I have Zucker, Lucky and Erik but I picked Erik because he's adorable and one of my all-time favourites. He is also really good to have in the wintertime. Cranston is actually my newest villager, ironically, and is my 5th lazy.
I may be biased because I absolutely adore Erik, but I voted him because I just think he's so sweet! although ultimately if you have your heart set on Zucker, go for zucker! there's no point getting a villager you don't want because a poll says he's cute
Seeing as you're island hopping I'd probably go for whoever you meet first of these~ But then I have no patience and prefer to island hop without having a specific villager in mind Lazy is my favourite personality type and all of the ones you've listed are cuties so I'm sure you'll love whoever you end up finding ~
From this list, I would get Walker, no doubt. He's one of my favorite villagers so it's really an easy answer for me. But, if you already like Zucker better than the others, I think you pretty much have your answer already. Go with the one you like better!
Thank you for the responses so far, everybody! I think I’m going to go with Zucker, but if I meet anyone else on this list I’d probably invite them as I’m island hopping and don’t want to stretch my luck, like @ReeBear said.
I’m setting the poll to close in an hour because I’m pretty much decided, but feel free to put your thoughts here anyway!
Oh this is so tricky! The lazies have some of my favourite designs and honestly I don’t think you could go wrong with any of your choices.
I chose Erik though because while I’ve never had him he’s quickly become one of villagers I hope to have one day! He just looks so darn cute I’ve had Zucker in New Leaf though and he’s really cute as well!