Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER

[Damniel]

dan i understand it now
you should take your own path i dont mind it. its gonna have its benefits

We have reached elation

 

[Geoni]

what’s your position on electing someone potentially maffy into power?

i don’t think it’s entirely a bad idea because it puts the mafia in a weird position— if they make a bad king kill choice they’ll be subject to accusations tomorrow, where as killing their partner is bad in the long run.

i’m not saying that i want to do that d1, but in the future would you think that’s a bad idea?

Yikes.

 

[voltairenism]

geoni istg

 

[tessa grace]

voting ribbit is just dan with an extra step but i would be fine with it

yes but also i feel like we could learn more with ribbit

Post automatically merged: Apr 10, 2024

(on page 30, giving myself a small break)
I feel like a lot of these posts are taking up space and saying nothing good grief

TY i agree, my brainrot is a little less bad after some homework but the struggle is real

 

[Geoni]

I think that tom stating he'll no kill if made king is towny since that type of thing can be construed as wolf agenda, think wolf would think twice before pushing that tbh

voting shiny for king i feel most confident on them being town atm

Kinda think Jacob was based for wanting to vote for Shiny since they appear to be a newer player

wouldn't go geoni would like to see them at least post before they die

ness feels the wolfiest to me, their method of trying to get people to vote them at the start by being direct with them felt weird, and of the people pushing for king they feel the most uncertain and I feel like town would be more likely to commit to doing it

I'm kinda wavering on my vote on you, I don't feel completely comfortable handing over king to you tbh either, I feel more comfortable handing it to someone who doesn't feel like they're trying to control gamestate

I'm guessing that was why you wanted Shiny over any of your other townreads? We're all trying to control the gamestate whenever we play, or at least people who are decent at the game. Not on board with Ness read though what makes that type of interaction inherently wolfy by itself?

nah never annika please, at least not tonight

I'm p certain they're town and if not I probably find them eventually, I have a confident read there

chris kill seems okish? oath seems kinda town from what i've seen so wouldnt go there

People are like 'no meta guys' but you seem to have meta I'm curious about. Do tell.

scared to lose your mafia partner?

Trying to figure out where this read on Annika came from.

I don't think I'd kill Ribbit. This EOD is a little better

How was it better?

Reached EoD1!!!

 

[tessa grace]

Alright fine I’ll reveal part of my hand: I’m a power role. Sorry for whatever chaos this causes but yall just need to trust me on this I’m so serious.

Making me king would basically guarantee a cleared slot on Day 3, and potentially keep me alive until Day 4. If there’s any amount of overthinking on whether I’m lying, it might not work. But I’d functionally be immune enough to take town into the endgame. For the love of god, take into account what I’ve been saying the last few phases and apply it to my current situation.

No, I won’t take questions on what my action is, I’ll let mafia guess how dangerous I am.

oh!

 

[Damniel]

In before geoni never comments on the current day by eod

Post automatically merged: Apr 10, 2024

what is the council thinking abt tessa so far

Thoughts on Tessa now?

 

[annika]

okay ig I'll vote ness!!

 

[Geoni]

What is PR?

Puerto Rico.

Did your weekend go well? What's your experience with mafia as a game and are you also caught up yet? If you were forced to pick three names for the wolf team and three names for town who would they be?

 

[tessa grace]

k @N e s s whos on your chopping block

i'll look into and iso them and give reads
even if you dont agree with the reads i'll have the quotes pulled up

Post automatically merged: Apr 10, 2024

Puerto Rico.

Did your weekend go well? What's your experience with mafia as a game and are you also caught up yet? If you were forced to pick three names for the wolf team and three names for town who would they be?

nope ender replaced them

 

[Damniel]

Puerto Rico.

Did your weekend go well? What's your experience with mafia as a game and are you also caught up yet? If you were forced to pick three names for the wolf team and three names for town who would they be?

negative point for this

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Puerto Rico.

Did your weekend go well? What's your experience with mafia as a game and are you also caught up yet? If you were forced to pick three names for the wolf team and three names for town who would they be?

LMAO

Convinced at this point Geoni's a power role who's power is review old content like it's currently happening

 

[Damniel]

Instead of using the little time he had to try to make some sort of impact on the game, he’s talking to the long departed

 

[Arstotzkan]

Direct quotes first reactions:

