Top 15 Collectibles (2023 Version)

[lieryl]

1-14.

i would trade my whole entire inventory for this one collectible and i apologize for the person i will become if there is ever a chance to win it again!!
15.

look at it

 

[LittleMissPanda]

Lucky me I own all my fave pixels but still not an easy list to compile, because there's just so many great collectibles out there <3 starting with the introduction of the 2022 fair collectibles, at this point we really are being spoiled senselessly by staff, thank you staff!

1. Kaleidoclover

my #1 favorite collectible ever. The thing that really got me hooked. Saw this one day and thought it looked so cool, I just had to have it. The first one I ever bought cost me 2k which was the most I had ever spent, at least back then lol it's super hard not to try for a full 10 lineup of them but I'm grateful for the ones I already have, especially the rare 2021 re-release which I cherish with all my heart

2. Eggs

these are my top 5 favorite designs. No other egg has resonated with me as deeply as these~

3. Glow Wands

to think I had like 4 heart wands at some point or another lmao the best one I own is the 2020 flower wand. I especially value collectibles with very unique raffle dates.

4. Feathers

it all started with a 5-piece gradient feather set I bought - Glam, Fresh, Hot, Cool and Sweet, for such a great deal, too. Seeing them together in a row looked so pleasing to the eye, suddenly feathers became an instant fave. But wow, that black feather.... like, I only ever wanted one just for kicks but I didn't think it would be THAT perfect...and the fact it was randomly gifted to me one day on my way back home after a ****ty day at work, I value it above even my galaxy eggs

5. Sheep Plush

out of all the plushies we have so far, this was easily a no brainer for me. Participated in my first ever fair in 2020 after coming back from hiatus, had no idea how anything worked and was pretty limited on what activities I could participate in, so I was lucky to have scrounged up enough tickets to afford one. To think I almost picked star fragments to just sell at some point, but something about the Sheep Plush really spoke to me, and when I bought it I was overcome with pure happiness. The first collectible I worked hard to buy on my own

6. Pink Star Fragments for daysssssss

went ham on collecting these lol currently own 8 of them but I sure wouldn't mind another 8 hahaha!

7. Pinky

I mean it's Pinky, what more do I need to explain

8. Snow Bunny

super adorable, always puts me in the mood to draw a cute little family of them whenever I see it~

9. Potions

these two are my favorites out of the whole set. We just need a yellow or orange potion now

10. Moon Ball

give me a moon ball over a love ball any day. This is where I make an exception over having multiples of one kind of collectible. Having a full 10 lineup of these would kick so much ass.

11. Wix Candy I get the feeling it tastes sour and I love me some sour candy

12. Mother's Day Carnation

my favorite out of all the flower collectibles, even more so than the Lily of the Valley. If we had a green Mum collectible that would be an instant favorite, for sure!

13. Spring Sakura

again I try to resist not having a full 10 lineup of them because that would be a bit too boring even for me lol

14. Special Snowflake

the very first staff favorite award I won and perhaps the only staff favorite award I will ever own, and it was for a writing activity during an event in December 2020. Nowadays I'm grateful enough if my entries are even acknowledged

15. Ruby and Vesta

favorite out of all the villagers. If we ever get a frog villager one day, and not just any frog, but Henry, Jeremiah, Lily, Drift or Tad omg especially Tad, that would seriously be the best day ever it's sad frog villagers don't get enough love.

Honorable mentions:

also still waiting on the day we get actual Legend of Zelda themed collectibles, but for now I like to think the fair crystals fill in that role pretty nicely~

 

[~Kilza~]

This is mostly the same list as I posted earlier this year, just with some small re-ordering and 11-15 added:

1. Red Star Fragment (

)
2. Shooting Star (

) (will never win one, rip)
3. Orange Mote of Flame (

) (will never get one, rip)
4. Flick Halloweaster Egg (

)
5. Dino Plush (

)
6. Bloodshot Potion (

)
7. Red Pikmin Egg (

)
8. Ocean Pearl (

) (because I won one)
9. Red Feather (

)
10. Golden Easter Egg (

) (because I won one)
11. Famous Mushroom (

)
12. Lump of Coal (

)
13. Rafflesia (

)
14. Enchanted Bloom (

) (because I won one)
15. Red Christmas Stocking (

)

 

[Aquilla]

1-5 are my favourites in order ^^ Everything below 5. I like equally and the order in which I placed them is random!

