ACNH Villager Rankdown (#1 and #2 HAVE BEEN POSTED!)

Asarena said:
At this point 3 of my top 4 and 3 of my bottom 4 have already had their ranks revealed. I'm curious to see when the last 1 in my top 4 and the last 1 in my bottom 4 will appear
Click to expand...
It’ll be interesting to see when they appear... 🤔

Verecund said:
I feel bad for ranking Sprinkle so low because she's pretty cute; I absolutely adore the aqua swirl on her head, which is why she quickly became one of my favourites when I first saw her, but then I realized that there's not much else that really stands out about her, especially compared to the other peppies, which is why my enthusiasm for her faded over time and I ranked her as low as I did. I think it's her eyes - Peanut can pull off those eyes well, but for some reason it doesn't work as well for Sprinkle. Her face just isn't cutesy enough to match her swirl, I guess. I'm surprised she got third among the public!

I'm still a little sad to see Sprinkle go because I still like her, but not too sad considering there are 19 villagers I ranked above her.
Click to expand...
Yeah, the eyes are a minor turn-off for me too! 😕
 
Not a huge fan of sprinkle, though she is cute, and my friend has her and very much love her. I do like her round little body. In general, I don’t like villagers who are winter themed for whatever reason, though obviously I got over it with flurry, who only has slight ‘winter’ accents. I also really hate all the house that have ice furniture, enough that it makes it hard for me to really love any of the penguins or any villagers that has it in their house. Sprinkle is just too much with her winter pastel coloring for me to really love her, but at the same time she otherwise has a very cute design and is memorable.

another interesting lesson for me about my preferences - I don’t really like pastel villagers or heavily ‘themed’ villagers -unless the theme is Japanese I guess, because I love Genji, Kabuki, Annalisa, and Croque).
Post automatically merged:

3 of my bottom 4 are left and I have a feeling I am going to be disappointed when they do show up...but I have one very beloved favorite left, and another villager I placed in my top 4 left, so cautiously hopeful about that.
 
Last edited:
WaileaNoRei said:
Not a huge fan of sprinkle, though she is cute, and my friend has her and very much love her. I do like her round little body. In general, I don’t like villagers who are winter themed for whatever reason, though obviously I got over it with flurry, who only has slight ‘winter’ accents. I also really hate all the house that have ice furniture, enough that it makes it hard for me to really love any of the penguins or any villagers that has it in their house. Sprinkle is just too much with her winter pastel coloring for me to really love her, but at the same time she otherwise has a very cute design and is memorable.

another interesting lesson for me about my preferences - I don’t really like pastel villagers or heavily ‘themed’ villagers -unless the theme is Japanese I guess, because I love Genji, Kabuki, Annalisa, and Croque).
Post automatically merged:

3 of my bottom 4 are left and I have a feeling I am going to be disappointed when they do show up...but I have one very beloved favorite left, and another villager I placed in my top 4 left, so cautiously hopeful about that.
Click to expand...
I actually really like the houses with the ice furniture and Sprinkle’s house is just 👌. I can’t remember your top 4 and bottom 4, so we’ll see...
 
Bk1234 said:
I actually really like the houses with the ice furniture and Sprinkle’s house is just 👌. I can’t remember your top 4 and bottom 4, so we’ll see...
Click to expand...

i really don’t know why I dislike them. They look uncomfortable to me, but that’s so irrational, because it is perfect for a penguin. I have no idea really, and it is a weird hang up! 😅
 
I had Sprinkle in my NL town, and I enjoyed her while she was there. I agree that’s she’s cute and that her house is very nice, but there are other peppies that I like more than her because they’re a bit more interesting design-wise imo. Though NH Sprinkle has the play hobby, so it’s cute seeing her airplane around town.

Honestly I’ve been thinking about making a dedicated winter area on my island, and someone like Hans or Sprinkle would be perfect to live there.
 
Wow, I’m pleasantly surprised Sprinkle made it this far! She’s very adorable, but I also agree that she isn’t as high up there compared to the other peppies. But her house is absolutely beautiful though, I love all the ice furniture!
 
