This one from Genesis is interesting. Only released as the last track on an EP titled “Spot the Pigeon” in 1977, it was the final Genesis song to feature Steve Hackett on guitar before he left the band. The first half of the song features Phil Collins singing about a violent guy in jail who persuades the governor to get pardoned, only to immediately repeat the actions that caused him to get arrested in the first place. It’s all-acoustic like, before it suddenly picks up and turns into a prog rock frenzy for the second half.
While the band did maintain a style like this for their songs up until at least
Genesis (1983), you could say that this song is the exact halfway point that the Phil Collins-led Genesis starting to shift their style from prog rock to more pop-oriented. The previous album (
Wind & Wuthering) was more prog-oriented, while the next album (
…And Then There Were Three…) featured more pop-oriented tracks. You could tell between those two albums that Steve Hackett played a rather big role for Genesis’ prog style of play. After leaving the band, his absence started to become more clear with the band’s shift to a pop direction later on.
I like both the Collins and Peter Gabriel eras personally, regardless of opinions.