I’m so jealous of tide pool rocks! The only decoration I really want for my rocks! When I visit my husband’s island and see his multiple tide pool rocks it is the only time I kind of wish I had known about the resetting to get a better island thing when I started. (Though Genji was my starter so I probably still wouldn’t have done it.)
But! Tide pool rocks are great!
Yeah, I just think it depends on what you're going for honestly! They are really a cool feature if you can work around them. I finally managed to find a design for one of my tidepool rocks I liked (flamingo sanctuary), and that matches really well with the tidepools' natural aesthetic. I just had to find another place to put my cafe and marine life research lab, because there was no way either of those two were ever going to fit on my rocks! xD
And I feel you on "maybe I would have re-started, but then again maybe not..." since I actually got my favorite jock (Teddy) as my starter too, so I know what you mean! Once I saw him, I knew I wasn't going to reset, for sure.