Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER

[Geoni]

I'll current page at this point if someone can tell me which post Tessa explained her kill choice and why Oath is so controversial whenever my posts have hit the current page after I post them. Seems to be the two most prominent topics lately. And apparently people are throwing tomatoes at me for how I'm posting sooooo....

 

[tessa grace]

i think i'm going to iso oath and try to get a read on him that isn't banking off of others'

 

[oath2order]

i think i'm going to iso oath and try to get a read on him that isn't banking off of others'

Ya got 40 minutes.

 

[tessa grace]

Ya got 40 minutes.

try me

 

[Jacob4]

yeah ness is a safe vote with the claim, find it hard to see that coming from mafia

whos in contention for kill rn

honestly a fakeclaim is possible but feel like the way ness went about the claim seems real, in terms of not claiming the exact role to leave things ambiguous which if they're town makes it more difficult for maf to deal with. on the flipside ig that does make it easier for ness to claim

but also I don't really think ness if mafia really has to claim in that position to get what they wanted? seemed likely they were gonna be king anyway, as mafia feels like they dont need to take the unnecessary risk. which is the main reason i think ness is town here

 

[Damniel]

idk i feel like they would just sheep dan and it wouldnt say much
but ig it doesnt matter rn


in one word harmless

Anyone that stands out to you so far?

 

[Arstotzkan]

Actually correction that I wanna post ASAP - Oath's only reaction to anything being OMGUS is sketch as hell, but he and Ness are not both mafia for sure. They're both suspicious, but they're not both mafia.

 

[voltairenism]

Anyone that stands out to you so far?

town: you, ness, ribbit, maybe ender
prob wolf: trent and jacob
any other reads is under construction, sadly. im feeling all kinds of bad rn and i just wanna sleep

 

[Geoni]

I mean, I'm not entirely convinced you're town. I have no evidence to prove one way or another but it's possible. at the time i had the mindset of y'all faking an argument to prove one of y'all as town but that's not the case

what sticks me out for killing over what other people have sus'd like volt, for example

Since I'm not finding it in your ISO, what (at that time) convinced you there was a fake or staged sounding element to their argument?

 

[oath2order]

Since I'm not finding it in your ISO, what (at that time) convinced you there was a fake or staged sounding element to their argument?

Day 1-ism.

 

[annika]

Actually correction that I wanna post ASAP - Oath's only reaction to anything being OMGUS is sketch as hell, but he and Ness are not both mafia for sure. They're both suspicious, but they're not both mafia.

wait why is ness suspicious to you?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

trent can you give a reads list

god damn it's been two hours!!
reading up, everyone shut up while I do please and thank you

Quick dirty I don't trust Dan remotely at all despite the majority of you townreading them, N e s s flip flops so much but I have to reread *checks notes* six pages of that, I don't trust you, Ribbit seems to be skating by on just meeting post count, Kat literally just did a thought/wall post that I probably should review in depth I think they're townish, I don't know if Geoni is doing a bit because I would figure he'd work with current information and then work backwards instead of *waves hands* this, Oath I'm still not convinced is town but whatever we seemed to have moved off that for now, annika doesn't seem to give much up but I also am wasting time here typing this so I can't fully review their posts, Jacob I've kinda just forgotten about, Volt is confusing

for real though why would you even doubt the claim that's not a risk we can take

Mafia lie, my favorite thing to do as mafia is fake claim. N e s s gets night immunity to death, but I assume all the other actions can be blocked so unless >infinite theorycrafting here< I also don't see what the point is to a potentially unforced PR claim when there's so many other "universally TR" players here. Plus if everyone here is gonna point out "softs" why even have PRs, might as well make a nice lil checklist for mafia uwu

 

[Arstotzkan]

1. ribbitribbon - As mentioned in the direct post reactions, nothing you said really stuck with me at all. People are flopping on you too, which I think it might be more interesting to look at why people think what they do of you than look at you yourself? That's Day 3's problem though
3. annika - Not a single one of your posts sticks in my memory. All I remember is Ender thinking you looked good.
4. Jacob4 - The only post that pinged me was the back and forth with Daniel that I didn't like in my initial reactions, I didn't really notice him much other than that. More or less null, though may be looking more red if Daniel turns up red.
5. Damniel - Hard to put a peg on him, but I don't like his posts. I'll see if I can ISO him tonight and actually come up with something tangible.
6. Geoni - Seemed more overwhelmed than anything in his various posts, they didn't ping me particularly badly
7. EnderWiggin - Ender is an audacious loud critter as always. He radiates confidence, but I don't think that pings me in any particular way. The back and forth he had with someone? Forgetting who at the moment. Regarding Shiny TR was strange to me. I disagree with Ender's stance (a townread is a townread, it's not worth it to assess why someone agrees with you), so I guess slight red if anything? But hard to say.
9. tessa grace - I don't feel the overly pocketness in Dan I felt in you during Day 1. I'm happier with you on the whole
10. voltairenism - I need more info. People are flopping on you and I don't get it. You've seemed fine enough to me, but I also feel like I'm missing something?
12. oath2order - His only real contribution is OMGUS. Scummy behavior, though I do think his interactions with ness are not Mafia/Mafia. If he flips mafia, Ness is town.
13. Trent the Paladin - I'll be so honest my biggest view of him right now is sympathy for witnessing the trenches I have. I didn't get a strong enough read in my readback to let it override this feeling, but he also didn't post much at all so *gestures*
14. N e s s - If you want more elaboration, look at my initial thoughts post, but I feel like Ness is picking targets rather than trying to connect dots, which I think is very mafia-esque. I don't think his interactions with Oath are Mafia/Mafia though - if Ness flips mafia, Oath is town.

