Which villager do you think has the ugliest house (interior and/or exterior)?

[Orieii]

Love Kid Cat to bits, but his house is a bit.. Like, dear lord! I understand he’s obsessed with the color red and everything, but his house exterior is kinda overkill Kinda sad his house is such trash. It doesn’t match my island aesthetic at all, but I love him so much, so I’ll try to make it work And his house interior is pretty much the same as it was in NL, which was also trash imo *sighs* Me and him have a lot of work to do, lol

Post automatically merged: May 7, 2020

Okay, I hate having to keep coming back here because I don't wanna seem overly critical and some of the villagers in this game have truly gorgeous houses, but--
View attachment 254228
Literally what is this? Why? Just looking at it makes me depressed.

I mean, to be fair, I also came across this screenshot of Jacob's RV in New Leaf so I'm guessing his house there is pretty awful too:
View attachment 254229
so like. at least it keeps in line with the theme of his NL house. But I have to ask, did it really have to? Man, poor Jacob... at least the NL version has books to read. And a bed, even if it is a cardboard one. Unless the hay pile in the middle of the NH one is supposed to be a bed? I don't even know anymore.

Now I feel bad for complaining about Kid Cat’s house

 

[Sloom]

decided to add pics for everyone in this thread who didnt attach a pic. (courtesy of nookipedia and the FANDOM wiki)
I was desperate to see all of them so I thought I'd show them to you guys too

Spoiler: Beau

Spoiler: Baabara (exterior)

Spoiler: Lolly

Spoiler: Billy

Spoiler: Default Lazy Starter Home

Spoiler: Coco

Spoiler: Ankha

Spoiler: Jakey (or Jacob if you're an Americanish LOSER)

Spoiler: Anchovy

this one probably wins for my personal least favourite so far

Spoiler: Kid Cat

Spoiler: Mira

Spoiler: Keaton

Spoiler: Zucker (exterior)

Spoiler: Eugene

Spoiler: Raymond's house, for comparison

Spoiler: Stitches (exterior)

EDIT: houses that came after this post!

Spoiler: Tabby

Spoiler: Lucha

Spoiler: Camofrog (exterior)

Spoiler: Hornsby

Spoiler: Zucker

Spoiler: Lucky

Spoiler: Bruce

Spoiler: Avery

Spoiler: Phoebe

this is honestly my fave house in the game lol

Spoiler: Flora

Spoiler: Dom

Spoiler: Octavian (interior & exterior)

Spoiler: Judy

Spoiler: Papi

enjoy!
(also why is Eugene's house literally Raymond's house lmao, they're nothing alike)

just added all the new one's into my dumbass megapost ALSO THE PERSON WHO SAID PHOEBE WILL BE EXECUTED. WRONG. WRONG. (also to be executed: people who said sherb's exterior, bruce's interior and mira's interior. all very incorrect, very bad)

 

[The Hidden Owl]

Part of the reason why half the houses are disappointing/ugly is because the initial game has such a limited amount of furniture to incorporate into the houses. So many villagers have similar concepts and items because they have to literally decorate 400+ villager houses with enough furniture to fill a quarter of an island.

 

[starlightsong]

Part of the reason why half the houses are disappointing/ugly is because the initial game has such a limited amount of furniture to incorporate into the houses. So many villagers have similar concepts and items because they have to literally decorate 400+ villager houses with enough furniture to fill a quarter of an island.

I’m glad to finally see someone else bring this up tbh as it’s a big issue for me—they can add the old furniture sets through updates for me to use, sure, but they’re not gonna update the default villager houses. I’ve definitely noticed some of the houses I feel look really weird and unfitting in this game (Mira’s for example—you can like it if you want and I won’t judge, but I got her in my space themed NL town for her old astro house and now her new house isn’t even a house, it’s just some weird theater...? Also Eugene, he used to have a lot of sleek stuff and so did Roscoe who I think someone here mentioned) have had a lot, if not all, of the furniture they used in NL removed from NH and I’m sure that’s part of the issue.

 

[Fey]

I’m never really a fan of houses that are meant to look like outdoor environments.

Like a few others have said, I also prefer realistic homes with more or less normal furniture. A bed, or at least a couch or similar surface is almost a requirement. I don’t care how beautiful or cohesive an interior is—if it’s just a bathroom or kitchen I won’t be too happy.

Flora’s house offends in every way, because it falls short in each category:
it’s an outdoor environment, lacks a bed, and isn’t even cohesive design-wise! Like really, a flamingo in a...swamp (?!) surrounded by...an alpine landscape? The floor and wall don’t match at all, they are entirely opposing locations/climates. I’m so, so glad mine lives in the default peppy house. Which is actually hella cute imo and suits her style pretty well!

