If you had an Island of only one personality, what would it be?

[LoveGraceMarie]

Peppy! I have a majority peppy lineup anyway and I love a lot of the villagers with that personality type

 

[Chere.]

Probably Normal! I always tend to gravitate towards them, and in both NL and NH I had multiple in mind as potential dreamies/permies. I remember in NL I cycled through quite a few normals I liked until I settled on my eventual permies. They're just easy to get along with and I feel like I can relate to them the most. ;v; I also quite like crankies in NH as I find them more soft-hearted but I'm not sure I'd want an island full of them.

 

[KittenNoir]

If I had to have only one personality type on my island I would pick either the lazy or sisterly personality.

I like the sisterly type but I think I would pick lazy type as I find them nice and chill to hang out with.

My island is filled with alot of lazy types at the moment now I find them easy to get along with no drama.

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

All Lazy for sure! Although Jock would be kinda cool too, I think the jock type is pretty funny

 

[Iris_T]

I quite like some Smug and Normal villagers, however I simply can't miss my favorite villagers that happen to be Lazy (and I'm lazy person myself so its matching xDD)

 

[Paperboy012305]

Probably Smug or Snooty Villagers, I vibe with those personalities quite a lot. Mostly because there's too many villagers I like out of those personalities.

If I were to choose, I'd pick Smug, since I can't leave my favorite Smug villager, Eugene behind. We go a long way a decade and 13 years ago.

2012 was 13 years ago, where has the time gone?

 

[Snek]

I like lazies the most and I feel that their personality is more tolerable than other personalities like jocks and normals. Smug personality also seems to have a lot of variety when it comes to conversation and their vibes make me laugh. The third I would use would be sisterlys although the lack of many sisterly villagers makes it seem like I don't have a lot of choice when choosing favourites to have on the island.

 

[mermaidshelf]

that would be difficult to pick as i already find the dialog repetitive but if i had to choose, i'd go with normal. they're the personalities i most gravitate to in real life and i find them to be the most even keeled. it would be easy to fill a town of 10 with normals because i love their designs and they have a lot of great villager options that i've always wanted but couldn't due to the 10 villager limit. my town already has 2 so the job is 20% complete haha. i do love all the personalities equally though and would personally never go for a 1 personality town.

 

[LateGamer]

This would be a tough call for me because I love Scoot to death but not sure I like all of the sporty since honestly irl I hate sports, lol! And I love my two peppy girls Pom Pom and Puddles. Yeah…..I don’t even know if I could choose! But if forced then I would have to say peppy. Sorry Scoot my love.

 

[Moonfish]

Normal villagers are the cutest I think. Although if I had an island with only one personality I wouldn't talk to them. The dialogue is already bland as-is.

 

[Aznoth]

I'd love to have an island full of either smug or lazy villagers because most of the villagers that are my favorites fall into those two categories.

 

[airpeaches]

I think I'd have to go for Peppy or Lazy. if I had to choose one, I'd do Peppy! there are soo many lazies and so many normals that I love and I could easily fill towns with them. but I really love peppies too. I just feel like they have more interesting and more fun dialogue than the normals. the lazies are adorable and I enjoy their dialogue but I do find it a bit stale after a while.after a while of playing I was pretty over the constant comments about bugs and such. Dotty is my favorite villager all time and I juat always have fun chatting with her, even the recycled dialogue feels fun just because of what she talks about! plus there are a lot of peppies I like. it wouldn't be too hard for me to fill a town of them!

 

[BalloonFight]

Most of my favorite villagers are lazy and normal. I think just for designs and such, I'd go lazy, but for interacting with villagers often, and having to deal with the pretty limited dialogue in ACNH, I'd choose normal ultimately. If only there were more variety in the dialogue like adding in NL or WW text.

 

[Bekaa]

Cranky. Fang was my first cranky and I kept him forever. I still have a warm spot in my heart for him - and all the crankys.

 

[himekirako]

gosh that’s so hard to pick… i love my peppy, lazy, and normal villagers haha
i guess if i really had to choose then it’d be peppy because they’re so chaotic and that should be entertaining, everyone vying to becoming the next island star