ACNH Villager Rankdown (#1 and #2 HAVE BEEN POSTED!)

[WaileaNoRei]

Yeah, the only reason I voted to cut group 2 was to save Caroline. I don’t think her group stood much of a chance against Fang and Pekoe though.

honestly, I did not realize pekoe was popular! I didn’t have anything against her, I just never realized she was particularly popular.

 

[Asarena]

Okay, I'm back! I'll start working on the write ups~

 

[Asarena]

I'm just going to start off by saying that I actually liked group 1 more than group 2! I do like all of the villagers that I nominated though.


Caroline
I happen to like most of the squirrels, and Caroline is no exception. She's one of my favorite squirrels actually. I really like her bright fur and blue eyes. I can understand why others may dislike her though. While I like her bright color, other people may actually think of it as a flaw and prefer villagers with more neutral or toned down coloring. I think I've seen some people mention that they don't like her house interior in New Horizons as well, although I like it myself. I guess that could also be a factor in why people dislike her though. I love her, so it's hard to think of much criticism, but I assume people have their reasons for not saving her.

Eunice
Eunice has been one of my favorite villagers since the GameCube game. I will say though, that I don't like her house interior in New Horizons. It's a laundromat, which is nice if you like that I guess, but it's just not for me. I much preferred her interior in previous games with the classic sofa and grand piano. It reminded me of a grandmother's house, which is certainly better than a laundromat. That being said, she'll always be one of my favorites due to my fond memories of her even if she's made some questionable interior decorating choices recently. (Also, I still think Eunice should have been the one to win the counting sheep polls and be made into a collectible, but Vesta is cute too.)

Julia
I have to say that out of the three who were cut, Julia being cut saddens me the most. Eunice may have developed poor taste when it comes to decorating her house, and Caroline may be a bit bright for some people, but what is there to even dislike about Julia? I looked at her. I looked at a picture of her house. She's a peacock. A female peacock who has the appearance of a male peacock. She has big, pretty eyes, the beautiful male peacock coloring, and she's clearly the best of the ostrich villagers. And I like several of the ostrich villagers, so that's high praise coming from me. On top of that, have you seen the exterior of her house? It's so blue! Blue is my favorite color. The more I think about it, the more I'm wondering why I don't have Julia on my island yet. I would say something negative, but I've studied her Wiki page and have failed to find a single flaw. Is being too perfect a flaw? I'll go with that if it is.

 

[Bk1234]

It is now @WaileaNoRei to nominate seven villagers.
@Florence + The Machine will then save someone and divide the remaining 6 villagers into two groups of 3.
@Pintuition @saucySheep @Verecund @Emmsey @Asarena will then vote on which group to save.​

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Well, this round has surely been a hectic one! It has brought the Top 140 all the way down to a Top 99! Round 4 hints will be coming later in the week. For now, discuss the results of the latest round!

Spoiler: Top 99

Agnes
Anabelle
Apple
Baabara
Bam
Bangle
Beau
Bianca
Biff
Blaire
Bones
Bruce
Canberra
Carmen
Caroline
Chadder
Charlise
Chevre
Clay
Coco
Cole
Colton
Curlos
Cyd
Diana
Dom
Dotty
Eloise
Elvis
Eunice
Fang
Filbert
Flora
Flurry
Francine
Freckles
Frita
Frobert
Gabi
Gala
Genji
Graham
Hamlet
Hans
Ike
Jacob/Jakey
Judy
Julia
Kabuki
Ken
Kiki
Kyle
Lobo
Mac
Maple
Marshal
Megan
Merengue
Merry
Mint
Mitzi
Moe
Muffy
Olaf
Peanut
Pekoe
Penelope
Phoebe
Pietro
Pinky
Plucky
Poncho
Prince
Punchy
Raymond
Reneigh
Roald
Rod
Roscoe
Rudy
Savannah
Sherb
Spike
Sprinkle
Static
Stinky
Stitches
Sylvana
Tabby
Tammi
Tasha
Timbra
Ursala
Vesta
Vivian
Wade
Walker
Whitney
Yuka

I think someone is missing, because plucky is on this list and she was cut? Just asking because I am going through looking for my 7 nominees (which I will post when you give the word!)

 

[Asarena]

Wait, for last round each of the 7 judges picked 12 villagers and 6 were cut each time, so that would be a total of 42 villagers cut right? And 140-42=98 right? Or I could have messed up the math somewhere in there

 

[Bk1234]

Wait, for last round each of the 7 judges picked 12 villagers and 6 were cut each time, so that would be a total of 42 villagers cut right? And 140-42=98 right? Or I could have messed up the math somewhere in there

I just discovered this after @WaileaNoRei mentioned Plucky. Yes, it is supposed to be a Top 98, omit Plucky.

Post automatically merged: Oct 3, 2020

I think someone is missing, because plucky is on this list and she was cut? Just asking because I am going through looking for my 7 nominees (which I will post when you give the word!)

You can post them now.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Wait, for last round each of the 7 judges picked 12 villagers and 6 were cut each time, so that would be a total of 42 villagers cut right? And 140-42=98 right? Or I could have messed up the math somewhere in there

No, that makes sense! And that’s great, it means I can just take out plucky from the list I am using and no one has to comb through for someone left off! Great math sleuthing!

Post automatically merged: Oct 3, 2020

For my 7 I nominate:

Gabi
Kiki
Mac
Rod
Static
Tasha
Wade

 

[Bk1234]

Thank you for the nominations @WaileaNoRei ! Now, @Florence + The Machine needs to save one villager split the remaining six into two groups of three. Then the remaining rankers will vote.

 

[Emmsey]

Question re the write up within 2 hours say the others vote and the one to cut is decided in the middle of my night? Is it just whenever I see it as the ranker and confirm the cut. The two hours starts from then? Just concerned re time zones don’t want to be too late.

 

[Bk1234]

Question re the write up within 2 hours say the others vote and the one to cut is decided in the middle of my night? Is it just whenever I see it as the ranker and confirm the cut. The two hours starts from then? Just concerned re time zones don’t want to be too late.

Don’t worry about the two hour thing for this round. I know it’s a lot of write-ups for everyone to do. Just post them as soon as you can.

 

[Florence + The Machine]

No, that makes sense! And that’s great, it means I can just take out plucky from the list I am using and no one has to comb through for someone left off! Great math sleuthing!

Post automatically merged: Oct 3, 2020

For my 7 I nominate:

Gabi
Kiki
Mac
Rod
Static
Tasha
Wade

I save Wade, so the 2 groups will be:

Group 1: Kiki, Static, Rod
Group 2: Tasha, Mac, Gabi

 

[Verecund]

Voting to save group 2.

 

[Asarena]

I vote to save group 1

 

[saucySheep]

vote 2

 

[Pintuition]

Voting to save group 1!

 

[Bk1234]

@Emmsey ’s vote will be the tiebreaker!

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Oh my gosh! What an exciting round! I take full credit

 

[Emmsey]

Sorry group 2- I vote group 1 to save.

 

[Bk1234]

Ok, that means @WaileaNoRei is responsible for write-ups for Tasha, Mac, and Gabi.