 

[starlightsong]

just added all the new one's into my dumbass megapost ALSO THE PERSON WHO SAID PHOEBE WILL BE EXECUTED. WRONG. WRONG. (also to be executed: people who said sherb's exterior, bruce's interior and mira's interior. all very incorrect, very bad)

lol, i’m not the one who said phoebe and i don’t think her house is ugly but i would like to say this: her wall and flooring are awesome. they fit her really well. i just think that besides that her house is uh, unfurnished and barren tbh? she’s only got like 3 things in there besides the crafting bench and when villagers have houses like that it makes me sad for them and wonder if they can’t afford any furniture so yeah, I’ll probably have her on my island at some point but I’ll need to gift her things to make her house feel more comfy to live in. but at least she has a place to sleep unlike some villagers. and idk why anyone is saying sherb??? hello, his house is so cute!

Post automatically merged: May 7, 2020

I’m never really a fan of houses that are meant to look like outdoor environments.

Like a few others have said, I also prefer realistic homes with more or less normal furniture. A bed, or at least a couch or similar surface is almost a requirement. I don’t care how beautiful or cohesive an interior is—if it’s just a bathroom or kitchen I won’t be too happy.

Flora’s house offends in every way, because it falls short in each category:
it’s an outdoor environment, lacks a bed, and isn’t even cohesive design-wise! Like really, a flamingo in a...swamp (?!) surrounded by...an alpine landscape? The floor and wall don’t match at all, they are entirely opposing locations/climates. I’m so, so glad mine lives in the default peppy house. Which is actually hella cute imo and suits her style pretty well!

tbh i love some of the crazy themed houses and the ones that look like backyards and beaches and stuff!! sometimes realistic houses are cute too, it just depends for me. but i’m with you on the fact that they always should have at least some normal house stuff too, i don’t understand how any villager can just not have a bed of any kind or even only have like 2-3 pieces of furniture and call it a day. those type of things make me sad every single time i see them and NH seems to do it a lot
eta: i just realized this is something that bugs me about beau’s house, which i’ve seen brought up a lot here. i actually like it and it keeps the theme he has in NL, but it occurred to me that his NL house looks cozier because he has a cute little hammock as opposed to a sleeping bag, and a nice table too!

 

[Cadbberry]

I grew to like Rooney, but I gave him to a friend. His house was boxing themed which made sense with his boxing theme... expect he is a cranky. It really bothered me, it looked and felt jock, not like a cranky old guy

 

[cicely]

Okay, I hate having to keep coming back here because I don't wanna seem overly critical and some of the villagers in this game have truly gorgeous houses, but--
View attachment 254228
Literally what is this? Why? Just looking at it makes me depressed.

I mean, to be fair, I also came across this screenshot of Jacob's RV in New Leaf so I'm guessing his house there is pretty awful too:
View attachment 254229
so like. at least it keeps in line with the theme of his NL house. But I have to ask, did it really have to? Man, poor Jacob... at least the NL version has books to read. And a bed, even if it is a cardboard one. Unless the hay pile in the middle of the NH one is supposed to be a bed? I don't even know anymore.

his tropical bird appearance and the difference between his animal forest house and this makes it seem like an unintentional environmental message LOL

 

[DJStarstryker]

Ugh! I'm unsure about which jock should be my final one, but definitely not going with Kid Cat. I hate that interior.

 

[Shinjukuwu]

I don't have her, but Flora's interior is so disappointingly bad! It was so cute and pretty in New Leaf, and very much her. This time they have flung in some Flamingo ornaments and called it a day.

 

[Rosewater]

I don't like Octavian's interior. It's just a couple space things thrown around randomly.

 

[Le Ham]

So, uh... Billy was my starter jock and he's my favorite villager on Espera right now, but I just now found out what his interior would've looked like... hoo boy am I glad he's my starter

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

man, y'all are HARSh, most of these I think are really cool house interiors.

I think Purrl's interior is a little bland but it's still fine.

 

[Haxot]

Graham’s interior is horrible. Because of that I wanna kick him off my island >_<

Post automatically merged: May 8, 2020

Eunice: it's basically a laundromat

View attachment 253305

haha!

 

[Believe]

this thread just made me realize I have a glitched house exterior (coco)... which happened quite conveniently cause I liked Lily's more anyways

 

[senbeiiscool]

I didn't know that so many people hated Chief's house, but I personally love it! It's probably coupled by the fact that I love graffiti + Chief being a dreamie but I think it gives him so much character! I give him a bunch of expensive stuff to replace the garbage bags though

On the other end, the house I like least is Marshal's house. Not because it looks bad, but it doesn't remind me of the Marshal I knew in NL. I knew him as the cute squirrel whose house is a little bit of a sloppy mess. Now in NH, his house is like a mini coffee shop. While cute, and I do like the interior, it doesn't even make me think like he's the same character

 

[Jared:3]

Disappointed in Mira's house, her interior in NL was amazing and fit her so well but her house in NH is so lazy and looks like a stupid theatre. Considering booting her for Cherry instead who has a much better house...

 

[helloxcutiee]

I was considering having Eunice as a potential dream villager for my island because she's really cute but once I found out her house is literally a laundromat I had to pass.