1. 
   Has always been my favourite, even before I got into collectibles. I can just hope one day all planets align and I can get one.
2. 
   Moon and rainbow, my two favourite things!
3. 
   My second favourite egg to this date
4. Can u tell I love eggs
5. 
   
   
   I like all potions, but these three just do it for me
6. 
   
   
   
   
   
   
   Kicking my butt I didn't buy fragments during 2020 fair but wasted all currency on raffles abshxuyb
7. Best house
8. 
   Best filler
9. 
   
   Best plushies
10. Favourite flowers in AC
11. It's so pretty what can I say! I'm so happy I finally have one!
12. 
    This is just so cool and nostalgic!
13. 
    
    
    
    
    Shiny and glowy
14. 
    
    They are so cool?? bring them back??
15. psychedelic disco flower ftw

Honorable mentions: All other eggs I didn't add, the other houses are neat too and I love me some cake

 

[Flicky]

I'm not 100% up to date on collectibles so I forget a lot of their names, but this is my list for 2022:

1.

- I absolutely love the Key to Bell Tree Manor, I think it'll be my fave for a while!
2.

- Really wish I had this one, it looks so cool.
3.

- Ancient scrolls? Yes. I want this one too.
4.

- I love cats.
5.

- See above.
6.

- Another 'frequently seen in spooky mansions' kinda deal.
7.

- The animation is absolutely amazing!
8.

- Spooky egg.
9.

- Love the little moon at the side.
10.

- This one looks so relaxing to me.
11.

- Another one that I just like the look of.
12.

- Similar to above. I like mushroom aesthetics.
13.

- Green is one of my favourite colours, and I love the way these crystals look.
14.

- Bats. I love bats.
15.

- Nothing better than a hot cocoa during those cold winter months.

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Bump! Has your list changed at all with all the new collectibles released? Mine has, will need to update the first post for sure.

 

[nightglow]

Yes, it has changed. And this time, I remembered to look at the non tradable ones too. Some of the older collectibles look kinda washed out to me after alot of the more saturated ones came along.

Summer 2023..

1.

2.
3.
4. Moon Set
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13. Frags
14.
15.

 

[oak]

Gotta show some love to the mushroom set. These beauties got over shadowed by the crystal set from the same event.

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

View attachment 510921View attachment 510922View attachment 510923View attachment 510924View attachment 510925
View attachment 510927View attachment 510928View attachment 510929View attachment 510931View attachment 510932
View attachment 510934View attachment 510935View attachment 510938View attachment 510939View attachment 510940

Gotta show some love to the mushroom set. These beauties got over shadowed by the crystal set from the same event.

I love that all the rabbit collectibles are up there haha

 

[Alolan_Apples]

1. Chocolate Cake
2. Crescent Moon Glow Wand
3. Snowflake Glow Wand
4. Pumpkin Glow Wand
5. Flower Glow Wand
6. Star Glow Wand
7. Heart Glow Wand
8. Tetris Grid
9. Disco Ball Egg
10. Galaxy Egg
11. Aurora Egg
12. Frost Egg
13. Light Blue Balloon
14. Blue Balloon
15. Green Balloon

Basically, the glow wands, balloons, and certain eggs will always triumph over other collectibles, but the Chocolate Cake will always be king,

 

[Xara]

trying to narrow down just 15 top favourites is even harder now than it was last year (partially because i’m sick rn and my brain is mush

), but my list has definitely changed a little! curse staff for throwing so many incredible collectibles our way

1.

- to reiterate what i said in my first post, i don’t think there’ll ever be a collectible that tops the crescent-moon wand for me. idek what it is about it, i swear it has crack in it it is my dream, my favourite favourite favourite collectible of all time, i have changed so much in the past 7 years but my love for that darn wand has not it is my beloved and i have been manifesting all week that i win one tomorrow, pls pls PLS put me out of my misery
2.