 

[tessa grace]

Quick dirty I don't trust Dan remotely at all despite the majority of you townreading them, N e s s flip flops so much but I have to reread *checks notes* six pages of that, I don't trust you, Ribbit seems to be skating by on just meeting post count, Kat literally just did a thought/wall post that I probably should review in depth I think they're townish, I don't know if Geoni is doing a bit because I would figure he'd work with current information and then work backwards instead of *waves hands* this, Oath I'm still not convinced is town but whatever we seemed to have moved off that for now, annika doesn't seem to give much up but I also am wasting time here typing this so I can't fully review their posts, Jacob I've kinda just forgotten about, Volt is confusing



Mafia lie, my favorite thing to do as mafia is fake claim. N e s s gets night immunity to death, but I assume all the other actions can be blocked so unless >infinite theorycrafting here< I also don't see what the point is to a potentially unforced PR claim when there's so many other "universally TR" players here. Plus if everyone here is gonna point out "softs" why even have PRs, might as well make a nice lil checklist for mafia uwu

can you give some justification for dan that isn't relying on your gut
or actually any justification for any of these takes?
i actually think being flip-floppy is a very common town-pr trait so it makes sense with ness

 

[annika]

14. N e s s - If you want more elaboration, look at my initial thoughts post, but I feel like Ness is picking targets rather than trying to connect dots, which I think is very mafia-esque. I don't think his interactions with Oath are Mafia/Mafia though - if Ness flips mafia, Oath is town.

oh hm i see

 

[Trent the Paladin]

can you give some justification for dan that isn't relying on your gut
or actually any justification for any of these takes?
i actually think being flip-floppy is a very common town-pr trait so it makes sense with ness

No because unlike people with jobs that apparently have computer time, anything I get through in terms of ISO is probably NOT going to make it

Secondly I do no care anymore

 

[Arstotzkan]

wait why is ness suspicious to you?

His suspicions have felt like pointing fingers rather than trying to actually connect any dots on anything imo.

That said I'm half tempted to vote to King Ness anyway and see what happens

 

[Damniel]

can you give some justification for dan that isn't relying on your gut
or actually any justification for any of these takes?
i actually think being flip-floppy is a very common town-pr trait so it makes sense with ness

There is nothing beyond that

Post automatically merged: Apr 10, 2024

His suspicions have felt like pointing fingers rather than trying to actually connect any dots on anything imo.

That said I'm half tempted to vote to King Ness anyway and see what happens

If you don’t want to vote him who would you vote for? You have to vote to avoid getting MKd

 

[Geoni]

I use bladescape on MU.

Volt ran into me there a few years ago. I proceeded to read them like a book for a bunch of games =P

The Deep Wolf isn't relevant to talk about rn because starting the "Witchhunt in town" is a bad idea. I regret making that post. That being said there is a person I think wolfing who is being townread rn. I'll bring it up if I feel it'll be an impact to the game further than that, but leaving that vague and letting them post is better because more reads for later.

Sometimes killing the head of the snake isn't as good early as later.

Also I note you've ignored the other alive players (Like Jacob) I've made reads on.

Say it louder!

Ender's posts feel stream of thought and straight to the point about things in a way I'm cool with atm though honestly kinda think he shouldn't mind policy chops if it's likely to flip red, that's the best info. Feeling good tonally between both himself and Gabby.

 

[voltairenism]

Quick dirty I don't trust Dan remotely at all despite the majority of you townreading them, N e s s flip flops so much but I have to reread *checks notes* six pages of that, I don't trust you, Ribbit seems to be skating by on just meeting post count, Kat literally just did a thought/wall post that I probably should review in depth I think they're townish, I don't know if Geoni is doing a bit because I would figure he'd work with current information and then work backwards instead of *waves hands* this, Oath I'm still not convinced is town but whatever we seemed to have moved off that for now, annika doesn't seem to give much up but I also am wasting time here typing this so I can't fully review their posts, Jacob I've kinda just forgotten about, Volt is confusing



Mafia lie, my favorite thing to do as mafia is fake claim. N e s s gets night immunity to death, but I assume all the other actions can be blocked so unless >infinite theorycrafting here< I also don't see what the point is to a potentially unforced PR claim when there's so many other "universally TR" players here. Plus if everyone here is gonna point out "softs" why even have PRs, might as well make a nice lil checklist for mafia uwu

it's a fact ness is the most tr'd person
and he said he can prove it tomorrow so. dont we have more to lose not crowning him