Spoiler

@ Deaths	Chris and Shiny, huh. Interesting. Gut says Shiny was mafia kill, which means they ascribed to the theory that they were too townie in their methods. Might be worth investigating if no one's done so yet.
Common volt maf thoughts	Someone's gonna have to catch me up on this one; it sounds like some stuff from EoD D1?
"maf not dying w/ a Tessa king"	The fact that she went uncontested is less of a condemnation on her wagon and more of a condemnation on the accuracy of Tessa's reads.
"don't think me and annika are wolves"	"the town" (this is a half joke).
tessa pr musing	might be overreacting here but am looking at how only one of the deaths (hers) was mentioned when there was a loss of two PRs last night - you'd think that'd exasperate the concerns rather than just focusing on the one she pointed at
post #505	Don't like how the wagon/analysis of the wagon/dan approving the wagon was basically a call/response between Dan and Jacob. It's nothing I can point to with a solid finger (purely gut/intuition), but I have not gotten anything from Dan that has given me any warm fuzzies all game. idk man.
"because no one had brought this up"	tessa I don't get what this is at. and why the bold?
my alignment	yea this says jack and **** about my alignment, my work here is done
"... Did trundle dupe me into playing a Kingmaker game."	get ****ed
page 30	noting 'ribbon sus' to 'ribbon town' without much changing in that regard? Hm. I have had absolutely no ability to read ribbon atm (my brain fogs over whenever they post, nothing against you ribbon I think it's more likely to be my current mindset than anything on your end), but the fact that either the reads are co-existing without questioning one another or the reads are changed with no explaination isn't great. Might be worth looking into later when my eyes aren't bleeding.
Ness talking about suspicion on me	You might have already answered this so forgive me if so, but iirc weren't you on the train of people who said that yesterday's vote went too smoothly? If so, why are Oath and I, two pretty inactive people, on your chopping block first and foremost when theoretically mafia was helping that day end? You're being inconsistent.
post #625	I do think the tone shift from afk to immediately focusing on the gun pointed at his face is interesting
"forgettable is mafia read"	HARD disagree. It is a mafia tactic that can be deployed, but it is just as much of a mafia tactic to be incredibly rememberable, command the stage, and draw everyone to their line of view and their points. It's just as much of a sketchy action to talk in absolutes.
Towncore strong	What towncore? There has never been one, based on what I've read. This chat has been going nowhere with people throwing out idle questions and looking at way too small of a picture rather than considering anything significant. I don't think I've seen anyone in this entire thread I feel confident is town at this point, which scares the ever living crap out of me because usually I feel something but all I see here is shuffling around pieces of sand and hoping they make a clear picture.
Ness doubting Oath	No ****ing shot, not after he's actually been active enough that a case can be made against him do you back off. Reaction test?
Trent wanting to kill Dan	Can someone link to me his thoughts on this (or @Trent the Paladin can you recap), must have been in D1.
Tunnel not bad	BAD. DISLIKE. DISLIKE. that is WAY too much confidence, PARTICULARLY when he said his empathy was getting the better of him earlier.
"everyone and their mother townread me"	I can't come up with a refutation for this off the top of my head, I don't remember people scumreading you besides Oath (which feels very omgus to me), but this makes me want to tear my hair out. ****ing christ.
"my vote's on Dan"	Didn't you just say Dan wasn't someone you liked as much anymore like 3 pages ago?

Need to still compile my thoughts on people individually but I frankly heavily dislike Ness (for reasons stated) and Dan (more of a vibes, nothing really gave me good vibes in my readback to make my change much of my mind). I know Ness PR claimed and he's going to ***** at me for pushing resistance out but I'd written out **** I thought was sus before he actually revealed that in my defense, and I could easily see Ness claiming a PR as a PR'd mafia (or mafia has a framer on their side) so. Dislike.

I'm not a massive fan of voting anyone for king at the moment, though I apparently need to vote so. Give me a few to actually make a reads list. Just pushing this out ASAP so people have a chance to react to it before EoD in 45 mins

 

[tessa grace]

LMAO

Convinced at this point Geoni's a power role who's power is review old content like it's currently happening

trent can you give a reads list

Post automatically merged: Apr 10, 2024

heavily dislike Ness

i have bad news for you
for real though why would you even doubt the claim that's not a risk we can take

 

[Geoni]

tired of everyone saying my takes are weird but not saying why

I think it's because you are playing alone.

 

[Jacob4]

yeah ness is a safe vote with the claim, find it hard to see that coming from mafia

whos in contention for kill rn

 

[Arstotzkan]

i have bad news for you
for real though why would you even doubt the claim that's not a risk we can take

Fakeclaims are easy enough to spoof up, especially if Trundle gives some fakeclaims to mafia to start off with (I know some mafia hosts do this). If I were neutral to town on him as-is I wouldn't question it as much but he was my strongest evil read so.

 

[voltairenism]

yes but also i feel like we could learn more with ribbit

idk i feel like they would just sheep dan and it wouldnt say much
but ig it doesnt matter rn

In before geoni never comments on the current day by eod

Post automatically merged: Apr 10, 2024

Thoughts on Tessa now?

in one word harmless

 

[Damniel]

I don’t see a point in Ness needing to give a kill list at this stage. There’s more negatives in doing so now