Which new potion collectible is your favorite?

[~Kilza~]

I'm surprised at how many people are saying the Rosewater Potion is red when it's more pink (reddish pink at most, I suppose). I feel like the Blue Rosewater Potion looks the nicer of the two tbh.

 

[Croconaw]

I'm surprised at how many people are saying the Rosewater Potion is red when it's more pink (reddish pink at most, I suppose). I feel like the Blue Rosewater Potion looks the nicer of the two tbh.

It’s definitely pink. The only hint of red I see is the reflection on the bottom.

 

[princess.looking.for.frog]

I love both so much, but the red would be easier for me to lineup because I own like, no blue collectibles. but, the blue one is very vibrant and pretty!

 

[IonicKarma]

im surprised that the blue potion is winning, usually pink is very popular around here o:

 

[Croconaw]

The Love Potion is pink and we don’t have a blue potion. The blue one we have is more teal than anything. Variety is cool.

 

[daringred_]

blue, and i'm so glad to see it's winning because i really thought everyone would want pink even though we have the love potion collectible. (it's very exclusive, i know, but it's still there, and it might be a prize again in future valentine's day events.) blue's my favorite color, so i've always wanted more blue collectibles, including a potion.

 

[Croconaw]

blue, and i'm so glad to see it's winning because i really thought everyone would want pink even though we have the love potion collectible. (it's very exclusive, i know, but it's still there, and it might be a prize again in future valentine's day events.) blue's my favorite color, so i've always wanted more blue collectibles, including a potion.

Yes, I’m donating all of my fairy dust to Farley for that blue potion. I’m not sure how much I’ll get, but it’s all going to Farley!

 

[S.J.]

They are both stunning, and it's really hard to choose between the two! For the sake of the poll, I chose the (red) Rosewater Potion.

 

[Bluebellie]

I like the blue one the best, but I’d love to have both.

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

I think I prefer the pink one, though the blue one is very nice!

 

[Crash]

really love the blue one. the regular rosewater potion is also very pretty but it feels a little redundant because we already have both a red and a pink potion? whereas the eerie star potion is more teal than blue.

i really just want a black potion with a skull charm that's like potion of death or something :')

 

[AlyssaAC]

I like both, so hopefully we’ll be able to get them and not just one of them. Though, I’m more towards the rose water potion a little more because it looks like a nice shade of pinkish red. Of course, I am in agreement with everyone else that the blue one really stands out.

 

[nightglow]

I'm not big into potion collectibles but the blue one is nice.

 

[-Mars-]

I just logged on and saw these beautiful potions
I'm so excited because I love the potion collectables but I've never got a chance to own one because they are really expensive for me
I like the pink/red one a little bit more
I'm really happy Justin made new rules to help the community work to together to get these

 

[Kattea]

I love that shade of pink, but can appreciate the vibrancy of the blue.

 

[Croconaw]

Regardless of the potion you prefer, can we just appreciate the fact that they have a dark background? The dark background collectibles are the best.

 

[Aerith]

Red is my favorite, but I love both

 

[JellyBeans]

i think they’re both absolutely gorgeous, but I do have to agree despite loving the pink/red the vibrancy of the blue is amazing!! im just glad that (provided we reach the targets) we can get one of each instead of having to pick one or the other

 

[deana]

I'm not even a pink person and I think the colour of the rosewater potion is really beautiful. (Pink is firmly where I stand in the pink/red debate) If we can unlock both I do plan to get one of each.
That being said though, my favourite is definitely blue rosewater potion not only for it's colouring but also because I love the idea of it being made of the oh so annoying to breed blue roses. So Farley is getting all my dust usual

 

[Mutti]

Both are cute, i dont have a particular fave but i know everyone is trying to get farley's collectable first, so i will try and help build up serenas funds, i think we can get both of them as we work so well as a community!