Who are the best (and worst) goat villagers? 🐐

[BetsySundrop]

I've never met a peppy goat, so I had to go with billy. I had billy in a previous town, and jocks are another fun personality i like.

While i do like crankies, I'm not really a fan of gruff's aesthetics

 

[Asarena]

My favorite goat villagers are Chevre and Kidd! Honorable mentions to Pashmina and Sherb.

My thoughts on each of the goat villagers:

Billy- I like the fact that he looks more elderly. The type who would stroke his beard thoughtfully while he listened to your troubles. Him being a jock also makes me think that he's one of those elders who is surprisingly fit.

Chevre- She is absolutely adorable. I had her on my island for a while, and she was just so cute and sweet. The sparkly eyes, the freckles, her little tuft of hair... I don't trust anyone who doesn't love her. Also, the fact that Nan is supposedly her pen pal just adds to the cuteness.

Gruff- He's one of my least favorite goats. His hair and the color of it combined with the color of his fur isn't the best to me. Not really a fan of the eyelashes being only under his eyes either.

Kidd- My other favorite goat along with Chevre. I love his lavender fur, and he also has a cute tuft of hair. His half lidded eyes give him more character as well.

Nan- Chevre's pen pal! She's cute, but I don't really like the black eyes with a white center.

Pashmina- I love her horns and fur color, and she has a good facial expression.

Sherb- The color of his fur and the darker blue tuft of hair are great. Blue is my favorite color. He's a cutie.

Velma- Her eye and fur colors are nice.

 

[Zinnia.]

The goats are nice! I like Sherb the best out of all of them since he's cute. His cookie items from pocket camp are also some of the best, I'd be really happy if the giant cloud cushion and nap-time window seat made it to the next ac game.
My least favorite's Pashmina. I don't really have anything against her, but I just like the other goats better.

 

[Kattea]

It’s really close between Pashmina and Chèvre. I think I prefer Pashmina just because I have too many normals on my island. And I love her retro diner.

This still holds true in 2024

 

[Giddy]

Nan and Chevre hands down, need to be top best here.
When I was playing Wild World for hours, I had Chevre, and she was just a darling! I now love Nan a lot more, and she is never leaving my Island. I dunno exactly why I love her so. Just cute!
I've had Kidd for a while, and I am always displeased seeing him. I don't have much drama, I just didn't like him in the end. Sherb looks cute, I always think of sweets due to his name.
Billy and Pashmina are really cool too!
Gruff and Velma are no. No thank you.

 

[Tylerhelt14]

Mine would be Sherb.

 

[Blue-cat]

My favourite is Sherb because blue, my least favourite is Velma.
I understand why people dislike Gruff, but I kind of like his eyes lol

 

[Milleram]

Chevre is the absolute best. Kidd is pretty great, too.

 

[Nunnafinga]

Sherb and Nan are the G.O.A.T.s of all the goats.