My favourite is the ghastly lantern! I'd definitely like to get one or two, though realistically I'm not sure if that's doable since I'll be focusing on the love potion and/or wix candy, so those may have to wait lol.
I like all of them, as you could probably expect, but I think my favorite is probably Edgourd since I'm always looking forward to new jack-o'-lantern collectibles being introduced. Booton, though, is either like a tie for first place or a close second place, as he is precious. Zipper T. Balloon's a close third too.
Crow Plush is up there but I wish its beak was a little larger or something so I wouldn't need to like get close to the screen to see it; I kind of want two of them regardless. Old Game Boy is cool and I want one or two, Half-Eaten Cupcake is nice and I like that we now have a second color of cotton candy with the addition of the Pink Cotton Candy; hopefully there will eventually also be a blue one at some point in the future.
The only one I don't really see myself getting any use out of is the Ghastly Lantern, but it's still neat and I'm glad others like it more.
I think my favourite of the new ones is the Old Gameboy. I don't plan on getting one for myself but I like that it exists. After that I really like the Ghastly Lantern and Edgourd.
I definitely love the Cursed Lantern, but for regular ones I'd pick the Edgourd. So happy for a green pumpkin.
I've a feeling I'll like user-created collectible too.
I think Edgourd is my favorite but I decided not to buy him because I have a really cute line-up in mind for the pink cotton candy, ghostly kitty ice cream cone, and love potion
Hopefully enough people buy Edgourd and have him up for sale for a while!
Also love that Gameboy but idk what I would do with it