Unpopular Animal Crossing opinions?

- Gulliver is an underrated character and deserves more love

- Gold roses are ugly

- The second floor of the museum in New Leaf is the most useless thing ever. The fact that they
not brought back the observatory for this is a shame. Celeste deserve better

- Tom Nook isn't such a bad character as people always say

- The Astro series looks dumb

- I miss Blather's explanations from the previous games when you donated stuff to him. I didn't like
it that they shorted it in NL

- Phyllis > Pelly
 
Perlounette said:
- The second floor of the museum in New Leaf is the most useless thing ever. The fact that they
not brought back the observatory for this is a shame. Celeste deserve better.

- I miss Blather's explanations from the previous games when you donated stuff to him. I didn't like
it that they shorted it in NL
Click to expand...

I've seen many people mention they miss the observatory and Blather's long winded explanations.

I do agree the second floor NL is pretty lame, but I'm currently using that space to display the theme furniture in my town Crystal. So far I have the Halloween set and the Balloon set on display.

Speaking the museum. I really hope they do something different for the museum in NH. To this day I have never completed any of my museums in the AC games. I have only completed the fossils room in my town Sol in NL. Throughout every AC game the museum has pretty much been the same. Collect fish, bugs, fossils, and paintings. Maybe they can add new collection? Other ways to donate? Just anything to spice it up a bit.
 
I think that achhd is underrated, I love the game almost as much as New leaf.
 
Last edited:
Oh I have one. I actually don't like Mabel at all. The days where you warm up to Sable she is always just telling her to shout up and don't talk about problems there having for years. That there prices are too cheap and they work way to much. I think she is really toxic in manipulating her sister. She is totally just getting advantage of that her sister is so kind and shy.

Also I don't really like Kapp'n he is a really sexist dude tho. Always talking about getting the ladys and stuff. I don't really know about his dialog as a girl but I think it will be as sexist.

I actually like Nook tho. He is giving you a house basically for free and if you decide to never pay the debt you don't even need to. I could just say no money no house and let you sleep on the ground like. Why is everyone hating him so much?

*dusting off this thread for good*
 
i love tom nook, he is such a kind and amazing character, also my 3rd fave npc after sable and kicks ☆

marshal is pretty basic, i used to like him in NL but now i just find him kinda lame

i don't like jingle (sorry) he's too cheery

and finally, i love jock villagers, they are so funny when they talk about lifting weights because most of them are so tiny lol
 
I'm not sure if this is an unpopular opinion but I kind of think that the Reset Center in New Leaf is a little bit underwhelming. It's just a small room that can only be accessed at certain times and also resetting without saving isn't something I do so I pretty much never see Mr. Resetti.
 
1. Raymond is not that interesting. I personnaly don't find him cute.
2. Happy Home Designer was a very fun game to play, the concept was great.
3. Wilbur is very nice. Maybe because I saw some pictures of him depicted as a human.
4. Isabelle is a terrible character. Yes yes, I don't want to explain this one, but I hated her for years. I don't understand why everyone loves her. She's (for me) annoying and a quite naive. Yes she does her best but... urgh. I don't care about your life.

🤭
 
EDIT: oops I had already commented this and forgot

Well I'll add the usual: I don't like Raymond (though it doesn't feel as unpopular..)
 
New unpopular opinion: I don't get the whole issue with the beans. They're just... throwable beans. You throw them and that's it. I don't see how they're "much worse" in NH, they do the same thing
 
Unpopular Opinion: I don't like all the clothes in the game. I just stick with my custom clothes all the time but it sucks how in New Horizions you can't customize pants, socks, or shoes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DVD
Sisterly villagers are actually the best, and it’s kinda sad that outside of Cherry (who is one of my favorites), they don’t get as much love as the normal, peppy, and snooty villagers. Don’t get me wrong, I love the other types of female villagers too, but sisterly villagers are really really good!

I didn’t realize that Marshall was popular until I got more into the community, but I don’t really get why he’s popular? Maybe someone can explain.

