Top 10 Villagers You've NEVER Had

[Sheando]

We talk a lot about our favorite villagers of all time, but I want to hear about the top ten villagers you'd be most excited to have in your town-villagers you've never lived with, either in NH or any previous AC title. I guess some might call these "dreamies," but I don't really have dreamies in the sense of planning for a set of ten villagers who all complement each other and live in my town at the same time. But I do have a mental list of some villagers I'd love to have in future towns one day--cool animals I'd be so excited to meet on a mystery island or after I step off the spaceship/hoverboard/whatever that transports me to my new home in Animal Crossing: 2035.

So here's my list, which was very difficult to narrow:

I had SUCH a hard time, but ultimately I stuck to my own rules. So tell me: which ten villagers are at the top of your hope-to-meet-one-day list?

(Link to website if you want to copy/paste your own choices: https://animalcrossing.fandom.com/wiki/Villager_list_(New_Horizons) )

 

[TN4U]

I also included villagers who I had on towns/islands very briefly and did not progress on or deleted. Here's my list:

1. Erik

2. Fauna

3. Phoebe

4. Diana

5. Cookie

6. Wolfgang

7. Tybalt

8. Quinn

9. Mitzi

10. Julia

As much as I want to put Roscoe on this list, he became a resident on my second island about a month ago, so I had to leave him out. In terms of who I may want in the next mainline game, I can easily say that Fauna and Phoebe would probably become residents. Even though Erik is my #1 "never had" villager, he's too similar to Beau in many aspects, and I wouldn't really want both at the same time unless I'm going for a deer-only town (which I'd totally do).

 

[rocketspruggs]

Here are some villagers I never had that I'd enjoy having on my island:

☆ Teddy
☆ Olaf
☆ Lucky
☆ Frobert
☆ Raymond (I like him for who he is, not his popularity.)
☆ Gayle
☆ Vesta
☆ Audie
☆ Shari
☆ Cookie

 

[Seastar]

I'm not sure what order to put them in, but maybe these? This was hard.

Marina (This one should definitely be at the top)
Sasha
Marshal
Audie
Vesta (I feel like I had her but then I remember that was Happy Home Designer)
Ione
Shino
Chrissy
Francine
Chevre

Honorable mention: Étoile (I plan to scan her into my 3rd New Leaf town eventually which is the only reason she's not on the list)

 

[BiscuitsAndTriscuits]

Oh goodness thats a hard question tbh

Diana
Pietro
Frita
Tom
Bubbles
Violet
Octavian
Dobie
Freckles
Molly

 

[azurill]

This is a hard decision. There are still a good amount of villagers I still haven’t seen even though I have played AC forever.
Top 10

1 Ellie
2 Bones
3 Hopkins
4 Daisy
5 Maddie
6 Tasha
7 Tank
8 Stella
9 Kitty
10 Jacob

If I do restart my second island at some point I might try and find them all.

 

[Emolga59]

I had to look through the list of villagers for this LOL

I used to cycle through a lot in New leaf so i’m limited on options

1. Portia
2. Bunnie
3. Olivia
4. Tasha
5. Ruby
6. Sydney
7. Kiki
8. Blanche
9. Bea
10. Cleo

 

[Hanami]

Here's my list of villagers I'd be happy to have on my island, and I'm pretty certain they haven't been residents (not counting my cycling towns and Pocket Camp).

Purrl, Scoot, Dotty, Benjamin, Melba, Tybalt, Kiki, Mitzi, Deena, Goldie

 

[Galatea]

Here's my list of villagers I'd love to have on my island, and I'm pretty sure they haven't been residents before.
Bluebear
Bonbon
Buck
Deli
Dobie
Flurry
Gabi
Jitters
Nibbles
Zell

 

[Muna]

Here are villagers that I've never had on any of my island but I would gladly take them:
1. Shino - but she's going to move in for sure, I even have her amiibo
2. Sasha - the same as above
3. Maple
4. Rosie
5. Lily
6. Lolly
7. Bluebear
8. Chief
9. Mitzi
10. Sprinkle