Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER

[ribbitribbon]

King kills are like any other kill, they can be blocked/redirected/etc

with that in mind i did a quick glance at shiny’s posts and found no real mafia reads from them, but they definitely did soft looking back so imo the mafia killed them rather than their ability.

What is PR?

power role, i.e. a role with an ability versus a normal villager

 

[Jacob4]

heading to sleep since its almost 1am for me, working 8:30-5:30 tomorrow but ill try to play / solve when I can throughout so im not completely dead and back fully tomorrow night

gn

 

[Gabby]

with that in mind i did a quick glance at shiny’s posts and found no real mafia reads from them, but they definitely did soft looking back so imo the mafia killed them rather than their ability.

power role, i.e. a role with an ability versus a normal villager

Thank you. What do you think of people thinking you are mafia?

 

[Jacob4]

What is PR?

power role, basically a role that has abilities of some kind

 

[Damniel]

I'm not gonna give minus points to tessa for killing chris (assuming that was their kill) tbh because I also thought it was an alright kill, I feel like PRs tend to look kinda wolfy to me lol

this was tessa's pool of possible king kills:

"i think chris, annika maybe? i trust volt, ribbit, or oath if i'm feeling really spicy"

chris was town, annika imo is town based on my meta for them (more on this later), oath imo feels towny for how they were so anti being king and also how they were joking about dying felt like they didn't really care about dying which is imo a towny trait

so i think if there are wolves here it'd be in volt and ribbit

could be that both of them are wolves, but if not (and probability dictates they're probably not both wolves) then that's either 4 or 5 town there

given that I think it's likely that at least 1 of the wolves would be voting for tessa yesterday regardless of tessa alignment

voters on tessa: annika, Damniel, N e s s, ribbitribbon, Jacob4

don't think me and annika are wolves so would leave with at least 1 in {Damniel, N e s s, ribbitribbon}

eh that didnt really narrow it down as much as id like to have, but i think it'll be a good approach to find town / mafia in that pool cause i do think it's greater than random chance that pool contains wolves tbh

Out of those I'd probably lean on damniel being the towniest but i havent really substantiated those thoughts in my head rn just kinda gut feels based on the posts ive seen from him

I think this is a solid attempt at analyzing the Tessa votes. However Ribbit voted for Tessa who in turn considered killing them so I'm not sure if a maf Ribbit would do this. I'm not as convinced on the Annika being town as you seem to be

 

[EpicGamer12]

King kills are like any other kill, they can be blocked/redirected/etc

Some clarification on this:
The King action cannot be altered by other PR actions. It always goes through on the intended target. But the kill itself is treated like any other kill, where it could potentially be protected against, etc.
I apologize for the confusion.

 

[Damniel]

Im really hoping Geoni goes in today bc if not that's a slot I can't do any type of reading on

 

[tessa grace]

I suppose Christ townreading Arstotzkan makes sense with that revealed

how come?

I think Volt had one of the more sus EODs. While there were players confused and didn't know what to do, it felt like Volt was okay with how everything was turning out (probably given Chris was the likely kill from Tessa). I didn't like their commentary on how it was our fault for not organizing the king wagons but they felt distant and not proactive in the thread the whole time. I think we were too quick to town read them and this slot needs to be looked into

adding on to this, can we please get more consensus and discussion !! i understand d1 is hard for all but some of the ideas surrounding king feel sooo anti town to me, namely just giving it to them and seeing what happens.

Sorry for my inactivity. This game started right when I was going to be on a trip for the weekend. I'm now back and ready to rock. Who's gonna be king?

GABBY REDEMPTION I KNEW I COULD SAVE HER

tessa doesnt have anything to respond for the kill of a pr because everyone mooted chris

weird comment because nobody had brought that up

Tessa's pool of people to kill probably contains all town which is why there wasn't much resistance to her being kinged. I don't think mafia felt like they were dying with a Tessa king

man i feel played this really makes me wanna go deepwolf hunting

too lazy to ping your wall but @Jacob4 can you elaborate on how the oath tr is bc of their not wanting to be king

with that in mind i did a quick glance at shiny’s posts and found no real mafia reads from them, but they definitely did soft looking back so imo the mafia killed them rather than their ability.

power role, i.e. a role with an ability versus a normal villager

hi can you explain your d1 pls

 

[ribbitribbon]

Thank you. What do you think of people thinking you are mafia?

np

i’m more concerned at rereading based off of last night’s kills, but i’m hoping i can contribute more today than yday. the only person i saw accusing me today was jacob who’s posts i haven’t paid the most attention too so i’ll keep that in mind.

I think this is a solid attempt at analyzing the Tessa votes. However Ribbit voted for Tessa who in turn considered killing them so I'm not sure if a maf Ribbit would do this. I'm not as convinced on the Annika being town as you seem to be

i would also like the reasoning behind annika being town fypov, but that can wait for later if you’d rather

 

[Damniel]

Annika and Volt are probably not both maf based on Volt sussing Annika when it wouldn't be practical to do so

 

[tessa grace]

Im really hoping Geoni goes in today bc if not that's a slot I can't do any type of reading on

luckily, we don't have to worry about voting ia cos if he doesn't show ip he'll be mod killed

 

[voltairenism]

i dont know ribbit meta at all but i don't think i would discard ribbit just because they voted for tessa. overall ribbit flew under the radar during EoD and i can see the vote being WIFOM-y
but i dont have opinions abt ribbit i need to ISO them. just two cents on this specific point

 

[ribbitribbon]

hi can you explain your d1 pls

what exactly are you asking about my d1?

 

[voltairenism]

weird comment because nobody had brought that up

tired of everyone saying my takes are weird but not saying why

 

[Damniel]

i dont know ribbit meta at all but i don't think i would discard ribbit just because they voted for tessa. overall ribbit flew under the radar during EoD and i can see the vote being WIFOM-y
but i dont have opinions abt ribbit i need to ISO them. just two cents on this specific point

I didn't sense any WIFOM from Ribbit at all

 

[N e s s]

I think ribbit is town tbh. Chris confirmed. Oath leaning yes but maybe not, Tessa wasn't pressing him as much

nahhh fam i dunno about that. The only thing Ribbit has realistically said is that there was a bus going on between me/Tessa/Arstotzkan. Not sure I'm buying their EOD stuff as town or mafia indicative anymore.

Honestly though Ribbit is the only person I have an opinion on at this point, having a hard time reading people.

good grief

did we get an answer if a saving role could save from king kills? since king is invincible it’s entirely possible shiny directed the kill onto themself.

Is this implying that Shiny directed the king kill onto themselves or the mafia kill, because I could buy Shiny protecting someone

 

[tessa grace]

what exactly are you asking about my d1?

i asked several questions d1 that you probably missed. lemme see if i can find them
mostly what are your reads and why

 

[voltairenism]

Annika and Volt are probably not both maf based on Volt sussing Annika when it wouldn't be practical to do so

do you think me turning to chris sounds better? what would that even accomplish?

 

[N e s s]

tired of everyone saying my takes are weird but not saying why

i feel this in my soul, we are two of a kind

 

[voltairenism]

i read it wrong nevermind