@Damnielhas been killed. They wereDoctor (Dr. Mario). @ribbitribbon has been killed. They wereFramer (Yellow Ninjakoopa).
Once per night, you can target a player. That player is immune to one kill action for the night. You win with the town.
Once per night, you can frame a player to make them seem Mafia-Aligned to any investigation checks. You win when the mafia equal or outnumber the town.
DAY 4 HAS BEGUN. YOU HAVE 48 HOURS TO VOTE FOR A KING.
Well I guess a feather in Jacob and Geoni’s cap of both being town was that Ribbit really laid it down thick talking to him at EoD. He seemed very confused about the claim in general.
Ribbit interacted with Tessa zero times at EoD if that’s worth considering.
I still can’t see it being Oath. Willing to settle on a Ribbit/Tessa/Annika team for now but that’s very thin reasoning. Hating that other than maybe Oath, Ribbit was the only one I was right about in PoE smh.
Post automatically merged:
Initially I typed that out as “Jacob was confused about the claim” but Geoni was as well. Although Geoni just straight up called it BS compared to Jacob, so which one is objectively more town requires some critical thinking.
Well I guess a feather in Jacob and Geoni’s cap of both being town was that Ribbit really laid it down thick talking to him at EoD. He seemed very confused about the claim in general.
Ribbit interacted with Tessa zero times at EoD if that’s worth considering.
I still can’t see it being Oath. Willing to settle on a Ribbit/Tessa/Annika team for now but that’s very thin reasoning. Hating that other than maybe Oath, Ribbit was the only one I was right about in PoE smh.
Post automatically merged:
Initially I typed that out as “Jacob was confused about the claim” but Geoni was as well. Although Geoni just straight up called it BS compared to Jacob, so which one is objectively more town requires some critical thinking.
im ngl i'll try very hard to not tunnel in a jacob/ribbit/tessa team just bc how eod went and how all of them were very against me being king for ? reasons
jacob said more than a couple of times that both dan and ribbit could have the same flavour, what is just insane
and even annika was dumbfounded by jacobs arguments that he should be king and not me
Post automatically merged:
tessa claiming literally the last second is just ridiculous because if she really got a red check on me, she shouldve said it as soon as my bw picked up instead of going "ahhh why nobody listens ;-;"
since dan could protect himself, wolves had to use both roleblock and kp to get rid of him, so tessa was safe to claim, stay alive AND get another investigation. all that also getting a mafia killed. and if anything, she could have saved dan
Post automatically merged:
the wording is also weird. she says "i must be a confused cop", as if she knows i am town. basically shes already implying she got an erroneous red check on me, laying groundwork for the framer flip
@Damnielhas been killed. They wereDoctor (Dr. Mario). @ribbitribbon has been killed. They wereFramer (Yellow Ninjakoopa).
Once per night, you can target a player. That player is immune to one kill action for the night. You win with the town.
Once per night, you can frame a player to make them seem Mafia-Aligned to any investigation checks. You win when the mafia equal or outnumber the town.
DAY 4 HAS BEGUN. YOU HAVE 48 HOURS TO VOTE FOR A KING.
since dan could protect himself, wolves had to use both roleblock and kp to get rid of him, so tessa was safe to claim, stay alive AND get another investigation. all that also getting a mafia killed. and if anything, she could have saved dan
Post automatically merged:
the wording is also weird. she says "i must be a confused cop", as if she knows i am town. basically shes already implying she got an erroneous red check on me, laying groundwork for the framer flip
he gets miskilled quite often when he’s town so i can kinda understand why he was so adamant about it after thinking it over
i was mostly just surprised bc it seemed like people were TRing him anyway but it makes sense to me now
also his frustration at eod seemed fairly real
Post automatically merged:
hmm i dont know who the mafia are though
there are probably just 3 at this point so mm
if tessa really is one (i agree i think she’s one btw) then… the last kinda makes sense to be jacob but hrmm
tbh i think she’s mafia for that last minute claim
unless it was a joke or something
but like, no way she gets a red check then just…doesn’t say anything until the LAST MINUTE
tessa claiming literally the last second is just ridiculous because if she really got a red check on me, she shouldve said it as soon as my bw picked up instead of going "ahhh why nobody listens ;-;"
since dan could protect himself, wolves had to use both roleblock and kp to get rid of him, so tessa was safe to claim, stay alive AND get another investigation. all that also getting a mafia killed. and if anything, she could have saved dan
@voltairenism my gut feeling yesterday was that Jacob wanted to be king because he wanted to “prove himself” by killing mafia, but like I feel he was just saying that lmao. Part of me feels like if Tessa is mafia he was setting up a bus there bc he seemed decently adamant on killing me at first glance but it felt he was trying to split away on getting himself killed.
Post automatically merged:
Then again I question why a Jacob/Tessa team would want to kill each other when they could reasonable get away with setting up an Oath or Geoni wagon this phase
Post automatically merged:
I bet 100 dollars mafia wasn’t expecting 5 blue roles in the game lol Dan being doctor really threw them for a loop
Post automatically merged:
Also this begs the question why on earth did Ribbit claim to begin with? What was the plan there
@voltairenism my gut feeling yesterday was that Jacob wanted to be king because he wanted to “prove himself” by killing mafia, but like I feel he was just saying that lmao. Part of me feels like if Tessa is mafia he was setting up a bus there bc he seemed decently adamant on killing me at first glance but it felt he was trying to split away on getting himself killed.
Post automatically merged:
Then again I question why a Jacob/Tessa team would want to kill each other when they could reasonable get away with setting up an Oath or Geoni wagon this phase
Post automatically merged:
I bet 100 dollars mafia wasn’t expecting 5 blue roles in the game lol Dan being doctor really threw them for a loop
Post automatically merged:
Also this begs the question why on earth did Ribbit claim to begin with? What was the plan there
Post automatically merged:
Questioning who Ribbit was implying here
Post automatically merged:
Why ask this
Post automatically merged:
Volt my heart will be permanently broken if you have played me for a fiddle
the thing about that "prove myself" point that bugs me is that ribbit had no way to come back from this. because of the nature of her claim, she was bound to be the one killed no matter how towny she looked. both tessa and jacob were pressed on this when bussing here is 100% the optimal play
i will say that jacob push on tessa was pretty radical for someone to be teamed but here's a bit of food for thought: 1) jacob's reads were called shallow and with no substance by several people and pushing someone like oath would not get me or dan pocketed like tessa did. dan had said multiple times he just thinks oath is town and there was attempts to get a geoni bw rolling 2) ribbit's claim was planned ahead of time because of her softs, so it was bound to come to save a teammate. considering ribbit/tessa for a bit, you see that tessa was down for a geoni policy chop, although being against it in the first day. she says she rather not kill a chatter, what is valid enough, but yk. also in a annika/ribbit/tessa world, annika random "what about geoni" the entire day could make more sense
needless to say that i overall think geoni is town. besides any of his behaviour yesterday, what i think were mostly town indicative, i dont think he would let that fakeclaim happen (like, i think he would suggest something else to claim)
