you must make a monospecies island with all eight personality types

[You got mail!]

I actually have an island that’s entirely bunnies!

I have…

Chrissy
Francine
Bunnie
Coco
Mira
Tiffany
Gaston
Toby
Genji
Cole <3

 

[rocketspruggs]

I already do have an island which has a mix of rabbits and cows, but I voted for the rabbits in the poll.
If I had an island that only had rabbits, these are the following that I'd choose:

Lazy: Doc
Jock: Snake
Smug: Toby
Cranky: Gaston
Peppy: Chrissy
Normal: Coco
Sisterly: Mira
Snooty: Francine

 

[Rio_]

I voted for cat because I made an all-cat town in New Leaf. Though I didn't do much with it after collecting all the villagers lol

If I were to do it again in New Horizons, this time I'd choose:

Lazy: Bob
Jock: Stinky
Cranky: Tom
Smug: Raymond
Normal: Mitzi, Kiki
Peppy: Merry
Snooty: Purrl, Olivia
Sisterly: Katt

I'd also be interested in making all dog, frog, and penguin islands! My main New Leaf town almost became an all-penguin town by accident when 3 of my 5 starters turned out to be penguins

Spoiler: Dog Villagers

Lazy: Lucky, Bones
Jock: Mac
Cranky: Butch, Frett
Smug: Shep
Normal: Daisy
Peppy: Cookie
Snooty: Portia
Sisterly: Cherry

Spoiler: Frog Villagers

Lazy: Raddle
Jock: Tad, Drift
Cranky: Camofrog, Wart Jr.
Smug: Henry
Normal: Lily
Peppy: Puddles
Snooty: Gigi
Sisterly: Diva

Spoiler: Penguin Villagers

Lazy: Wade, Puck
Jock: Roald, Iggly
Cranky: Hopper
Smug: Tex
Normal: Aurora
Peppy: Sprinkle
Snooty: Friga
Sisterly: Flo

 

[Mattician]

Cats:

Cranky - Tom
Jock - Rudy
Lazy - Punchy
Smug - Raymond
Normal - Kiki
Normal - Lolly
Normal - Mitzi
Peppy - Tangy
Sisterly - Katt
Snooty - Olivia

This is tough because there are soooo many good cats in Animal Crossing.

 

[. Rarity .]

I had an all male rabbit island once of Sasha, Toby, Cole, O-hare, Claude, Hopkins, Gaston, Dork (Doc), Genji, and Snake ♡

I don't think I could ever do a Monospecies island ^^; I only really vibe with male personalities, and I really don't want a sisterly, personally not a fan of them.

 

[Airysuit]

That is so difficult, because my faves are all different species
But if I had to choose, id go with bunnies because of coco.

 

[Sae]

I had one. I flattened the island and regretted it, so I reset on my own switch and now I’m unsure if I want to keep some of those villagers or hunt for Rosie and Ankha.

 

[AlexSilverpen]

I chose cats because I'm a cat person, though the thought of having Raymond on my island makes me feel weird. I like his design, but his stans have left a bad taste in my mouth when it comes to him. I would've picked frogs, but really Tad and Lily are the only 2 frogs I like. I do want to do a mono-species island one day, but I'm not sure how well I'd do it. Especially as a chronic resetter.

 

[Snek]

I guess cat

Normal: Lolly
Jock: Kid Cat
Peppy: Tangy
Smug: Raymond
Sisterly: Katt
Cranky: Kabuki
Snooty: Ankha

 

[mermaidshelf]

I chose pigs because they're the only species I have 2 of on my island currently and I think they're an underappreciated species that deserve a lot of love.

Normal: Gala, Lucy
Lazy: Hugh
Peppy: Peggy
Jock: Kevin
Snooty: Pancetti
Smug: Chops
Uchi: Agnes
Cranky: Rasher, Boris

 

[Alliecakes]

I picked squirrels but koalas are my favs

 

[Fruitcup]

I kinda have that going on on my island right now, they are all birds and ostriches

 

[Giddy]

Either Cat, Dog or Frog; this is after going through all of them and seeing which I would like more. And these ones had more of my favourites and nothing I HAD to add like the others. Or like one villager out of them all were what disapointed me more, say for example Sheildon in the Squirrels.

Cat:
Snooty: Olivia & Purrl
Normal: Lolly
Peppy: Felicity
Big Sister: Katt
Smug: Raymond
Jock: Rudy
Cranky: Tom
Lazy: Moe & Punchy

Deer:
Snooty: Diana & Fuchsia
Normal: Fauna
Peppy: Shino
Big Sister: Deirdre
Smug: Lopez & Zell
Jock: Bam
Cranky: Bruce
Lazy: Erik

Dog:
Snooty: Portia
Normal: Bea & Daisy
Peppy: Maddie
Big Sister: Cherry
Smug: Shep
Jock: Mac
Cranky: Butch
Lazy: Benjamin & Marcel

Frog:
Snooty: Gigi
Normal: Jambette & Lily
Peppy: Puddles
Big Sister: Diva
Smug: Henry
Jock: Cousteau
Cranky: Wart Jr.
Lazy: Drift & Jeremiah

Horse:
Snooty: Annalise
Normal: Peaches & Savannah
Peppy: Victoria & Winnie
Big Sister: Reneigh
Smug: Colton
Jock: Buck
Cranky: Roscoe
Lazy: Clyde

Penguin:
Snooty: Friga
Normal: Aurora
Peppy: Sprinkle
Big Sister: Flo
Smug: Tex
Jock: Roald
Cranky: Hopper
Lazy: Boomer, Cube & Wade

Pig:
Snooty: Pancetti
Normal: Gala & Maggie
Peppy: Truffles
Big Sister: Agnes
Smug: Chops
Jock: Kevin
Cranky: Rasher
Lazy: Hugh & Spork

Rabbit:
Snooty: Tiffany
Normal: Coco
Peppy: Bonbon & Bunnie
Big Sister: Mira
Smug: Toby
Jock: Genji
Cranky: Gaston
Lazy: Cole & Sasha

Squirrel:
Snooty: Blaire & Tasha
Normal: Sally & Sylvana
Peppy: Agent S
Big Sister: Hazel
Smug: Marshal
Jock: Sheildon
Cranky: Static
Lazy: Filbert