Korichi said:
Wow, I’m pleasantly surprised Sprinkle made it this far! She’s very adorable, but I also agree that she isn’t as high up there compared to the other peppies. But her house is absolutely beautiful though, I love all the ice furniture!
Click to expand...
Yeah, I agree that she isn’t as cute as some of the other Peppies. I love to see another ice furniture fan! 😊
 
I must have missed Sprinkle's reveal yesterday. Poor Sprinkle! Oh well, maybe I'll have to bring her to my island to make up for her ranking 😂 but all things considered, I never even thought she'd make the top 50 let alone be in the final round! Placing 16 is really great considering how many villagers we've ranked!
 
Pintuition said:
I must have missed Sprinkle's reveal yesterday. Poor Sprinkle! Oh well, maybe I'll have to bring her to my island to make up for her ranking 😂 but all things considered, I never even thought she'd make the top 50 let alone be in the final round! Placing 16 is really great considering how many villagers we've ranked!
Click to expand...
That’s true. Even getting in #24 is a huge accomplishment! 😅
 
thetessagrace said:
I hope cheri shows up high on the list, i'd be really excited. she's my all time fav C:
Click to expand...

sorry, but Cheri actually was not among the 140 original villagers in the running (each of us 7 judges nominated 20 villagers)

glad to have some Cheri love making an appearance though! My personal favorite is Tabby, another peppies. A lot of the peppies have really great designs, and personally I love their enthusiastic and friendly personalities.

here’s who made the top 24, whose final placements you are now seeing. Maybe there’s someone else you can happily root for in there:


Bk1234 said:
Round 8: The Final Round
​
View attachment 330631

For everyone: We've officially narrowed it down to our Top 24. Your job now is to rank the remaining 24 contestants from 1 to 24, with #1 being the person you want to win the most.

For the rankers: You are required to submit write-ups for your Top 4 villagers and your Bottom 4 villagers, at a minimum (for a total of 8 write-ups). There is no word requirement, but at a minimum, the write-up should explain why you ranked that person at the top or bottom of your list. Write-ups can also include pictures or videos.

For the public: You guys can send me your rankings of the villagers through PM. Public voters may also submit write-ups by private message to me before the deadline.

Here is your Top 24...
  1. Bangle
  2. Beau
  3. Bruce
  4. Canberra
  5. Colton
  6. Eloise
  7. Fang
  8. Filbert
  9. Judy
  10. Kiki
  11. Merengue
  12. Merry
  13. Mint
  14. Olaf
  15. Pinky
  16. Reneigh
  17. Roald
  18. Rudy
  19. Sherb
  20. Sprinkle
  21. Sylvana
  22. Tabby
  23. Wade
  24. Yuka
The voting will close once all 7 rankers have sent me their rankings and write-ups. If I do not receive the rankings/write-ups by Saturday, November 7th (and you have not asked for an extension) I will calculate the final results without your rankings. ☹

@Asarena @Emmsey @WaileaNoRei @Verecund @misstayleigh @Florence + The Machine @Pintuition​
Click to expand...
 
WaileaNoRei said:
sorry, but Cheri actually was not among the 140 original villagers in the running (each of us 7 judges nominated 20 villagers)

glad to have some Cheri love making an appearance though! My personal favorite is Tabby, another peppies. A lot of the peppies have really great designs, and personally I love their enthusiastic and friendly personalities.

here’s who made the top 24, whose final placements you are now seeing. Maybe there’s someone else you can happily root for in there:
Click to expand...
oh bummer, well i'm rooting for bangle then, my first ac best friend C:
 
thetessagrace said:
oh bummer, well i'm rooting for bangle then, my first ac best friend C:
Click to expand...
Good luck to Bangle! 🙌😺
Post automatically merged:

WaileaNoRei said:
sorry, but Cheri actually was not among the 140 original villagers in the running (each of us 7 judges nominated 20 villagers)

glad to have some Cheri love making an appearance though! My personal favorite is Tabby, another peppies. A lot of the peppies have really great designs, and personally I love their enthusiastic and friendly personalities.

here’s who made the top 24, whose final placements you are now seeing. Maybe there’s someone else you can happily root for in there:
Click to expand...
Thank you for explaining by the way! ☺️
 
Last edited:
thetessagrace said:
oh bummer, well i'm rooting for bangle then, my first ac best friend C:
Click to expand...

