Mafia TBT Scummy Award Mafia Game - End Game #justicewasright

[Sataric]

to all of u questioning my post, aside from his claim, is there anything at all that makes you think ness is town?

Yes - I have a feeling that he's simply not fully capable of going "full ham" with such anger and ferocity if it's all a ruse in the end, with the purpose of simply bamboozling us. Of course, it is dangerous to underestimate someone, but in the end there's other people I find far more suspicious that I'd rather vote for.

Speaking of which, how much time is left until the day ends?

 

[Blu Rose]

to all of u questioning my post, aside from his claim, is there anything at all that makes you think ness is town?

um yeah his brashness, but sat already said that so
whatever i was totally wrong in got so screw me

Most scummy thing posted in the entire game thus far. How come noone reacted to this? I am very much inclined to put my vote onto Blu Rose for that comment.

hey sataric
day 1 lynches rarely ever matter <3

 

[EnderWiggin]

to all of u questioning my post, aside from his claim, is there anything at all that makes you think ness is town?

Genuine pettiness.

Also I just don't get the scum vibe.tm

 

[Trojan]

Why do you need to be a veteran if you kill whoever targets you at night?

His role makes no sense and he should be lynched

 

[mother of all llamas]

Sorry, I haven't gotten the chance to read what's happened so far, I'll do so during/after school.

 

[Arstotzkan]

You/Trundle/Blu

Reasons?

Yes - I have a feeling that he's simply not fully capable of going "full ham" with such anger and ferocity if it's all a ruse in the end, with the purpose of simply bamboozling us. Of course, it is dangerous to underestimate someone, but in the end there's other people I find far more suspicious that I'd rather vote for.

Speaking of which, how much time is left until the day ends?

He is capable. Take a look at DA:I mafia for example. He and Panda were at each other's throats the whole game, and he was still mafia.

@Blu How do D1 lynches not matter? They're what the rest of the game is based off of, reads wise.
@Trojan I wouldn't imagine you would have to. Granny's inherit thing is they kill people who visit them.

 

[Byngo]

Yes - I have a feeling that he's simply not fully capable of going "full ham" with such anger and ferocity if it's all a ruse in the end, with the purpose of simply bamboozling us. Of course, it is dangerous to underestimate someone, but in the end there's other people I find far more suspicious that I'd rather vote for.

Speaking of which, how much time is left until the day ends?

day ends in 7 hours

 

[Sataric]

Since I am a little unsure of when the day will end, I will put down my vote for Blu Rose for now. However, I am willing to change it later on if necessary. Not too confident in the Ness lynch though, personally. Is that really the only option we're considering? I think I'd rather go for Trojan, unless he makes me pancakes, in which case he's okay in my book!

- - - Post Merge - - -

day ends in 7 hours

Oh, thanks!

 

[Trojan]

BUT BUT HOW IS HE VETERAN?? YOU WOULDNT NEED VET AS A GRANNY

 

[Arstotzkan]

Just gonna throw this out there - Ender's play comes off as really lazy to me. He's made what? 2 actual posts? The rest of his posts were playful banter at the beginning and talking about the nature of the roles we have. I'd chalk it up to him just not being here at the right times, but he has hopped in periodically to say things like: "Great thread. I rate it 1/10" and "Me rn". And when I ask him to contribute, he does basically the least amount possible and just lists names without reasons. And he's the guy at the end of GOT mafia that said you have to have reasons behind all of your accusations. All 4 of his reads have been either unsubstantiated or justified as "I'm not getting a scummy gut feeling". My guess is that he's non-killing 3rd party. But it's frustrating none the less.

- - - Post Merge - - -

BUT BUT HOW IS HE VETERAN?? YOU WOULDNT NEED VET AS A GRANNY

He has two night lives. So if someone shot him, he'd still live, but the shot would still go through nonetheless.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Since I am a little unsure of when the day will end, I will put down my vote for Blu Rose for now. However, I am willing to change it later on if necessary. Not too confident in the Ness lynch though, personally. Is that really the only option we're considering? I think I'd rather go for Trojan, unless he makes me pancakes, in which case he's okay in my book!

- - - Post Merge - - -



Oh, thanks!

I definitely agree that Blu Rose's nonchalant attitude about D1 is really scummy. But I can't not ignore Ness's early D1 play being 100% counterproductive without any reason.

