Ok, so Ness:? Vengeful Granny
Questions:
1.Why was he acting so trolly earlier, like he wanted to be lynched?
2.Why did he claim after I asked for someone to shoot him?
3. Is a Jester/other scummy role still in question?
4. Why Daniel?
1.Why was he acting so trolly earlier, like he wanted to be lynched?
I can think of three reasons: he's either flat out scum refusing to cooperate, he wants to use his Granny powers, or he's reaction testing. But if he's reaction testing, why hasn't he said anything to that effect? He flat out claimed instead of claiming his intention of reaction testing, which is something I can't see him doing, either. Ness isn't THAT bad of a player, so I don't think he'd outright act like an idiot like that. So I'm thinking he probably wanted to be lynched to confirm his ability to be unlynchable (and kill someone)? And if it's to kill someone outright like that, then why isn't he getting any other opinions if he's going to basically waste a freaking lynch and kill someone who may or may not be town? This wouldn't confirm him as town, as there's been mafian Grannies before. And hell, Vengeful Granny? That sounds like it could be a 3rd party in of itself. Plus, his actions in of themselves aren't very town-like. He's disrupting all of chat and being as obtrusive as possible. There's also the possibility that he's attracting attention so we think he's Jester so we leave him alone, but I just don't think he'd do that, knowing his meta.
2. Why did he claim after I asked for someone to shoot him?
Well, the obvious one here is that he wants to stay alive. And if he's a Granny like he claims, then well, he'd still die that night.
3. Is a Jester/other scummy role still in question?
I'd believe the Granny claim. He seemed so cocky in the face of a lynch, making me think he is actually unlynchable. And he tried way too hard to attract attention to himself to make me think he was any other scum role. Jester... maybe. He looks like he's kind of trying to save his skin now though, when night becomes part of the conversation, which I guess involves Jester too. So in short, I'd say Jester is still a possibility. I really, really don't see him as any other scum role though. It just doesn't fit his meta, as I've previously explained.
4. Why Daniel?
My guess is that he just picked him out of no where cause there wasn't much suspicion being thrown at Daniel and Daniel is generally considered as an "easy" lynch, making it look suspicious that he's doing anything for that.
Conclusion: He wanted to look scummy. If he's telling the truth that he's Granny, then it's because he wanted to potentially kill someone using his power. If it's the Jester thing, he wants to win. Either way, I think lynching him is a bad idea. But I think considering his motives, and what he's wanting to do as Granny (and why he's doing what he's doing), I think he's a scum version of Granny. I think having someone shoot Ness would still be a great idea.
