Besides Deirdre and Genji, both of whom I kept resetting for until I found villagers I liked, with the move ins, I'd say a tie between Bangle and Dora.
I've always loved Bangle anyway but Dora I suppose would be the one I pick as most surprising. She's sooo cute. I'd keep her if I wasn't so set on all the villagers I want lol but she's welcome to stay as long as she would like!
I don't have a favorite, but I will say that some surprises have really grown on me. I started with a villager I really wanted (Reneigh), but Kevin, Erik, and Marina have grown on me to where I want all three of them to stay.
Now if I could only get rid of Curlos and Puddles ...
i really like kody!! he's my starting jock villager and he's always looking out for me fashion and recipe-wise. he's given me lot of lil gifts, and i've done the same for him. i try to talk to him multiple times a day because he's just always doing something strange lol i dont know if i'll keep him forever, but he's definitely made his way into my heart.
Ellie, she is so cute! I started liking Plucky as well, especially when I saw her singing in the plaza yesterday but I don't think I'll stop her if she pings me to move.
Out of my five villagers, Celia is my favourite. She's very classy and cute, and I'm a massive fan of Eagle villagers! I hope she and fellow Eagle villager Pierce become good friends!
Thus far, it's Gayle, hands down.
She's just so darn cute! She's a bit shy, but she doesn't hesitate to help the others and me whenever we need it. She sounds so kind and calm, and I smile every time I see her.
I am definitely keeping this sweet gator =^-^=