The internet back then was so freeing and not just like my current life, where in part, it is “freeing” for lack of better options.
Of course, I was a kid back then. I can’t verify this but I've heard with neuroplasticity, your brain as a child does absorb more, for example colors look more vivid and not just due to some naive nostalgia.
It made websites a big deal, but they really were different then. In the 90’s, every site was a little personal GeoCities page, but the late 00’s were where some of those old pages were still holding out. Fake gaming rumors and cheats were still prominent- there was a big culture of it on YouTube, as much as people forget that part of that site. In general, there was still a lot of mystery in life to discuss on the web because we didn’t have as many… organised sources for information, let’s say. Anyway, I remember using Webs back when it was a free service, kids were still making their own sites back then! Point being, the 00’s in general were the perfect fusion of those old clunky sites, and a more developed web 2.0 that had not had its edges filed off for homogenous presentation like today. The most visually customisable “mainstream” site I can think of is Tumblr and it’s dwarfed by larger, more visually boring sites.
Ironically privacy was better practiced then, distinctively before Facebook and Google’s services getting even more popular. If you used your real name anywhere, it would only be on your email.
YouTube truly was better with lesser ads and of course that old web design wasn’t the smoothest, but they didn’t have as much anti-consumer design on it. I remember when you could completely customise your page there and the pages had comments. To a degree that site was actually a social space, which helped foster some of the stuff like the YTP community that people generally remember those years for. There really were very few ads. When they put ads on the iOS apps AT ALL it was a massive deal… ‘cause yeah back in the day they didn’t even have ads there. If you remember the old skeumorphic iPod icon for YouTube then you get a veteran’s discount by the way.
I could also count some of the old App Store shenanigans as a part of the old Internet. The stuff that topped the charts was so different, and honest good games made it up there. A lot of those games had their own weird mini-communities on unique forums/chatrooms integrated in the games.
As far as games in general go the vibe with online randoms was very different and you could easily make friends since lobbies were set up in a way you would be repeatedly playing with the same people, and on Nintendo games where you had to exchange friend codes, doing that was a big deal and made it very personal. You can just put in dream addresses now, and that on its own changed the experience, back in the day if you wanted to hang out in AC you would be getting personal town tours, and asking people not to seed you, stuff like that.
Also, having a lot of different accounts/profiles and showing them off was a lot more common, because things weren’t consolidated on megasites or social apps. I think it’s charming. Personally during those specific years, I joined my first forum ever.
The bad thing about the old Internet is that people were definitely more casually rude. I don’t like how puritan some of the Internet is now but definitely back in the day more of it had to be called out. I do think there was better discussion back then with the slower pace of the internet but hell man I can go on forever and I’m trying to wrap this up. Looking back on shock sites is funny for me but I was never hit by one and objectively I don’t really think they’re funny, it’s more, “damn that was a weird thing in my life I’m glad I dodged”.
I’m honestly glad I grew up during that era though, I feel like the loss of those kid-friendly MMOs is because the Internet is already trying to rope in and advertise to children (which is disgusting) and not actually protecting them regardless of what lawmakers say. At best the social media spaces and influencers of today are a worse influence on kids. It’s another way the old Internet was more personal and genuine. Some of these things are just like, if you know you know. But you don’t know what I would give to go back to Internet like that man, it’s truly special in history.