-
Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.
Mafia The Hunger Games Mafia - Game Thread - Endgame - Mafia + Survivor Win
- Thread starter cornimer
- Start date
Ghostkid
the Ghostkidliest guy
Q and As from Gavin starts now ask me anything about the game, how my day went, about that Regice i just caught anything really. But id think itd be best for Vanessa's sake to ask about the game.
Nah, I think that I have a good handle on how Ness and Toads would each want things
- - - Post Merge - - -
I do want a justification from you on why you think that Rune is SK, or at least why you thinkhe's not telling the truth
- - - Post Merge - - -
Where did Calamity 180?
MapleSilver
Frost Egg Collector
Right now I'm most comfortable with a Rune lynch.
1. He's telling the truth, so his death is neutral to town.
2. He's lying and is scum, so his death is beneficial.
3. He's lying and he's town. Would a town player ever want to do that though?
1. He's telling the truth, so his death is neutral to town.
2. He's lying and is scum, so his death is beneficial.
3. He's lying and he's town. Would a town player ever want to do that though?
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
He didn't, I didnt read the thread at that time
Why are you going after Rune so hard ? What is your thought process there to insist that he get lynched right away ?
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
you mean to tell me that you said cal said something without even reading the thread, to see if he actually did say what you said he said?!
- - - Post Merge - - -
and now silver wants rune gone. I usually agree with his reasoning on TPs but I am not comfortable with rune becoming a unity lynch and thus an easy way for scum to blend in. Something feels really fishy about the whole thing
MapleSilver
Frost Egg Collector
Who do you sus the most currently?
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
I WAS HUNGRY DON'T JUDGE MY MOTIVES
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
Antonio is the most sus for me atm
- - - Post Merge - - -
I hope you realize how incredibly scummy it is to say someone did something without even bothering to read if they did or not. No matter how hungry you might be, I will definitely judge your motives in this case
though the fact you just openly stated it makes me wonder...hmmm is this another Punchy the Time Bomb Veteran like play??
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Antonio is the most sus for me atm
- - - Post Merge - - -
View attachment 216375
I hope you realize how incredibly scummy it is to say someone did something without even bothering to read if they did or not. No matter how hungry you might be, I will definitely judge your motives in this case
though the fact you just openly stated it makes me wonder...hmmm is this another Punchy the Time Bomb Veteran like play??
May I ask for you reason why you think I'm scum?
Is it because I'm talking about Rune? I have stated my opinion on him, and I do think his reasons for claiming early had no point because 1) He acting out of pure paranoia because he was worried dolby of reading him so he claimed which in the end should leave him vulnerable to Mafia because he stated he would work to benefit town. 2) Now, I get that everyone said that it's unlikely scum would claim as their first message especially with an orange role but it's an amazing tactic to do because no one would expect it. He played 5 (I think) serious games so either he realized that this isn't something mafia would do or he didn't know well and believe claiming would be his best benefit. Plus, claiming this early especially stating he would help the town side means some people may not lynch him because of the unlikeness of this situation therefore having a greater chance to meet his win condition.
I do not believe he should by lynched though, at least not now anyways. I would rather see how mafia handle him in Night 1 since he is an obvious threat to them. If he's not lynched, he's either mafia or mafia is keeping him aside for day 2 lynch. I'm not 100% sure whether or not he is telling the truth but due to the unlikeness of him claiming with a illogical reason (basic paranoia led to his claim as stated above), I am leaning on the "he's lying" side of thing. I do believe his actions are polite though and I don't have a full grasp on my opinion of Rune so state that he is either Town or Scum.
That's well stated.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I am also reading everyone, with one person in particular besides rune. Everyone at the moment is Null for me.
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
holy mother of overreactions
well I felt like your pressure on rune was opportunistic and very poorly reasoned. Like, there's reasons to be skeptical of TP claims, but your continued insistence in the face of well-reasoned opposition shows me you may have an agenda beyond just getting rid of rune. Perhaps you wish to distract us from your teammate(s) by focusing on rune so much. Idk. Whatever it is, yes, I think you're sketch because of how you have handled rune and your interactions with some people, particularly punchy.
also I love how you are "reading everyone else" ...as null
like I know it's day 1 but seriously? you oughta have at least SOME idea of who you think is town and scum at this point
Antonio do you have any thoughts on the other players asking for Rune to be lynched ? Specifically Punchy & CalamityBot ?
MapleSilver's reply is really structured and pretty much repetition .. but would he join the bandwagon this late ?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Wouldnhe join the bandwagon this late if he were Mafia * because it's making him stand out.
MapleSilver's reply is really structured and pretty much repetition .. but would he join the bandwagon this late ?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Wouldnhe join the bandwagon this late if he were Mafia * because it's making him stand out.
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Calamity: Nope, nothing at the moment.
Punchy: He's the person I'm reading more than Rune. I need him to post a lot more before I can state my reason why because it would mess things up.
Also, I'm not trying to be all about Rune. Usually when playing mafia, I don't intend to but I focus on a particular person (Fire, Punchy, etc in past games) because well...I'm not sure. Maybe because I have an opinion that I think they are this alignment that I strongly believe is credible therefore I state it often.
@Amazon I believe other people were on Rune before I was so opportunistic might not be best word or at least IMO.
Anyways, I'm going to go eat my microwaved Jamaican beef patties because I'm hungry
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
so the reason that I was sus of rune is that I asked Dolby about balancing, and he said that an SK should only be put into a game of 15 players or more. I thought that that's why Vanessa insisted on having a 15 player game. Ofc Ness could have said something similar, but I highly doubt that.
brian is that u buddy
ooof : ( i hope u feel beter soom