Bk1234 said:
Good luck to Bangle! 🙌😺
Post automatically merged:


Thank you for explaining by the way! ☺
Click to expand...

wonderful, Bangle is my favorite in the running villager too! 🥰

and no problem, it’s been a long, ongoing game/event and I know it could be confusing from the outside.
 
awww hello! i’ve been super busy with work! i like Sprinkle’s design fine enough but had her on my island and she just drove me nuts hahah. and then it took me AGES to get her to move!
 
15. Bangle
EaJRE8VU0AIvHnu.jpg

Average Score:
12.625
Rankings:
@Florence + The Machine - 13th
@Asarena - 8th
@misstayleigh - 8th
@Verecund - 23rd
@WaileaNoRei - 2nd
@Emmsey - 18th
@Pintuition - 20th
Public - 9th

I know one ranker is going to really upset by this ranking. Bangle is a villager I have always felt neutral towards. She’s pretty cute, but her colors have never really appealed for me. I will admit that she looks really cute in the image I provided. She's also one of the better tigers that are in the game. This is kind of sad, but my fondest memories of Bangle are when I was hunting for my first Peppy and I rejected her. Maybe I would like her better if I actually had her in my town. I’ll let the other rankers give you a better summary of Bangle.

Ranker/Public Write-Ups​
@Asarena - Bangle is my second favorite tiger after Bianca. The yellow stripes go really well with her brown fur. The only things that kind of bug me are her singular light color eyelashes.

@Verecund - I actually like Bangle better than Olaf (although still less than everyone else above him), but I'm putting her below him because I nominated her twice and she's still here. What can I say - I'm stubborn. ;\ I don't even dislike Bangle at all; it's just that I'm not enthusiastic about her and she doesn't interest me enough. She's actually pretty cute, though, and the bright yellow markings on her are cool. But with so many great villagers, there has to be something to really stand out, and she's not cute enough to do that, and she just doesn't match up to the others in here.
BanglePicACNH.png


@WaileaNoRei - To be honest, Bangle was not a villager I expected to become a favorite. I was island hoping for my three first move-ins and had a limited number of tickets. I’d passed up a few villagers, don’t remember them all but definitely Puddles and Audie were in there. I didn’t know what I was looking for and was worried I had made a mistake in passing up Audie (all I knew was that she was popular, and at the time I didn’t know whether that was for a concrete reason or not). But then there was Bangle, and she was cute enough. I planned to have her for a while and then hopefully let her move out quickly to get a villager I liked more. Then one day I just realized...she was like the life of my island. She’s a great villager. I know there are no real differences but I swear she’s just extra special. Always out and about, always doing different activities – singing, treasure hunts, playing, fashioning (don’t know what to call it), hanging out with the other villagers. She’s so fun to dress up, her cheery look always makes me feel better. Originally, I wasn’t sure I liked the tiger villagers. Their heads are quite large and I didn’t know if I completely liked the design. But Bangle has such great expressiveness, and I find her body is just stocky enough to balance out her head. Can’t imagine my island without Bangle now, in a strange way I feel she is the villager Island Rep (Genji may have been around longer but he’s got his own weird jock stuff to do).
1607172432693.png
 

Attachments

  • 1607172434653.png
    1607172434653.png
    1.3 MB · Views: 17
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Cetoddle769
ACNH Frog Rain Dialogue
Replies
9
Views
451
Nunnafinga
Nunnafinga
Savont 2.0
What if : You could pay isabelle to evict a villager
Replies
7
Views
297
xxcodexx
X
W
I need help making a winter pallete!!
Replies
0
Views
55
WinniesHoneyPot
W
oliv
how to get ANY ACNL villager
Replies
2
Views
210
oliv
oliv
Savont 2.0
Cool thing i found
Replies
1
Views
100
Cetoddle769
Cetoddle769
Back
Top