I kinda wanna reset since my map sucks and all, but I have had this town since the game first came out, and I have done so much with it. Caught all the fish, diving-thingys and bugs you can, gold exterior and all of that. I also have a couple of villagers I really like.
it's been said over and over again. If your map really bothers you.... just reset it because it will always keep bothering you. Fishes, bugs, villagers, you can get all over again... it'll take more work but the decision is ultimately up to you.
Question though, why don't you like your map?