Which Animal crossing game is better

[frostyfuz]

The Nintendo 64 version.

..oh yes, I went there. =p
No really, the original kept me interested a lot longer than the Wild World. And the addition of holidays made me happy, and most definitely the music was better.
I still want more bg music options for City Folk when it comes out. Maybe they'll give us some through downloadable content.

 

[Gaminger]

It was difrent, way bigger and far more appealing. And the holidays and special events were far more intresting, you could get a lot of cool sets from those. Caracters like Wendell had a purpouse. Plating trees and the stuff was easier and looked better... well, it was difrent. I'm not sure but the DS version was a big redesign from the N64 version, it was like a new art dirction or something. If you look at the first animal crossing ds screens known it looked almost exactly like the Gamecube version, i bet it was the Gamecube (more likely the n64 version) running on the DS. They were experimenting, until they thought it would be better to change some things, probably even to acomodate to the DS's limited capacities.

And the Wii version will take the best out of both versions i guess. Holidays are back as you have seen and some new ones have been added.

 

[nintendofan510]

gc version, i love that nostalgic feeling, which acww will probably get when accf comes out

 

[MitchHanson]

GC version ftw

 

[Cottonball]

totally Acww

 

[Zephent]

Original, In fact im looking forward to City folk because of how much it looks like GC, I may only buddy select people to keep its nostalgia factor.

 

[MitchHanson]

Well CF should beat GCN and WW combined!

 

[AC guy]

GC way better cause the NES was there and was a minigame but when WW came out there was only walk around and wi-fi WW wasnt as great as the first 1

 

[ZAR]

Well CF should beat GCN and WW combined!

Hopefully it will. I want an AC game that's better then the near perfect AC:GC. AC:WW didn't meet that standered. City Folk will beat WW easily though. ^_^

 

[JJH]

That's really hard for me.

As far as gameplay aspects go, I prefer GCN. It had better holidays, events, and just general aspects of the town.

But I still like Wild World, for the reason that a lot of people don't; it's a hand held. I don't have to sit down in front of a TV to play, I can play in the car on a three hour long drive, lying in bed at 2 A.M. when I can't sleep, pretty much anywhere I choose. For the most part.

But in the end, I'd have to say GCN. If you could take the GCN game, downsize it to a DS game, but keep everything the same, (Obviously, graphics and whatnot may have to be lessened a bit. Or not. I don't know.) you'd have one amazing Animal Crossing. On the other hand, make Wild World a Gamecube game, and you really wouldn't get much more out of it.

But that's all just my opinion.

 

[Bee]

Definitely the GCN one. Better holidays, better characters, better music. Eh.

 

[Away236]

city folk one..lol

 

[Megamannt125]

Wild World is fun when your bored or on the go but ive put more time into GC by far

 

[Khengi]

Both are good, but AC GCN has that nostalgia on me big time. Kinda like Pokemon Silver. Had that gave for more than 8 years.

 

[coffeebean!]

I haven't played city folk, but I think the first one will always be better. =]

 

[Garrett x50 cal]

city folk it combines both great games into one

 

[SuperAnthony]

I like ACWW alot, a big step in Animal Crossing, but then again, ACWW didnt hold onto some cool stuff that the first one had. So i like both.

 

[neverbeenkrissed]

But I still like Wild World, for the reason that a lot of people don't; it's a hand held. I don't have to sit down in front of a TV to play, I can play in the car on a three hour long drive, lying in bed at 2 A.M. when I can't sleep, pretty much anywhere I choose. For the most part.

this is exactly how i feel. i was able to play WW for a whole year for this reason. vacations, etc. when i didn't have access to a TV/GC.

i did miss GC holidays though.

 

[neverbeenkrissed]

Definitely the GCN one. Better holidays, better characters, better music. Eh.

ahh i forgot about the music too... far superior.

 

[Tola]

Who the heck voted for anything BUT the first game? It's ten times better. Not only was its music many times better composed, but it was better to listen to. There were more villagers able to be fitted in your town, HOLIDAYS were HUGE - they added a vivid life and wholesomeness to the game which Wild World completely and utterly neglected. Flat world was better than the rolling log in many cases. Money trees were GOLD. Acres. NES games. The four houses were cozily tucked in the same acre. Police Station. Train (more quaint).

And to top it off, it was the first of its kind.