesn't help much especially if they're new and isn't familiar with everything yet.
There are roles more important they could try to get rid of first. A newbie townie might even get a false lead and accidentally vote off someone with a better role, such as detective, since they don't get any clues aside from observing what other people say.

You lynch a newbie by day, kill off the good people/people with an action at night. That's how scum won in, Cell mafia, Olympus mafia,Sunleth mafia, and portal mafia.
It's easier for scum to lynch a newbie because they don't know how to properly defend themselves and scum knows that the newbies will bandwagon on the other newbie getting lynched. It's gonna be hard for them to lynch an experienced player because they know how to form their own opinions and properly defend themselves. Like in portal maf, when all the experienced players were dead they just sat back and watched the newbies lynch fellow town members. In sunleth there was a mass claim so it was easy for scum to pick off the important roles.

Does this make sense? ;_____;