• The community has spoken and 8 collectibles have been added to the shop! Congratulations to Chere for designing the winning Ghostly Kitty Ice Cream Cone!

ACNH Villager Rankdown (#1 and #2 HAVE BEEN POSTED!)

Asarena said:
I'm just going to start off by saying that I actually liked group 1 more than group 2! I do like all of the villagers that I nominated though.


Caroline
I happen to like most of the squirrels, and Caroline is no exception. She's one of my favorite squirrels actually. I really like her bright fur and blue eyes. I can understand why others may dislike her though. While I like her bright color, other people may actually think of it as a flaw and prefer villagers with more neutral or toned down coloring. I think I've seen some people mention that they don't like her house interior in New Horizons as well, although I like it myself. I guess that could also be a factor in why people dislike her though. I love her, so it's hard to think of much criticism, but I assume people have their reasons for not saving her.
Caroline_NewHorizon.png



Eunice
Eunice has been one of my favorite villagers since the GameCube game. I will say though, that I don't like her house interior in New Horizons. It's a laundromat, which is nice if you like that I guess, but it's just not for me. I much preferred her interior in previous games with the classic sofa and grand piano. It reminded me of a grandmother's house, which is certainly better than a laundromat. That being said, she'll always be one of my favorites due to my fond memories of her even if she's made some questionable interior decorating choices recently. (Also, I still think Eunice should have been the one to win the counting sheep polls and be made into a collectible, but Vesta is cute too.)
Eunice_NewHorizon.png



Julia
I have to say that out of the three who were cut, Julia being cut saddens me the most. Eunice may have developed poor taste when it comes to decorating her house, and Caroline may be a bit bright for some people, but what is there to even dislike about Julia? I looked at her. I looked at a picture of her house. She's a peacock. A female peacock who has the appearance of a male peacock. She has big, pretty eyes, the beautiful male peacock coloring, and she's clearly the best of the ostrich villagers. And I like several of the ostrich villagers, so that's high praise coming from me. On top of that, have you seen the exterior of her house? It's so blue! Blue is my favorite color. The more I think about it, the more I'm wondering why I don't have Julia on my island yet. I would say something negative, but I've studied her Wiki page and have failed to find a single flaw. Is being too perfect a flaw? I'll go with that if it is.
Julia_NewHorizon.png
Click to expand...

RIP @ Julia being cut </3
At least queen of the pigs Agnes has made it through this next round, def one of the girlies who I'm hoping makes it far!
 
ooof. rip vesta. though i hate flora and pheobe, so this should be easy enough

Flora:
Flora.... is just... ew. Please no. The bright pink hurts my eyes. And the white on her fast as a horrible contrast. I guess I like the heart shape... but... ehh. Her eyes look blank and dead inside - not something I'd want on my island. She also seems like a recovering emo with her picture quote "pink is the new black". What, did someone inject her with pinky-happy-sappy? I guess I like the house interior a lil bit... though it's a bit sad to look at. Imagine being the only flamingo out of all the 450 other animal friends in the game and having to surround yourself with fake flamingos in your house so you could have some friends.
House_of_Flora_NH.jpg

Phoebe:
Phoebe.. really sends the wrong vibes.... she's very, uh, unique, but... again, far too bright for me. (If you couldn't already tell, I prefer darker colored villagers, with the exception of Sherb, Tammi, and Dom). First of all. Her house. SHE LIVES IN A FRIKING VOLCANO. SHE'S GOING TO BURN DOWN THE ISLAND. Ok.. ok.... Her eyes seems just as blank as Flora's, but with weird makeup that makes her look like a snooty. Also ahh,, the red, yellow and orange clashing with the specks of blue may be pleasing to some but I find it to make her appear very unorganized. Idk. she just makes my eyes unhappy.
House_of_Phoebe_NH.jpg

Vesta:
Oh crap. I hate to see any sheep left behind. This is painful.
As you all already know, I have absolutely nothing against any type of sheep - vesta including. She's adorable. I lovE her. Loving the fall-colored horns, the not-so-blank-and-totally-not-creepy face, and the overall simplistic and happy vibe she gives me. At the very least, she definitely looks like a normal. Probably one of my favorite normals - most of the others have some dumb grown-up look about them (sorry, Gala.... but I prefer to think of normals as younger than 50). Her house is really unique and really fits the personality - though it may look better without so much white. Sorry Vesta *crys in sheep language*
download.jpg
 
saucySheep said:
ooof. rip vesta. though i hate flora and pheobe, so this should be easy enough

Flora:
Flora.... is just... ew. Please no. The bright pink hurts my eyes. And the white on her fast as a horrible contrast. I guess I like the heart shape... but... ehh. Her eyes look blank and dead inside - not something I'd want on my island. She also seems like a recovering emo with her picture quote "pink is the new black". What, did someone inject her with pinky-happy-sappy? I guess I like the house interior a lil bit... though it's a bit sad to look at. Imagine being the only flamingo out of all the 450 other animal friends in the game and having to surround yourself with fake flamingos in your house so you could have some friends.
View attachment 324716

Phoebe:
Phoebe.. really sends the wrong vibes.... she's very, uh, unique, but... again, far too bright for me. (If you couldn't already tell, I prefer darker colored villagers, with the exception of Sherb, Tammi, and Dom). First of all. Her house. SHE LIVES IN A FRIKING VOLCANO. SHE'S GOING TO BURN DOWN THE ISLAND. Ok.. ok.... Her eyes seems just as blank as Flora's, but with weird makeup that makes her look like a snooty. Also ahh,, the red, yellow and orange clashing with the specks of blue may be pleasing to some but I find it to make her appear very unorganized. Idk. she just makes my eyes unhappy.
View attachment 324721

Vesta:
Oh crap. I hate to see any sheep left behind. This is painful.
As you all already know, I have absolutely nothing against any type of sheep - vesta including. She's adorable. I lovE her. Loving the fall-colored horns, the not-so-blank-and-totally-not-creepy face, and the overall simplistic and happy vibe she gives me. At the very least, she definitely looks like a normal. Probably one of my favorite normals - most of the others have some dumb grown-up look about them (sorry, Gala.... but I prefer to think of normals as younger than 50). Her house is really unique and really fits the personality - though it may look better without so much white. Sorry Vesta *crys in sheep language*
View attachment 324723
Click to expand...
RIP Phoebe RIP Flora RIP Birds
At least Roald and Megan survive though<3
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Rio_
  • Poll
How many islands have you "completed"?
2 3
Replies
45
Views
491
daynapapaya
daynapapaya
Chronos314_XD
Write Me a Short Story About...
Replies
0
Views
46
Chronos314_XD
Chronos314_XD
Jeremy
Pin the Tail on the Villager
33 34 35
Replies
688
Views
25K
toxapex
toxapex
Jeremy
Banner Beasts
4 5 6
Replies
106
Views
3K
CylieDanny
CylieDanny
EvilTheCat6600
Goodbye And Good Riddance To My Second Island
Replies
0
Views
203
EvilTheCat6600
EvilTheCat6600
Back
Top