Top 15 Collectibles (2023 Version)

[LadyDestani]

This is always so difficult and it's even harder to narrow it down with all of the amazing new collectibles that keep being released. But allowing for sets and increasing it to 15 helps.

1. Enchanted Bloom!

2. Aurora Sky

3. Potion Set

They're all nice, but these are my top 5 in no particular order.
4. Star Fragments

Again I love them all, but these are in my top tier. I guess you can tell my favorite color schemes.
5. Moon Jellyfish

Among the first true ocean themed collectibles. I hope we see more in the future.
6. Lily of the Valley

7. Wands

These are the only two I own, but they are all beautiful.
8. Aurora Egg

My first favorite collectible. I still remember the thrill of obtaining it after a long search. It will always be precious to me.
9. Blue Mote of Flame

10. Dusty Scroll

11. Ancient Lantern

12. Key to Bell Tree Manor

13. Mushroom Lamps

14. Gradient Feathers

These are my top 2 and I'm grateful to own them both.
15. Tetris Grid

My list actually hasn't changed very much. I'd include the new Galaxolotl and ISC star frags in with the set at number 4. I think I'd also move the Aurora Egg to Honorable Mention just because the background doesn't go with any of my other favorite collectibles. Then I'd put the Crescent Moon set somewhere in the 5 to 8 range with the white, blue, purple, and green ones as my favorites.

 

[.: Meri :.]

It's been almost a year since I posted here so... time to update my list!! I think I'm gonna need at least a top 25. help

1. 
   Enchanted Bloom - Still the best collectible ever imo!! I love it so so much.
2. 
   Shooting Star - WHY did I put this so low on my list last time. It is gorgeous. Incredible. I will be wishing my hardest in any future raffles starring it—
3. 
   Special Snowflake - Very happy that I was able to bring this one home It's so elegant and I love wintry aesthetics.
4. 
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   Crescent Moons - no but for real a literal dream collectible of mine basically since joining was "literally just a crescent moon in the sky" and I never thought it would happen and yet??? I love these so much. White, Yellow, and Blue are my favorites but I had to include the whole set.
5. 
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   Star Fragments - Whatever Lost Fragment 004.MB will look like you can just go ahead and include it here. The number of fragments has only grown since last time and so has my love for them!! pink frag come home
6. 
   Lily of the Valley - My favorite IRL and in-game flower!! Tried telling myself I only needed one but they're too pretty and now I desperately need at least one full row of them. ;v; The framing and colors of this one are honestly perfect!!
7. 
   
   
   
   
   Crystals - They're pretty and shiny and the colors?? Immaculate. Also the dark green Enchanted Forest Fair background is one of my absolute favorites now
8. 
   
   Rosewater Potions - I love all the potions but lowkey I want these to become a set of their own in all sorts of rose colors?? I already associate the blue one with Code: Realize but my Ib-loving heart would die for a yellow rosewater potion, a complete trio and I wouldn't say no to a deeper red to better match Ib herself! or white, also bc Code: Realize. or orange. or—
9. 
   Mermaid Scale Halloweaster Egg - green/blue/purple palettes give me serotonin, straight up. the gold accents and the dark background make this one
10. 
    Stardust Easter Egg - The color scheme is so striking and pretty and y'all can probably tell that I'm weak for blue and/or starry things by now ;v;
11. 
    Frost Easter Egg - That deep bright blue and the snowflake pattern?? so freaking pretty.
12. 
    Aurora Easter Egg - the blue?? the aurora borealis theme?? love her
13. 
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    Feathers - this is technically one set right? right?? I cannot get over how pretty these are!! I love the colors, and they're so aesthetically pleasing and versatile! also I need more of those super soft and pretty pastel pavé feathers pls. imagine blue, yellow, or green versions
14. 
    Galaxy Easter Egg - cannot believe I relegated this to honorable mentions last time ;; I love it so much and I dream of owning one someday, but I can't help that there's too many beautiful collectibles out there!!
15. 
    Aurora Sky - absolutely gorgeous and one of my treasured few "rainbow" collectibles that I actually own!! still hoping my IRL dream of seeing the aurora someday will soon come true

Honorable mentions: almost all the unlisted potions, mushroom lamps, flowers, and birthstones, Zen Easter Egg, Spring Sakura, Key Lime Pie, Yule Log
okay yeah I think I failed on the "top 15" front

 

[nightglow]

I feel like my list changed quite a bit again since this summer. I'll have to update it after Christmas
The staff always make such interesting collectibles.

 

[CometCatcher]

The order here does matter, but minimally.

