ACNH Villager Rankdown (#1 and #2 HAVE BEEN POSTED!)

Overall I think I'm pretty happy with our selections so far! Only a few villagers I like have been cut so far (RIP Bluebear lol). I still see a few I'm after to cut next but for the most part, many of my favorites or villagers I like are still in the top 99. I'm looking forward to see what round 4 brings!
 
Sorry about the delay; I was doing schoolwork! This is actually a tough choice on who to cut...

Save: Moe (best cat needs to stay in)
Cut: Lucy

I feel bad for cutting her because she's very cute and probably one of the best pig designs, but I like Astrid and Canberra more than her so I didn't have a choice. I actually don't have anything negative to say about Lucy, besides the fact (and this seems to be a recurring theme for me), but her eyes are kinda unnerving imo. The black scleras with the tiny white pupils don't give off the cute vibe like Nintendo probably intended, but I think the rest of her design works well. People hate the front-only bangs, but I think it can be endearing depending on the villager (still kinda salty about my girl Opal being eliminated ngl). I just checked Lucy's house interior because I hadn't seen it before, and it turns out that it's super cute, like she's going to give a piano recital or something. Honestly I had never really paid attention to her before writing this post, but now I think I'll have to get her in my own town and see how it goes because she has intrigued me. Seriously, look at her house:
800px-House_of_Lucy_NH.png

(edited out an unnecessary comma)
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO LUCY MY BABY FOR THAT UGLY CAT :eek::eek::eek::cry::cry::cry::cry:😥😥😭😭😭😭😭😭
 
All I am saying is thank goodness for fast pass, I wouldn't have been able to sleep at night knowing that Beau, Pietro and Raymond could be savagely cut before I even had the chance to read the message! We've lost too many good ones already in my opinion but I'm glad I managed to keep some in before they were cruely snatched away from me. I am pleased to see that all the judges seem to feel free to share whatever opinion they have no matter how savage. Its made life much easier not having to censor my opinion! LOL
 
All I am saying is thank goodness for fast pass, I wouldn't have been able to sleep at night knowing that Beau, Pietro and Raymond could be savagely cut before I even had the chance to read the message! We've lost too many good ones already in my opinion but I'm glad I managed to keep some in before they were cruely snatched away from me. I am pleased to see that all the judges seem to feel free to share whatever opinion they have no matter how savage. Its made life much easier not having to censor my opinion! LOL

I agree! No one’s list made it through unscathed, and I was so sad for my poor axed babes. But I am so glad I didn’t have to worry about those three at least, especially tabby 😉

it is nice to freely air our negative opinions, I always feel very guilty (and don’t want to make people feel bad), but it’s so nice to just not have to self-censor. I am glad the atmosphere has stayed really fun and positive even in the midst of all these villager take downs.
 
All I am saying is thank goodness for fast pass, I wouldn't have been able to sleep at night knowing that Beau, Pietro and Raymond could be savagely cut before I even had the chance to read the message! We've lost too many good ones already in my opinion but I'm glad I managed to keep some in before they were cruely snatched away from me. I am pleased to see that all the judges seem to feel free to share whatever opinion they have no matter how savage. Its made life much easier not having to censor my opinion! LOL
I agree! No one’s list made it through unscathed, and I was so sad for my poor axed babes. But I am so glad I didn’t have to worry about those three at least, especially tabby 😉

it is nice to freely air our negative opinions, I always feel very guilty (and don’t want to make people feel bad), but it’s so nice to just not have to self-censor. I am glad the atmosphere has stayed really fun and positive even in the midst of all these villager take downs.
These were so nice to read! 😊 I’m glad everyone is having fun. In terms of the fast passes, don’t get too used to them, as they won’t be here forever. 😅
 
Next round will still involve cuts and saves, but it’ll be a little different. This difference might affect some decisions. 🤔
Will you force us to pick one fast-pass baby to let go??? :eek::eek:😓😓
 
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

ok sorry that was an overreaction. Allow me to retain my ~ c a l m n e s s . ~

Uh. uhm. uhhmm... I think.... no.... uh, Tammi's too delicate to get axed to death... Sherb might get saved if I sacrifice him, but there's only a chance... Curlos? I guess most people think he's ok, but it's probably a little risky to give him up just yet.... uhhh......................

My babies need me 😂
 
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

ok sorry that was an overreaction. Allow me to retain my ~ c a l m n e s s . ~

Uh. uhm. uhhmm... I think.... no.... uh, Tammi's too delicate to get axed to death... Sherb might get saved if I sacrifice him, but there's only a chance... Curlos? I guess most people think he's ok, but it's probably a little risky to give him up just yet.... uhhh......................

My babies need me 😂
We’ll see... 😅
 
They are nook mile designs specific to the various airport colours on your island no? How that relates to villagers and their rankings no idea...

Maybe villagers will be grouped by species? Two by two like the ark.... that was mostly my imagination and not based on that picture in any way!
 
Back
Top