Idk, I'm getting a townie read on Trojan, but I generally can't read trolls for **** so augh. Trying to compare his play to different games I've been with him and am trying to think of how he compares.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Yeah his role really doesn't add up. I am keeping my vote on Ness, and if he isn't scum, we get him and Trojan or CMD, both equally great early deaths regardless of your alignment.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Waait. Just realized my logic was wrong. I came to the conclusion before that he was trying to get lynched, so if he was given Granny, the only way he'd want to be lynched is if that's his wincon. And in which case... That would be a seriously ****ed up win con. A vengeful Granny sounds like someone who'd be apart of a mafia or town (because of the ability to take someone out if lynched), and in which case, his actions earlier would make more sense as town ****ing around than as scum, since scum would never want to attract that much attention to themselves.

ABORT ABORT.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Unless he's lying about Granny in the first place...

Augh, **** me

 

[Damniel]

Like if you think ness's claim makes 0 sense.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Like if you think this whole damn thread makes 0 sense.

- - - Post Merge - - -

You know what? No. His role seems pretty stupidly OP, but I trust it. Vengeful Granny that's consistent with the roles given out on TBT rather than the TBT mafia wiki seems a little too hard to BS, especially considering there's only ever been 3 grannies. And the fact that he'd be able to incorporate the vengeful part... I guess he could have done research, but I doubt it. Seems like a pretty damn complicated role unless he was handed the fakeclaim, and unless he'd be apart of the mafia, I doubt he'd receive a fakeclaim in the first place. I'm unvoting Ness for now.

@Anyone who's been a 3rd party on TBT: Did you get a safeclaim with your role?

 

[Trojan]

This is just as bad as Trundle last game. I'm just gonna leave and check back when he gets lynched

 

[EpicGamer12]

Like if you think this whole damn thread makes 0 sense.

- - - Post Merge - - -

You know what? No. His role seems pretty stupidly OP, but I trust it. Vengeful Granny that's consistent with the roles given out on TBT rather than the TBT mafia wiki seems a little too hard to BS, especially considering there's only ever been 3 grannies. And the fact that he'd be able to incorporate the vengeful part... I guess he could have done research, but I doubt it. Seems like a pretty damn complicated role unless he was handed the fakeclaim, and unless he'd be apart of the mafia, I doubt he'd receive a fakeclaim in the first place. I'm unvoting Ness for now.

@Anyone who's been a 3rd party on TBT: Did you get a safeclaim with your role?

3rd party roles rarely get safe claims unless they are a team, but it varies from host to host

 

[glow]

Don't you guys think that if Ness was scum he'd be more in the background or trying harder to push someone else? like it seems as if he's just given up because he's frustrated. And if he was scum why would he claim such a ridiculous role, it'd be so much more believable to simply claim Granny.

so these are the possibilities, he's being:

1. bad town. he's not lying, was trolling 2 b funny and then when everyone was like wtf ru doing, he just backed himself into a corner
2. worse scum. he's lying and slipped majorly??? on purpose? idk I honestly don't think this is that likely. Ness isn't a bad player and I doubt he would be so obvious. although I have not looked into previous games when he was scum
3. third party?? where his wincon is being lynched or something idek

imo the 1st seems the most likely given that he was pushing Daniel in the beginning so id assume he was reaction testing. I just think if he was scum he'd be more likely to lay low and not bring so much attention to himself. anyway although some of his actions don't scream town, to me it seems like he just got emotional. so I won't be voting him. I'd rather vote someone that's kind of skating by even though they're usually strong/aggressive players. namely, Ender. I'll be looking more into him rn, I'm on mobile at work so I only have enough time to write this for now, sry

 

[Blu Rose]

@Blu How do D1 lynches not matter? They're what the rest of the game is based off of, reads wise.

that's what is posted day 1, not day 1 lynch--the lynch itself usually doesn't matter

 

[N e s s]

I'm probably going to be killing Trojan or CMD, unless someone has a request.

Yeah his role really doesn't add up. I am keeping my vote on Ness, and if he isn't scum, we get him and Trojan or CMD, both equally great early deaths regardless of your alignment.

You really don't need to be condescending.

 

[glow]

what time does day end?