Which Peppy Cub Is The Best?

[ChrissyAndFrancineLover]

Hi!
So i'm thinking of doing an all cub island! The cubs i have so far are:
Maple
Stitches
Marty

I'll be getting more,soon. But here is the thing:Idk which cub to get for my peppy:Cheri or Bluebear?(Or maybe i can get both someday we'll see)

I hope that i can get some help with this!
PS:I do have Cheri's amiibo if that helps.

 

[Dunquixote]

I’ve only had Bluebear and she didn’t click with me, but only because I had two other peppies and I grew tired of their identical dialogue really quick. Personally, I like Bluebear’s design a little more, but I also think Cheri is really cute. Sonce you have Cheri’s amiibo, I’d suggest maybe trying Bluebear first if you can find her. You can always use the amiibo card later when you are 100% sure who you want in your final villager lineup.

Post automatically merged: Apr 17, 2021

You can always have both if you like them equally.

 

[JellyBeans]

I've never had Bluebear but I have had Cheri multiple times over the years and loved her, so perhaps I'm a little biased but I'd go for Cheri! but like dunquixote said since you have her amiibo, it could definitely be worth getting bluebear first + then switching her out for cheri if you don't click that much c:

 

[LambdaDelta]

cheri's one of my favs, so lol

 

[ChrissyAndFrancineLover]

I’ve only had Bluebear and she didn’t click with me, but only because I had two other peppies and I grew tired of their identical dialogue really quick. Personally, I like Bluebear’s design a little more, but I also think Cheri is really cute. Sonce you have Cheri’s amiibo, I’d suggest maybe trying Bluebear first if you can find her. You can always use the amiibo card later when you are 100% sure who you want in your final villager lineup.

Post automatically merged: Apr 17, 2021

You can always have both if you like them equally.

Yes that’s really smart to do! I’ve had Bluebear once,but very briefly so idk what’s she’s like anymore,so I’m going to try and find Bluebear first! Thank you so much!

 

[Moonlight.]

i think cheri's a lot cuter, but honestly i would recommend both if you're doing an all cub island, that way you can have both cuties

 

[Felix Felicis]

I love Bluebear personally! Surely because I had her once.

 

[VanitasFan26]

I would say Bluebear because she has my favorite color and her home interior is really good that fits the style that I like the best.

 

[Etown20]

I've had both and like them both. I voted Cheri because I think she is a bit underrated, but you can't go wrong with either. Having them both could be fun too because they seem like friends - cherry/blueberry.

Here's a recent photo of Cheri from my island

 

[Halloqueen]

I very much prefer Cheri's design, and you mentioned that you have her amiibo card, so I would definitely recommend her. That said, depending on which Cubs you intend to have overall, maybe there would still be a way to have both?

On a side note, I noticed that there aren't any Cubs who have the Smug personality, so you might want to have one of those around for at least a while so you can get their Reactions. Maybe Beardo or Klaus since they're still bears, just fully grown?

 

[ChrissyAndFrancineLover]

I've had both and like them both. I voted Cheri because I think she is a bit underrated, but you can't go wrong with either. Having them both could be fun too because they seem like friends - cherry/blueberry.

Here's a recent photo of Cheri from my island

View attachment 369625

Aww she looks adorable!

Post automatically merged: Apr 17, 2021

I very much prefer Cheri's design, and you mentioned that you have her amiibo card, so I would definitely recommend her. That said, depending on which Cubs you intend to have overall, maybe there would still be a way to have both?

On a side note, I noticed that there aren't any Cubs who have the Smug personality, so you might want to have one of those around for at least a while so you can get their Reactions. Maybe Beardo or Klaus since they're still bears, just fully grown?

Yes I also noticed that there aren’t any smug cubs,coincidentally,I do also have Beardo and Klaus’ amiibo’s,so much thank you for the suggestion!

 

[-Blue-]

I never knew they were both peppy. I thought Cheri was snooty and Bluebear was normal by the way they're designed. I guess it all depends on who you like the most aesthetically. Or maybe what house fits your theme better if you're being technical.

The only peppy cub I ever had was Pinky in NL. She was one of my originals and I never thought I would keep her, but she remained as one of my mainstays throughout the years.

 

[litilravnur]

I voted for Cheri. I only have had her and I really like her bubbly personality and the way she talks to me. Don't know if it was just me but it was quite easy to befriend her and obtain her photo

 

[0ni]

I personally like Bluebear best of the two - but that's just because Cheri's face makes it seem like she is always judging me with her lil' smirk and side-eye

 

[Antonio]

Bluebear because he can sing the blues

 

[Blueskyy]

I had to vote Cheri. I love that she has a feisty look to her. She’s one of my favorite cubs (along with like 10 others).

 

[Mr.Fox]

I've had both and neither were keepers.

I had an all bear town in NL and tried to work a couple of the cubs in here and there...none of them clicked.
Kody was probably the closest.

Anyways, Cheri looks better IMO, but if I remember correctly her 'tra la la' is an annoying catchphrase.

 

[Marshmallows]

I love Bluebear. She's very cute, though for a long time I thought she was a male. I had her on my island for a while, but let her go because I already had too many peppies. Cheri seems nice too. I say get both.

 

[Serabee]

Personally, I like Cheri. Bluebear is cute but I feel like her design looks more like a normal villager (by which I mean... I thought she WAS a normal villager). But I think Cheri has a sassier, more popstar-esque appearance. I'm also biased, though, because my favorite color is red, and my least favorite color is blue, lol. Though I still think Bluebear is a cute villager and would even consider having her on my island, I personally think Cheri is cuter and looks peppier!

 

[Hype]

I vote for blue bear because I had her in my first town.