I just want to say, I really appreciate you being careful about not criticizing those who don't like Raymond.
I think it's natural and unavoidable that some people will be turned off a character if they see others going overboard for them, and that really applies to any game/movie/music group. Sometimes it's because people don't want to be associated with that fandom, other times it's because they think "well X is good but it's not that good..." and it starts making them think about the negative aspects of X in objection to the worship. Other people are just obstinate by nature, and they simply don't want a town like everyone else has. I totally understand that. I love Punchy and nothing will diminish that, but my friend whose island I visit all the time has Punchy right now, so it feels too weird for me to get Punchy too. I likely won't get Punchy till he leaves her island.
Also, I think it's awesome that villagers remember you when they are moving back to your island and all have something unique to say! It makes me wanna see what that text is for each personality type! I should have a Jock coming back soon.