Totally there with you.
My laptop's keyboard is god-awful because it's so flat and uncomfortable. It's like pushing down on rubber, and most of the time I let go of it too soon out of habit. I, too, like having that tactile feedback. I want a physical button that I can hear click when I press it. I want to know what I pressed and when I can let go of the key.
I could get a completely blank keyboard if it's mechanical and do just fine.
If it's flat, I have no idea what I'm doing, even with the keys painted on it to guide me.