- my top 3 favourites actually haven’t changed in the past year. so many stunning and magnificent collectibles have come out, but me wand, celeste chick plush, and aurora egg stay for me!
3.

4.

- it might be the leftover camp hype and my love for my crew talking, but the moon bunny collectible is genuinely so adorable, and it’s brought my obsession with the og snow bunny back as well! i mean look at their little faces begging staff to make more of them, i need a whole lineup of bunny collectibles in this style
5.

- rainbow moon jellyfish has been bumped down by the bunnies, but i still love her!!! she is so colourful and gorgeous, and i am forever kicking myself for not slaying last camp
6.

- i have it???? it’s in my inventory???? it’s so pretty and colourful and my aesthetic???? you just have to throw anything rainbow at me and i will love it forever, but rainbow crescent moon is so so special to me
7.

- i am still a plushies girl at the end of the day
8.

- i gave the aurora egg its own spot since it‘s my absolute favourite, but these are my other favourite eggs!! shiny eggs?? pastel eggs?? cutesy eggs with little faces?? yes please!!
9.

- i am also a potions girl hehe, love all of them but these are my faves! rainbow potion when,,,
10.

11.

- the glow wands are so cool in general, but enchanted butterfly is my favourite after crescent-moon
12.

- aurora sky slays so hard
13.

- this one is also in my inventory???? it is so serene and stunning? i cry every time i look at it??? i love her she is gorgeous and so special to me, my very first event favourite collectible
14.

- i have become a star frag whore, i fear there’s no going back now
15.

- kaleidoclover my og rainbow child, ily

honourable mentions:

and many others :’)

 

[King koopa]

Here's mine for summer 2023:

1. Galaxy Swirl

Well, I love it's design, and because I have one! Plus I'm a huge SMG fan and it reminds me of that game lol

2. ISC frag I love it's design, and because it has two of my favorite colors, Blue and Purple, the best of both worlds

3. Frost Egg

while I don't have one, (and i'm kicking myself because I didn't snag one during the winter 2021 event rip) I do think it's really pretty and I hope I'll be rich enough to buy one one day ❄

4. Galaxoltol frag

Mkay so I'm not a galaxoltol so I'm not sure if I'm legally allowed to say this, but I actually really like this design! Reminds me of a starbit from SMG
5. Rainbow frag Will I ever win one in the future? Probably not lol. But is it pretty? Yes!

6. Rainbow feather

Basically copy-paste what I said about the rainbow frag, I love it, but I probably won't be lucky enough to win one

7. Cool and hot feathers

Gonna dump these two together because I can't decide which one I like more, but these two are my favorite gradient feathers, and I'm happy to own both! ❄

8. Glam feather while I still like the Cool and Hot feathers slightly more, I do think the Glam feather is still really pretty! It's also in the same boat with the Frost Egg of being a long-time dream collectible of mine

9. Purple star fragment another long-time collectible dream of mine, currently nowhere near affording one, but hopefully one day I will

10. Wix candy

probably my favorite candy besides the Friday the 13th candy, and while they seem near impossible to come by, I do still hold hope I'll be able to get one one day

11. Friday the 13th candy

I really like the wrapper design on this one! Wonder what it tastes like?

12. Potions! I like all of them, but here are my favorites in no particular order:


13. Blue mote of flame

kinda wish they'd return, I think it looks amazing! Unfortunately I wasn't around in 2013 oof

14. Blue feather

I'm a sucker for blue collectibles, plus one was gifted to me by a friend when I was feeling really sad, so it'll automatically be one of my favorite collectibles for that reason

15. Blue and green balloons

I love all the balloons, but these two are probably my favorites because they remind me of Kourage and Hope lol

Honorable mentions:

 

[Bui]

I don't really follow collectibles enough to be able to make a top 15, so for now I'll just keep it down to a top 5.

1.

Mailbox.
2.

Space Whale Plush
3.

Blue Junimo Egg
4.

の (Yellow house/ "no")
5.