1. 
   Sweet Feather. This thing is GORGEOUS! I hope they get re-released someday, because goodness, I don't think it's possible for me to ever get one otherwise.
2. 
   Celeste Chick Plush. My favorite Animal Crossing character ever (what a sweetie!), IN ADORABLE PLUSH FORM? I lost my mind when I saw her! So happy I got her.
3. 
   Heart Glow Wand. Used to own one of these, but had to trade for Celeste Chick Plush + more, because...well, I rank Celeste higher.
4. 
   Dreamy Egg. THIS EGG IS SO PRETTY AAA it pairs so well with the Celeste Chick Plush! I'm so happy I managed to get one!
5. 
   Crescent Moon Glow Wand. So so so happy I got this ages ago as a TBT Fair Bucket of Paint Favorite! It's so pretty.
6. 
   Aurora Egg. Wow. GORGEOUS. STUNNING. SPECTACULAR.
7. 
   White Feather. Like freshly fallen snow.
8. 
   Galaxy Easter Egg. Just wow.
9. 
   Star Glow Wand. Highly coveted, and for good reason.
10. 
    Pink Feather. Pink!
11. 
    Bluebird of Happiness Plush. I love birds SO much. This bird is so adorable and sweet, and it truly does bring happiness. Love this little guy.
12. 
    
    Star fragments, especially white and pink. These guys are so pretty! Love that night sky look.
13. 
    
    
    Crescent moons, especially white, pink, and purple. These pair so well with the star fragments and are also way more affordable. Win.
14. 
    Crescent Moon Easter Egg. This egg is so pretty and has such Sailor Moon vibes. Matches so well with the Bluebird of Happiness.
15. 
    Loveball. So cute!

 

[cornimer]

I don't know if these are 100% in order, but here are my current top 15:

1. Green Pinwheel
2. Space Whale
3. Yoshi Egg
4. Flower Glow Wand
5. Splat Egg
6. Rainbow Feather
7. Kaleidoclover
8. Magenta Pinwheel
9. Aurora Sky
10. Red Balloon & Green Balloon
11. Bloodshot Potion
12. Sweetheart Egg
13. Rainbow Candy
14. Dino Plushie
15. Prismatic Egg

Honorable mentions: Invader, Goomba, Party Popper

 

[cornimer]

I don't know if these are 100% in order, but here are my current top 15:

1. Green Pinwheel
2. Space Whale
3. Yoshi Egg
4. Flower Glow Wand
5. Splat Egg
6. Rainbow Feather
7. Kaleidoclover
8. Magenta Pinwheel
9. Aurora Sky
10. Red Balloon & Green Balloon
11. Bloodshot Potion
12. Sweetheart Egg
13. Rainbow Candy
14. Dino Plushie
15. Prismatic Egg

Honorable mentions: Invader, Goomba, Party Popper

After this event I need to update this list to replace red balloon with pink balloon! The pink balloon is such a beautiful colour - it catches my eye immediately when people use it in lineups. So glad I was able to get 3!

 

[Zinnia.]

1. Jeremy's JPEG Resetti egg - Bring it back please, I'd love to have a full row of them! I laughed so hard when I found out that it existed but then I was disappointed when I realized that it was removed D:

2. Fresh feather - The soft gradient and sky background are very pretty and go well together.

3. Summer shell - The shade of blue is really nice and I love the beach background with the clear sky. I'm so happy that it was made tradeable.

4. Lily of the valley - One of the first collectibles I bought from the shop. I love the shading on the leaves and how glowy the flower itself is.

5. Sheep plush - It's so soft and cute! I've always had my eye on it so I was super excited when I won it in a raffle last year.

6. Aurora egg - Very detailed and shiny! I'd love to own one someday, maybe it'll get rereleased during an upcoming egg hunt

7. Blue crescent moon - It's simple but cute!

8. Butterfly wand - I like how colorful it is compared to the rest of the glow wands.

9. Pink toy hammer - bonk >:D

10. Raven wings potion - It looks like it's full of stars! The wings look great on it too.

11. Caustic & Pearlescent crystals

12. Black feather

13. Green and MB frags

14. Blue heart & Pink bunny balloons

15. Silver mailbox

 

[Hyoon]

i have a preference for mostly pink or purple things but here goes:

1. heart glow wand

- doesn't need explanation she will always be that girl imo
2. pink fragment/moon

- similar to why i like the heart wand. i just really like the galaxy theme + pink combo
3. galaxy egg

- beautiful what more can i say. galaxy theme always hit
4. blue/white fragment

- kinda lumping them all together here and they look so good together ughhh
5. blue/white/purple moon

- all of the moons are so pretty tbh but i will pick my favorite colors
6. sweet feather/balloon

- it goes without mention that this color scheme is amazing. more sweet colored items plsssss
7. crescent egg

- i love the moon and the shiny-ness of the egg
8. planet glow wand

- more wanddsss
9. love potion

- the only thing that stops me from liking this more is i dislike that this gray background only works with other candies/potions. it would be too powerful otherwise
10. moon bunny

- soooooooo cute ahhh ;u;
11. plushes

- i generally like them all cause they're pastel and they're cute. a combination that can't go wrong

collectibles i can only dream of: