Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER

whats truly confusing me about dan's claim is the push for volt to be king over jacob- the same result comes from both so why protect volt? especially since i feel like mafia would kill dan over volt bc of the pr claim. (In a world where volt!t and dan!t)
it seems like a weak reason to vote somebody as king and makes me think volt is going to take a different route... maybe, which is why i dont understand this logic
i just feel very skeptical about counterclaims overall as well
@voltairenism ayo what you said holds water
Post automatically merged:

NO *I* will be heartbroken if u are tricking me
I could never pookie. On my mama im truthin
 
i thinking more abt a tessa/ribbit/annika world. annika eod said a couple of times she was down for a ribbit kill even if she thinks dan was the wolf. it feels very flip-floppy although it is logical sound (she thought it was better to try to get the promised trent inspection). considering shes been worried abt being 4 mafia, not worrying abt actually killing wolf doesn't make much sense to me
 
Well I feel better about volt now at least, 1 maf down - I was really scared

Think we should crown volt again since we can crown the same person multiple times in a row right?

Also I think Tess is probably just mafia after that confused cop claim it doesn’t make sense especially with 2 invest roles already being dead
 
i will say that i have no clue what annika could accomplish with this but it's true that this is a cold thought process that doesn't sound town. even jacob's arguments to be kinged makes sense for a town player
 
@voltairenism sorry for doubting you :(
Post automatically merged:

I have work next 5 days with p bad hours and in office with a strict boss so I can’t really play at work, so don’t know how much I’m gonna be able to post from now but I’ll try my best to solve the game in the time I have

With volt being more likely town after killing ribbit I think it’s somewhat likely that maf team outside of Tessa is just laying low, I think ness siding with the idea of killing ribbit is prob a better look for him

I feel like tess is maf and tried to make herself seem aligned with me by pushing me for king over volt despite that I’d been pushing her all of yesterday, thinking itd eventually get me killed for it after she dies (she might have just planned on outing herself as mafia with that confused cop claim? Idk lol)

Maf in tess/geoni/oath maybe?
Post automatically merged:

I think maybe at least some of the maf could have wanted me as king cause they thought I was less likely to kill ribbit than volt was

In which case that’d point to tess/geoni being maf, but idk as much with geoni on that logic cuz I think at the time he voted me I was p adamant on killing ribbit
Post automatically merged:

Geoni also wanted ribbit dead tbf so that’s a good look for him
 
Last edited:
I have work next 5 days with p bad hours and in office with a strict boss so I can’t really play at work, so don’t know how much I’m gonna be able to post from now but I’ll try my best to solve the game in the time I have
rip
you can get through it!!
I feel like tess is maf and tried to make herself seem aligned with me by pushing me for king over volt despite that I’d been pushing her all of yesterday, thinking itd eventually get me killed for it after she dies (she might have just planned on outing herself as mafia with that confused cop claim? Idk lol)
this somewhat makes sense
but tbf, I have no idea why she'd do that and out herself when a teammate is dying, just to potentially get one townie killed...
hmm
I'll have to think about it ig but let's just see what she says today
Geoni also wanted ribbit dead tbf so that’s a good look for him
yea true I suppose

I have to recheck what Oath was saying at eod too
Post automatically merged:

or maybe kill dan if you think the game is ending but it prob wont
^ I figured the game probably wasn't ending which is why I still wanted Ribbit dead @Volt

um ignore the first part of this post
it doesn't exist
haha
Post automatically merged:

oh i just accidentally mentioned some random person- sorry
help
Post automatically merged:

hmmm
Oath didn't really say much about whether or not he believed Ribbit or Dan more, that's kind of interesting... they didn't share their opinion at all at the time
-snip-
me rn reading ribbit's roleclaim
I mean, if volt kills ribbit and ribbit flips mafia, then that says a lot about volt's alignment, right? I think that would basically confirm-volt as town.
Does maf tessa necessarily mean maf ribbit?
this is all they said regarding it I think

the first post is just a meme and I think it's supposed to express surprise? so it seems like they're not taking a stance

also while I was going through eod posts, I remembered Daniel was also pretty sure that Ribbit being maf meant that Tessa was also maf, so... I think we should definitely just kill Tessa here to honor his legacy

it COULD just be Tessa and Oath as the remaining two
 
Last edited:
If we were to assume the last two were within Tessa/Jacob/Annika/Oath how do we arrange the order of execution
Post automatically merged:

For me it would go Tessa > Jacob > Annika > Oath but I’m questioning the legitimacy of Oath again 👁️👁️
 
If we were to assume the last two were within Tessa/Jacob/Annika/Oath how do we arrange the order of execution
Post automatically merged:

For me it would go Tessa > Jacob > Annika > Oath but I’m questioning the legitimacy of Oath again 👁️👁️

I really want Tessa to post before nailing anything down.
 
I really want Tessa to post before nailing anything down.
1713200222442.gif
 
If we were to assume the last two were within Tessa/Jacob/Annika/Oath how do we arrange the order of execution
why would you assume that tho
specifically why are you excluding Geoni? (excluding yourself and volt is fine obv)
 
why would you assume that tho
specifically why are you excluding Geoni? (excluding yourself and volt is fine obv)
I agree with Volt’s earlier points about Geoni, Ribbit’s claim isn’t a move he would organize he’s far more intuitive than that.
Post automatically merged:

I can make some more coherent points later there’s only so much I can do on my phone at work
 
Last edited:
because i tr jacob and i dont tr volt lmao
@tessa grace why were you townreading me and wolf reading volt? I looked through your iso but I don't really see anything tangible as to why you thought i was town and volt was maf, just feels like it came from nowhere

kinda just feels like you wanted me king cuz u thought i maybe wasnt gonna kill ribbit
Post automatically merged:

If we were to assume the last two were within Tessa/Jacob/Annika/Oath how do we arrange the order of execution
Post automatically merged:

For me it would go Tessa > Jacob > Annika > Oath but I’m questioning the legitimacy of Oath again 👁️👁️
i still feel like annika is towny, assuming its 2 maf left (i think it is cause 4 maf would be dumb) i think this ordering would lose

honestly i think it's gonna be difficult for me to not get miskilled here especially after i advocated for king yesterday, in hindsight I should've known volt was towny there and i'm sorry if that misplay costs us the game
Post automatically merged:

i kinda hate how you cant like nest like multiple quotes on here i keep wanting to quote things that have quotes in the post but i cant
 
Last edited:
@Jacob4 alright well if you’re set on Annika being town, which of Geoni and Oath do you think would be feasibly mafia?
 
@Jacob4 alright well if you’re set on Annika being town, which of Geoni and Oath do you think would be feasibly mafia?
before I would have said geoni is wolfier because gth some of oath's emotional posts read to me as town, but I think geoni wanting to kill ribbit is a good point for him

ngl I usually tend to read emotional plays as towny so I think my thoughts on oath could p easily be wrong. so gth I would say geoni is townier for having stronger opinion on wanting to kill ribbit while oath kinda skated around the issue

what are you thinking rn on those 2 in terms of which is townier?
Post automatically merged:

ngl i dont know if im like 95% or more confident on annika being town now, I can't 100% get a grasp on her in normal games

her thinking dan was maf yesterday at eod felt weird to me cause I think town annika might be a bit more likely to understand dan's softs are likely to come from town, usually she is a bit more malleable as town imo

but at the same time its kinda weird as wolf to say shed say to kill ribbit still even tho she thought dan was the maf, and i felt she's been p towny outside of wanting to kill dan
Post automatically merged:

honestly what if its just tess/geoni/oath and there are 4 maf lol
Post automatically merged:

what do you guys think the likelihood of there being 4 maf is rather than 3?

assuming there's 5 town PRs (assuming ness is town and claim is real) i don't think it's totally outside the realm of plausibility, but with the jester on top of everything honestly 4 mafs would be pretty maf sided so it seems unlikely to me
 
Last edited:
tbh its kinda unproductive to speculate on how many mafia we have bc we don't know lol. We'll find out eventually.

Geoni is more town to me than Oath is, but again that's on a very thin basis since my retail job has been demanding my blood and tears the last 4 days
Post automatically merged:

I will say that town has felt pretty stacked this game in terms of PRs, but given that mine and Shiny's roles are arguably useless maybe its by a thin margin
 
honestly i think it's gonna be difficult for me to not get miskilled here especially after i advocated for king yesterday, in hindsight I should've known volt was towny there and i'm sorry if that misplay costs us the game
Post automatically merged:

i kinda hate how you cant like nest like multiple quotes on here i keep wanting to quote things that have quotes in the post but i cant
i would rather solve tessa slot first
and i am not as sure that you are mafia as well. what ness that about you pushing tessa instead of geoni or oath got to my head. it feels super unnecessary
Post automatically merged:

what ness said*
 
i would rather solve tessa slot first
and i am not as sure that you are mafia as well. what ness that about you pushing tessa instead of geoni or oath got to my head. it feels super unnecessary
Post automatically merged:

what ness said*
remind yourself that overconfidence is a slow, and insidious killer
 
Back
Top