As someone who had Stitches and Lily on their original island, those two are a little overrated, especially Stitches. Lily is nice, but she’s not my favorite normal type by a long shot, and Stitches is cute, but he kinda got annoying after a while, even though he was the only lazy villager on my island. It might just be how NH dialogue is written, though.

While I wouldn’t say he’s my absolute favorite by any means, Angus is actually not that bad, and people need to give that boomer of a bull a chance. I wouldn’t be upset if I got him on my island again (although I would prefer Fang, obviously).
 
Ohohoho, I've been wanting to share this opinion for so long, remember, we're entitled to our own opinions, but I thoroughly dislike Isabelle.

I know she's now the poster pup for the series, but I absolutely dislike her with a passion. She was okay to start with in New Leaf, and I thought, yeah she seems sweet, but I just find her annoying. I also think she's a bit too 'happy' and 'peppy'. I've nothing wrong at all with people being optimistic and excited etc, but it just seems fake to me. I know she's super popular now with fans and everything, but I also don't agree with her being the poster pup for the game. I think there's a lot more characters who should be the 'mascot' for the series. I know Nook is also kinda a mascot for the series, and though he's a swindly little rogue, I don't mind Nook. Anyway, that's my input on that :'D
 
VividRevolution said:
Sisterly villagers are actually the best, and it’s kinda sad that outside of Cherry (who is one of my favorites), they don’t get as much love as the normal, peppy, and snooty villagers. Don’t get me wrong, I love the other types of female villagers too, but sisterly villagers are really really good!
Click to expand...

Absolutely agreed!! I love the sisterly personality!
 
Alright here goes

Marshal is better than Raymond (i don't get why everyone loves raymond I like his heterochromic eyes but that's it).
Crankies are super sweet.
New Horizons hourly music is bad compared to New Leaf and other games.
Tom Nook is an greedy tanuki who's plotting against us all.
Marshal is adorable and deserves the world.
 
ACCF was not a bad AC game.
ACGC dialogue is a little OTT. (ACWW hits the spot)

The beta trees in ACNL looked so good and I'm disappointed they scrapped them and never returned. Seeing the branches was wesome and I hate they changed it. Why not add it as a new tree even???


1613264950391.png

2010 BETA
1613265014286.png

2011 BETA

ACNH 5PM is horrible.
ACGC music from 11PM–5AM is horrible.
 
carackobama said:
Just as the title says - do you have any unpopular Animal Crossing opinions and if so, what are they?

Personally, I’m not a huuuge fan of most lazy and cranky villagers (except my sweet boi Beau <3). I also kind of hate gyroids, they freak me out a lot lmao. Character wise, I’m not sure I get the hype around certain popular villagers such as most of the wolves and Marshal. Also Celeste is by far my favourite NPC (tied with the Able Sisters) and I don’t think she gets enough love.

Let me know yours!
Click to expand...

Any of the rhino or ant eating ones creep me out!
 
I can't stand Isabelle - especially in New Horizons. She was cute in New Leaf but they watered her down so much that she's almost a completely different character. She just seems so boring and lifeless in NH.
 
NH feels like a vastly superior version of NL, and I spent a lotta time in NL and somewhat liked it, but it was frustrating at times with all the mayor things.
Oh and I agree with Isabella feeling like a throw in, her role is kinda something that I expected (or wanted) Pelly or Phyllis to do.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

danienby
Help! Animal Crossing Memories
Replies
3
Views
231
Suguri
Suguri
famiquinn
How do you decide which Animal Crossing game/town you commit to?
Replies
4
Views
211
famiquinn
famiquinn
DaCoSim
New animal crossing game idea
Replies
2
Views
104
Alolan_Apples
Alolan_Apples
Chronos314_XD
The Flanderization of Animal Crossing's Characters and Dialouge
Replies
5
Views
408
Alolan_Apples
Alolan_Apples
Bilaz
Play ... if:
Replies
0
Views
106
Bilaz
Bilaz
Back
Top