Would Marshal be nearly as popular if he had a nose?

[ForgottenT]

Try eyebrows lol

 

[Todders17]

@LemmyLem BAHAHAHA, who is he? Voldemort?

 

[randomforeignguy]

Dude, he looks way better with a nose. He's ugly without one.

View attachment 236164

IM DEAD LMAO

 

[toenuki]

i thought he had one for four seconds

 

[Pickler]

 

[Leela]

turns out this is the unpopular opinion, but I prefer him without a nose

 

[Halloqueen]

I'm not particularly interested in him, but I would like him more if he had a nose like the one shown in the original post. While there are some villagers I like who lack noses, like Ankha for example, I usually dislike it when villagers lack noses. I especially dislike Flurry for this reason.

 

[Vanillite]

Is there a master list of villagers without noses?? I need to nose. (is my pun funny?) Anyway, I like him better with a nose.

 

[Clock]

I’m not a Marshal fan, but he would look nice with a nose.

 

[ughrora]

He looks cute with and without a nose! I think he'd still be popular either way, honestly.

 

[Sweetley]

If the nose would fit along with the rest of his design, I assume he would be still as popular as without one. Personally, I prefer him without one, just got used to it.

 

[Megan.]

Yes I think it would be the same, the nose doesn't make much difference.

 

[niconii]

I think he’d still be popular either way! To be honest, he might look even better if he had one

 

[Hedgehugs]

tbh whenver i thought of marshal with a nose i always imagined a nose similar to poppy's, kinda like;

ignore the fact he's kinda naked i didn't feel like drawing too much

he looks like a frickin' cub now oops. anyway, i then tried with the nose most people are imagining;

gotta say, now i wish he had a nose like this, it looks slightly better but noseless marshal is cute too.

Try eyebrows lol

how about a unibrow

in short, these were fun to make

 

[Che5hire Cat]

Fascinating how a little dot in the face can change his whole appearance so much. Overall, I do think Marshal would still reach high popularity in the community even if he would own a nose. It's the cranky/smug-ish look he has that makes people like him so much (at least from what I see and hear) and I think a nose would not ruin this that much (as long as said nose has a decent shape and size. A gigantic, weird looking nose for example may turn him into a joke). Personally, I like Marshal with and without one.

 

[fluttershy300]

He would still be popular, maybe even more popular. I think that’s the one thing I don’t like about is the fact that he doesn’t have a nose. There are many villagers without a nose (Tangy, Punchy, Kabuki, Bunnie, etc) and I kinda hate that but still love them nonetheless.