I honestly like most of the villagers in the game, even those I do not love, I can generally warm up to. I have dozens of favorites.
However there are a handful I heartily dislike. I hope this does not offend anyone,
in somewhat particular order:
1. Colton - his design is one I just find both totally unappealing and mildly repulsive.
2. Diana - looks like someone bleached a more interesting and colorful villagers. Her whole appearance screams bland and colorless.
3. Whitney/ Fang - the exact same design on my two least favorite personalities. It probably is unfair to some extent but I find them very overrated. I don’t like the colorlessness passed off as ‘elegant’ design in general - it is so boring to me. it gives me country club/ people who create grayscale nurseries vibes.
4. Kid Cat/ Agent S/ Rocket - I do not like the superhero themed villagers at all. I tend in general to not like villagers who are wearing permanent headgear (with the exception of stinky) and I find the superhero outfit totally unappealing. For some reason I do not feel as strong of dislike for Big Top, possible just because I have had the least exposure to him.
5. Jacques - hate his soul patch (in general dislike the animals with facial hair, especially the little soul patch style goatee). Arguably he fits the worst aspect of the smug villagers - he seems like a huge poser. To me he reminds me of all those guys in college that have decided to be wine/ coffee/ music/ film connoisseurs and can’t wait to educate you on why your tastes are wrong. Also seems like the type who wants to ‘play devil’s advocate’ and make you debate whether women actually deserve rights andwhether racism is bad.
6. Gayle/Merengue - find their overdone cutiepie designs to be bit sickening.
7. Chèvre, while I understand why people find her cute, her face reminds me of something specific that I won’t name to try and not ruin her for anyone, but I can’t get past it, and it unsettles me.
In general I also tend to dislike the wolves as a species in general. They are so spiky and their heads look like they shouldn’t be attached to their bodies. Why do their tails look like maces?
There are others where I may not like them much, but don’t actively dislike them. I hope i have not upset anyone, I generally avoid being too negative, but wanted to share.
Side note
@VexTheHex you may already know, but even though I really like freckles you are not wrong about her. Her Japanese name is Maguro, which is tuna. So all her fishy attributes are very intentional and not imagined. And I have no idea why she is a duck that is a fish.