I don't have any of my starters in town anymore so they don't count but Genji was the first to move in I believe, he's practically the founder of my town hahaha
I only have one "starter" villager left and that's Walt. Both Hamlet and Victoria were early move-ins, though. It's a shame because there's really only Victoria that I'm interested in keeping.
Mine in New Leaf has got to be Eugene. I have had him since 2013. Though, to me restarting. I had him since 2014. The reason is because I always wanted to keep my Eugene from 2014 on each town I restart. I have kept him for only 2 years. Now, I don't wanna restart anymore. I found the town i'm cool with.
Pudge is my only starter left! He wouldn't leave for so long even though I wanted him to, but eventually when he gave me his picture I just let him stay in my town.
Curly, a starter of mine, actually left just yesterday! He, of course, has the record so far!
Of all villagers I have in my town now, it's Zucker. He moved in quite early, after I started playing.
Big Top and Groucho are the two starters that stayed. Apple just moved out unexpectedly, and she was my favorite starter and that was the saddest day EVER. Melba was the first villager to move in and she's still around though!
Well, he isn't one of five originals by faaar, but... it's Marshal[/B the smug squirrel]!
That adorable marshmallow white thing was so precious to me that when he so unexpectedly left my town, it was the very first time I actually wept over the game. And even worse, at that time I didn't know about the 16 cycling thing, so I thought I had lost him forever. Yeah, it was such a depressing day... Because he was a surprise villager coming on his own the first time, you know. Luckily, I joined this awesome forum and learned that I could get him back. Oh boy, I was so incredibly happy!
Since then, many villagers have passed through my town (more than hundred currently), but I've always been extremely careful to not lost Marshal again. So that's it, he's my eldest neighbour now Second would be Zucker, and I'm also keeping him forever.
Right now, Zucker is the oldest one in my town. He moved in 4 days after I started my town, August 6th.
I remember the excitement, I was so happy such a cute villager had moved into my town. He's not going anywhere anytime soon, either!