Pokeball, my dream collectible since my early days on the site which I will likely never be able to afford.

 

[digimon]

proceeds to list almost every collectible ever i ranked them by sets ? kinda? and for some of them that have variations, i just put the ones that i like c:

1)

wand set ToT
2)

THE G.O.A.T
3)

so beautiful and they go with so many things, i love them sm
4)

also versatile and i love the gradients on them
5)

seeing this set grow over the years to almost having enough for a full lineup it's saur good!
6)

has a fond place in my heart! i remember working really hard to earn one during tbtwc ;u;
7)

i wish there were more added to this set because they go so well with the tetris grid + star frags
8)

goes great with the star fragments
9)

i love that these two were released together, they're so perfect
10)

bunny besties 4lyfe
11)

my favourite plush collectibles!
12)

THE DETAILS! it's such a beautiful collectible, i can't
13)

the gradients on these are so so pretty!
14)

these two are the first collectibles that i was really excited to get
15)

my favourite patches

honorable mentions: (the animated ones make me sob tbh)

my pre-2023 list won't differ too much from my "it's almost 2024" list (kinda scary to say that out loud tbh but here we go!) gonna try and challenge myself to limit the amount of collectibles i put in each set, but we'll see how that goes LOL


digimon's updated collectible tier list

1.

and i repeat, THE G.O.A.T, i don't think another colllectible will ever come close to this i fear
2.

wands go hard as heck and the planet wand is an excellent addition to the set
3.

the frag that made my gradient frag pipe dream a reality
4.

so beautiful ;u;
5.

so pretty and the go great with the frags!
6.

watching the animation makes me so happy
7.

not from the same set obviously but i think they look so cute together!
8.

9.

pee potion sneak but look how perfectly it fits under the yellow crystal
10.

my favourite eggs!
11.

updated fave plushie list
12.

they're icons, they're legends and they are the moment, now come on now
13.

i want there to be a 5th one so bad to make up a half line up
14.

my favourite patches, updated
15.

same reason as last year, the gradients are pretty!

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

i have become a star frag w[redacted because unsure if word is allowed], i fear there’s no going back now

I have full respect for your choices girlie, lots of good ones in there, but just know I got to this part and lost it lmaooo (because same)

 

[Snek]

I used to be sort of distant with collectibles but once you go down that rabbit hole well...
Anyway here's my top 15:

1. Galaxy Swirl

Nothing will top it! I doubt I will ever be on another winning team knowing my luck so this beauty is enough for me.

2. Oarfish Set

Do you think I would forget my lovely snek set? Winning one was a dream come true for my first Camp TBT so it didnt matter that I was on the overall losing team (Buzzy Bees). It still has a special place in my inventory that wont be going anywhere

3. Andromeda Potion

I've been obsessed with the potions more lately. This is probably my favourite out of all of them. I could have a whole lineup of just these bad bois

4. ISC Fragment

Oh, the pain it was to get this! So beautiful, a gradiant of both purple and blue! Another beautiful reminder of being on the ISC crew.

5. Glitched Easter Egg

My favourite egg. I spent a lot imo for a whole row of them. It'll be a tradition for me to always have a row of them during egg hunts or if they go with my current theme

6. Space Whale Plush

No words to say. Best plushie so far! Its also a wonderful memento of my ISC crew since we were the space whale team

7 & 8. Raven Wings & Angel Wings

I have both of these and are tied (deservingly)
They go perfectly together, a yin potion to the yang potion, naughty and nice, etc

9. Galaxolotl Star Fragment

Glad for the Galaxolotls for winning this fragment! The blues go perfectly well together. I'm not super into fragments but the gradiant ones are just different.

10. Bloodshot Potion

The only potion on this list that I don't have. I love the red and hopefully I'll get one in the near future

11. Friday the 13th Candy

There's a Friday the 13th coming soon so maybe this will be my first chance to get one? Maybe? ... Possibly?

12. Will o' the Wisp Halloweaster Egg

Its the blue flame. Its just so cool.

13. Eerie Star Potion

Loved this potion so much! It went down a little, maybe because I have it now amd want the Bloodshot so much...well the teal is really nice on the eyes.

14 & 15. Rosewater Potions

Both are tied. Love both of them equally so I have to include both. Also, I'm a sucker for potions.

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Interesting how much my list has changed in almost a year. Of all the collectibles that I have, these are my top 15 favorites:

1.

I think the Shooting Star will always be my favorite collectible!
2.

Star Fragments.. they always make me think of the 2020 Bell Tree Fair; great memories
3.

Still love my Love Potion
4.

Finally managed to get one of these bad boyz and just ugh.. the prettiest egg ever
5.

Arguably the most beautiful of all the star fragments! So proud to have been a Galaxolotl

6.

A beautiful trip
7.

One of my dream collectibles is finally here.. an alien plush!!
8.

Love the Shooting Star plush too.. so cute and aesthetic. Reminds me of the Kiki & Lala table in NL/NH
9.

The mush lamps are still super underrated. I absolutely need to get the white and yellow ones!
10.

Always loved the Spring Sakura; just wish I could have more. They're definitely aesthetic
11.

I can't decide between these two. I also love the popsicle but I don't have one right now!
12.

The Glitched Egg is so eye-catching.. it's a fantastic egg and I'm so glad I bought one
13.

I always wanted a UFO collectible! I think this is my favorite Bell Tree patch collectible.
14.

IDK, still just really enjoy this lil guy. He so cute
15.

Love Cocotryoshka; really wish there was a Bunnie-tryoshka and a Ruby-tryoshka

 

[daisyflowers]

1. glow wands -

CMON THEY'RE SO CUTE AAA
2. star fragments -

glowy!! favourite colours!!!
3. crescent moons!! -

these match so well with the frags!! mega rad rad
4. space camp 2023 patch -

5. lily of the valley -

6. silent night bauble -

(needs more love imo!! i love the lil crescent moon in the middle! aaaa)
7. caustic crystal -

(all my favourite colours in a collectible!)
8. eerie star potion -

(this shade of blue slaps)
9. swamp potion -

10. raven wings potion -

11. pumpkin glow wand -

(this guy from the 2021 halloween event was my first ever glow wand!!) ;u;
12. stardust easter egg -

13. blue rosewater potion
14. stardust easter egg
15. crescent moon egg

 

[~Kilza~]

-snip-

This list has actually changed a fair amount, thanks in large part to camp. No comments, just going by feel:
1.

Red Star Fragment
2.

Shooting Star
3.

Galaxy Swirl
4.

Orange Mote of Flame
5.

Flick Halloweaster Egg
6.

Bloodshot Potion
7.

Red Pikmin Egg
8.

Space Whale Plush
9.

Dino Plush
10.

S.S. Dolphin
11.

Ocean Pearl
12.

Red Feather
13.

Golden Easter Egg
14.

Famous Mushroom
15.

Rafflesia

 

[S.J.]

I last posted here in Nov 2022, so I thought I'd see whether my top fifteen had changed between then and now. With the new camp collectibles, it's definitely changed a bit!

1. 
   Crescent Moon Glow Wand
2. 
   Glam Feather – The first collectible I won, and just one of my most loved and precious collectibles.
3. 
   Space Whale Plush – My beloved Space Whales, even more cherished because of who they've come from.
4. 
   Pink Love Potion - It's perfect.
5. 
   International Space Cetacean Fragment - The best team
6. 
   Christmas Lights – I just love Christmas and the holiday season so much.
7. 
   Galaxy Swirl - ISC crew
8. 
   Ocean Pearl - Poliwag crew
9. 
   Sheep Plush
10. 
    Sweet Feather (only in my dreams!)
11. 
    Heart Glow Wand (only in my dreams!)
12. 
    Swamp Potion
13. 
    
    
    
    
    Crystal set
14. 
    Jingloid – Pretty cute Christmas gyroid
15. All of the honorable mentions: Rainbow Crescent Moon and Rainbow Jellyfish, Enchanted Bloom, Crescent Moon set, Celeste Chick Plush and Bluebird of Happiness Plush, Asteroid Plush and Shooting Star Plush, Aurora Sky