Oh no....i love most of the goats.....this is gonna be tough for me...
BEST: Kidd, Sherb, and Billy. Out of these 3, only Sherb has not stayed on my island, but omg, HES. SO. CUTE!!!! (sad im the only one out of my siblings who does not have him ). Billy and Kidd were both of my starter villagers (Kidd in my old town, Billy in my new one) both are really cute and i got attatched to both of them really quickly. Billy gets bonus points for giving me my first photo in my new town
WORST: Nan. I dont like her coloration that much, and shes kinda creepy....
My favorite Goat villager is Pashmina. She has a cool look to her, I really love her house's interior design in New Leaf, and she's one of my favorite Sisterly villagers. Not really a fan of the drastic change they made to her house's interior for New Horizons, though I guess at the very least that it looks good for what it is. Doesn't really matter at the end of the day though for me since she's not a resident of my New Horizons island, but yeah.
Gruff is probably my second favorite. Billy, Kidd, Nan, and Sherb are all good too.
I don't really dislike any of the Goats. If I absolutely had to pick a least favorite I guess it would be Velma, but she's fine too.
Nan and Chevre are both really cute! I've watched a adorable video on Reddit few yeeks ago and they are just so sweet! I love Kidd's eyes and colour too, he's really handsome haha
But Chevre is perfection. Her little eyes are bright and glowing! Can't wait to invite her on my island!
Chevre is soo cute I have her in my WW town and I am rather connected. She is so sweet! I also like Velma because she have default glasses which I haven’t seen much!
My favourite is Sherb as I think he's really cute and I like his blue colour scheme, it took me a long time to find him but he's now the permanent lazy on my island. I did vote for Chèvre and Nan too, I had them on my island together and thought they were really sweet, especially with the backstory linking them but after I got their photos I let them go as it just didn't feel right keeping one without the other and I would've been left with too many normal villagers if I kept them both.
The only goat I really dislike is Gruff, I usually like the cranky villagers but there is something odd about his design, I'm not very keen on his green colour scheme but I think the main problem is his hair, it looks strange on him to me and I don't like the sideburns.
Pashmina is the best! She is so darling, the her eyes are so pretty when she smiles with the sisterly villagers I feel the designs really change my interpretation of the personality and pashmina just seems to especially bring out their sweet side.
Nan is very cute too and would be my second choice.
poor gruff, I hope someone votes for him. He came to my campsite once and he really is much better looking in game than he seems in pictures.
Something about Chevre I find a little unsettling, but i don’t really dislike any of the goats
Sherb has the best design for a lazy and his dream/sleep theme suits his lazy personality so much! He is cute but not overdesigned. I once ran across him while island hopping. I considered him for a moment but thought I could do better. Passing him was my worst island hopping regret.
Worst: Velma
I don't hate any goat villagers but if I had to choose it would be Velma. She would be the least likely for me to invite her since I rate all animals depending on that. It would have to be the hair and that female goats with beards are weird for me. I considered adding Gruff but honestly his design isn't too bad.
I gotta be honest. I don't care much for goat villagers. And I haven't had any of the goat villagers.
I voted for Nan.
She is cute and would be the only one I would be ok with on my island.
For a while I thought I liked Sherb because his face seems more normal to me than the other goats. Then I realized how much the Lazy personality talks about bugs. You know sharing with them, talking to them... being in the walls or on the floor... ect.
Then I look at Sherb in his house... NOPE! It feels very awkward to me. I know it can be "remedied" by giving him butterflies and ant farms like I do with other Lazy villagers I really like, but I don't care for the goat villagers to begin with. So that just kinda put the icing on the cake for me.
I'm not a big fan of the goats in general because of their upside down, triangle head shape and the placement of their faces. But out of all of them, I like Pashmina the most. She has a nice design, nice colors, and I really like her yellow, cat-like eyes. She's one goat I'd be happy to invite to my town.
Over all my towns, I have only had Sherb, Nan, and Velma. I wasn’t a big fan of either Sherb or Velma, but Nan was one of my favorites in City Folk. And if I’m voting for Nan, I have to vote for Chèvre too.
My favourite is Kidd, I hated him in New Leaf since he moved in somewhere awful but when he moved in randomly on New Horizons I resented him even more until I found him watering a flower and then running off as if he didnt want anyone to see him and since then ive really really liked him and couldn't imagine my island without him.
My least favourite is absolutely Velma, she isn't too appealing to me at all. All the other goats I quite like except maybe Gruff too
It’s really close between Pashmina and Chèvre. I think I prefer Pashmina just because I have too many normals on my island. And I love her retro diner.
hmm..I really like pashmina and I think she suits the "sisterly" personality well; she just has this chill and easy going vibe. and her blue horns are super cute as well c:
don't really have a least fav goat, but I'm not really a fan of velmas design..
). Billy and Kidd were both of my starter villagers (Kidd in my old town, Billy in my new one) both are really cute and i got attatched to both of them really quickly. Billy gets bonus points for giving me my first photo in my new town 
with the sisterly villagers I feel the designs really change my interpretation of the personality and pashmina just seems to especially bring out their sweet side.
