voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
voltairenism's Creature:
im ngl i have everyone in my poe. basically only found you and ribbitHow about we all have a little pow-wow, lets calm down and have a reasonable discussion; anyone who is currently considered "suspicious" is welcome to join with their own input if they're so inclined.
View attachment 552783
If we're going to form a "towncore" then we should probably start to think who is realistically the most town here. I made a list on paper lat night of the players that I don't find inherently town and then I narrowed them down to the 5 names below.
I said earlier that one of these 5 has mafia: Oath, Arstotzkan, RibbitRibbon, Volt and Ender. The order of those is in the way that I want them dead. Considering Arstotzkan has a chance of dying no matter what, I reasonably think Oath is the best choice. RibbitRibbon, Volt and Ender all have points that make me think they're town and I'm reluctant to consider them on this list. If not them, then these players need to be considered:
Jacob, Annika, Geoni.
How do we feel about this? Is there a more solid "box" of players that we could create for PoE? I've already outlined why I'm not including my personal TR's on this list.
Post automatically merged:
@Trent the Paladin pspspspspspspspsps
Post automatically merged:
can i analyze this orA wee reminder guys to be aware of your language. The words "lynch" and "scum" are not permitted in TBT Mafia. We haven't issued any warnings thus far as we are aware it has been a good while since any of you have played a mafia game on here, but we might need to crack down if it continues to be a problem. This was a community-motivated change so please do respect it.
(Yes your boy is still following. And yes I've been screaming at my phone screen.)
like should i go back to chris' dan/trent/ness shenanigans
Post automatically merged:
mostly holding on questioning tessa bc shes not active. i think we should keep it that way.yeah i am down to bounce ideas tbh
finding it difficult to come up with reads i believe in tbh as well outside of you being town, more difficult when it's a lot of people you're unfamiliar with since my reads often come from meta lol
kinda lean on tessa being town overall, d1 they did a lot of poking around and trying to get reactions / responses from people (e.g #273, #357, a lot more examples exist tbh but lazy to put here lol) which strikes me as genuine solving and trying to get a read of things, on top of the more assertive tone at points also makes me think they believe what they're saying (e.g. #107 #110 #382). one point that kinda makes me sceptical on tessa though is that she did kill a villager yesterday with the king kill, which don't get me wrong i don't think is inherently a wolfy thing in itself since i think a lot of people would have killed chris in her position, but I'm kinda sceptical that not that many people are speculating it could be her because of that at the same time? I feel like if villager it might be a bit more likely that wolves try and use that point against her today, but im kinda shaky on that reasoning tbh and think my points for tring are stronger
I'm not too sure on oath, initially i thought they could be town cause of their carefree attitude d1, joking around about dying (not seeming to care too much about it), and also resistance to being king came across to me as towny, but in more recent posts they feel kinda... scared? which feels like a p big contrast. I think he is being pushed a bit more tbh so it kinda makes sense if he's a villager but the tonal shift is kinda throwing me off still lol
geoni is a weird one since they only have 2 posts lol, tbh a lot of it felt like filler just talking about mech which feels kinda easy to post as a wolf. wanna see more from them before I place a confident read there but would lean mafia atm
@annika what are your thoughts on my thoughts above?
will go through and iso the others now
Post automatically merged:
actually brb
Last edited: