ACNH Villager Rankdown (#1 and #2 HAVE BEEN POSTED!)

Sorry all, for the late response! On Pacific time out here. Here's the write up -
9CA9D65E-EA07-4C6D-96DB-3E1ED8C930E4.jpeg

Tasha - She's my least favorite of the three, but I also know a lot of people love her. The design of her eyes bothers me, they give her an odd tired look in my opinon. However, I love her coloring, it is very striking, and it sets her apart from a lot of the other snooties who tend to be more candy colored and pastely. I think her small size and her tired eyes could potentially end up being cute in game, since she's like an exhausted, sophisticated old lady, but also a tiny little thing. Then again, so far squirrels are the number one species i really want to love, and feel like they have everything i should love, but have not yet found one that is a favorite yet. Anyway, Tasha, you may not be for me, but you seem cool, and I'd choose you over a lot of other villagers, and probably not be too upset if you showed up randomly.

E50543BF-5368-415F-99A0-FBE2CCE08DE9.jpeg

Mac - He's my favorite of this group, and currently on my short list when I'm island hopping. I didn't use to like his design at all. I thought his face looked too pinchy and that he looked too angry. But now, after seeing a few people on here who love him, most notable an unfortunate user who had some kind of glitch that caused him to move out, i have come to love his weird little face. He's got the little pig nose i seem to like (see Tabby and Graham, two of my favorites) and he kind of seems like he's be a fun dog best friend, a rough and tumble friend to play with. This vibe pretty much perfectly fits the jock personality too, which despite myself - my dislike of 'muscles' talk, and my personal opposite of jock approach to life, i have come to really like them. they have cute voices, and instead of seeming like 'cool' jocks, they mostly come across as *****y weirdos, which is infinitely preferable to me. This has gotten a bit off topic, but essentially - Mac, you are a smooshie face cutie and I love you! Sorry to see you go, while I also do understand why some don't love you.

52D6F112-A21C-4E25-A18B-45C8B49E5036.jpeg

Gabi - While this picture of Gabi is adorable, I go back and forth on whether I like her design, or very much don't like her design. Her nose is a bit large, and looks like a dog nose (this is something my husband dislikes in quite a few villagers and always points out, so now it gets stuck in my head too). her eyes are also not my favorite, cause they kind of have a blank look. Still, altogether I think she has a kind of cute, nerdy look...unless she doesn't look cute at all? I can never quite decide! One thing I do love are her freckles, which are always a plus for me on villagers, because I am also a freckle face. I do wonder what he overall coloring is. Is she all reddish brown except for her head? Why? Is only her lower half red-brown, like pants. [spends five minutes googling images of Gabi to try and find the answer by seeing her in different outfits]. - so it looks like she has a ring of red brown at her wrists where her yellow paws end and then her arms are white, which makes them look like sleeves, idk, it is still confusing. In conclusion, this is not what i set out to write, but I guess Gabi just confuses me. Still, sad to see her go, she is at least not boring, which is the worst thing a villager can be for me.

Hope these write-ups will do, looking forward to the next nominations! We really created a pretty good group in our top 140.
 
I believe that means I'm next to nominate? Here are the 7 I choose:
- Whitney
- Agnes
- Maple
- Kyle
- Biff
- Kabuki
- Coco

Also I went through the list of remaining villagers and removed the fast pass recipients plus the ones that have already been saved/cut this round. I checked it like 4 times so it should be accurate.
Anabelle
Apple
Baabara
Bam
Bangle
Blaire
Bruce
Canberra
Carmen
Charlise
Chèvre
Clay
Colton
Diana
Dotty
Eloise
Elvis
Flora
Flurry
Freckles
Frita
Frobert
Gala
Genji
Graham
Hamlet
Hans
Ike
Jacob/Jakey
Judy
Ken
Lobo
Megan
Merry
Mint
Mitzi
Moe
Muffy
Peanut
Phoebe
Pinky
Poncho
Prince
Reneigh
Roald
Rudy
Savannah
Spike
Sprinkle
Stitches
Sylvana
Timbra
Ursala
Vesta
Vivian
Walker

In regards to the last set of cuts/saves, I'm glad to see my plan worked. I know Kiki and Static are popular so I was hoping I could sneak Rod into the next round by putting him in their group.
 
I believe that means I'm next to nominate? Here are the 7 I choose:
- Whitney
- Agnes
- Maple
- Kyle
- Biff
- Kabuki
- Coco

Also I went through the list of remaining villagers and removed the fast pass recipients plus the ones that have already been saved/cut this round. I checked it like 4 times so it should be accurate.
Anabelle
Apple
Baabara
Bam
Bangle
Blaire
Bruce
Canberra
Carmen
Charlise
Chèvre
Clay
Colton
Diana
Dotty
Eloise
Elvis
Flora
Flurry
Freckles
Frita
Frobert
Gala
Genji
Graham
Hamlet
Hans
Ike
Jacob/Jakey
Judy
Ken
Lobo
Megan
Merry
Mint
Mitzi
Moe
Muffy
Peanut
Phoebe
Pinky
Poncho
Prince
Reneigh
Roald
Rudy
Savannah
Spike
Sprinkle
Stitches
Sylvana
Timbra
Ursala
Vesta
Vivian
Walker

In regards to the last set of cuts/saves, I'm glad to see my plan worked. I know Kiki and Static are popular so I was hoping I could sneak Rod into the next round by putting him in their group.
Thank you!!!! 😊 It is now @Pintuition ’s turn to save one villager, and split the remaining six into two groups of three.
Post automatically merged:

hellloooo I just want to say I have been lurking on this thread and it has been highly entertaining,,, thank u all for your insight even though cutting some of my favourites has been painful hahaha
This means so much! 😊 I’m glad you’re entertained, but I’m sorry about your favorites. 😅
 
GROUP 1 AHDSAHFESA
vote group 1 and win 3,000 tbt c:
Post automatically merged:

Argh, I hate having to vote to save Whitney, but I love Agnes so much! @Bk1234 you are diabolical 😖
Haha, I vote to save group 2. (Also, sorry Biff!)
noOOOOOOO TAKE IT BACK AGNES IS NOT WORTH IT FOR WHITNEY
Post automatically merged:

hellloooo I just want to say I have been lurking on this thread and it has been highly entertaining,,, thank u all for your insight even though cutting some of my favourites has been painful hahaha
Aha yes it's quite a fun lil thread c: i lofe the writeups
 
y'all, please protect my child Kabuki. I've been keeping up with this thread and thoroughly enjoy reading along so thank you so much for keeping me entertained :'D I'm really happy to see some less popular villagers having a chance to shine (even though everyone's sleeping on Colton smh)
 
y'all, please protect my child Kabuki. I've been keeping up with this thread and thoroughly enjoy reading along so thank you so much for keeping me entertained :'D I'm really happy to see some less popular villagers having a chance to shine (even though everyone's sleeping on Colton smh)
dude i stan for Kabuki, and I also hecking want Colton to live for just a lil longer (eh... maybe not win, obviously that's Tammi's job)
glad you've been liking it!! Say, are my write-ups any good?
 
GROUP 1 AHDSAHFESA
vote group 1 and win 3,000 tbt c:
Post automatically merged:


noOOOOOOO TAKE IT BACK AGNES IS NOT WORTH IT FOR WHITNEY

Haha, I was very torn, and I hate it honestly. But on the other hand I also am not big on Kyle, I think he looks kind of creepy, so in then end I just couldn’t give up Agnes. At least if Agnes does end up getting cut I will have some consultation though.


y'all, please protect my child Kabuki. I've been keeping up with this thread and thoroughly enjoy reading along so thank you so much for keeping me entertained :'D I'm really happy to see some less popular villagers having a chance to shine (even though everyone's sleeping on Colton smh)

I do think Kabuki is one of the best designs in the game, tbh, and regret that I didn’t click with him when he was on my island.
 
dude i stan for Kabuki, and I also hecking want Colton to live for just a lil longer (eh... maybe not win, obviously that's Tammi's job)
glad you've been liking it!! Say, are my write-ups any good?
They definitely are fun to read! I love the contrast between the write-ups, everyone has a specific way of wording things and approaching the challenges. I'm very pleased to see the praise for Kabuki and Colton, I can now happily disappear again lol


Haha, I was very torn, and I hate it honestly. But on the other hand I also am not big on Kyle, I think he looks kind of creepy, so in then end I just couldn’t give up Agnes. At least if Agnes does end up getting cut I will have some consultation though.

I do think Kabuki is one of the best designs in the game, tbh, and regret that I didn’t click with him when he was on my island.
Understandable, sometimes it just doesn't work out :) When Kabuki wears the Kitsune mask I gifted him it looks so cute (unlike the human characters, the villagers wear them like a hair clip on the side of the head)
 
Honestly, I was torn between wanting to save Whitney and not wanting to save Coco, but I'm mostly apathetic towards all of the villagers in group 1, so group 2 it was.
 
I was hoping that this would be my chance to get Whitney and Coco out of the competition, but I should've seen this coming with how popular they both are. Regardless, here are my write-ups for the 3 who got cut.

Kyle
In all honestly, the wolves are one of my least favorite species overall. There's something about their weirdly long faces and the spikes on the backs of their heads that doesn't sit well with me. Kyle is one of my least favorites within the species, which is mostly due to his half-closed eyes. I'm not really a fan of this type of "lazy" eyes that Nintendo seems to like to give to a bunch of different villagers, but I can at least appreciate the fact that Kyle's design is based on the African wild dog. He used to be infamous in the NL community for having one of the worst house exteriors in the entire game, but he got a bit of an upgrade in NH. I get that he's supposed to be part of a band, and that's why his house is filled with instruments, but I kinda feel bad for him because it's pretty barren otherwise and he doesn't even have a place to sleep. I won't be sad to see him go.
120px-Kyle_NH.png



Kabuki
He definitely has the best design out of the three getting eliminated this round. He's very distinctive and I really like the pink detailing on the ends of his paws and at the tip of his tail, plus cranky is my personal favorite out of the 8 personality types. There are so many different cat villagers in the game that some of them inevitably get tossed by the wayside, but Kabuki has such a memorable design that he manages to stand out despite the overabundance of felines. His house design is simple yet cozy, and he actually has amenities like a bed and toilet that a real living being would need in their house (not really related, but do any of the cats have a litter box in their house? That would fit their theme better, but would also be kinda gross lol). Kabuki was also one of the villagers that had their default outfits improved the most between NL and NH; the yukata is perfect on him. I'm not sure what to add besides the fact that Kabuki didn't deserve the injustice of being cut yet.
Kabuki_NH.png



Biff
I used to be biased against the hippos in NL, but their improved NH model has changed my mind. Biff is very cute now, and his little tail is probably my favorite thing about him. I also think that his new red color suits him much better than the weird brownish hue that he used to be pre-NH. The gold shirt looks way better on him than that ugly shirt he used to wear too. His house exterior is aggressively red, which could be an issue for some people, and the interior has almost nothing inside. It's like he's living in an alleyway, which is kinda sad imo. Anyway, he's cute and I plan on having him in my town at some point because I still haven't decided on which jock I want.
Biff_NH.png
 
Last edited:
I was hoping that this would be my chance to get Whitney and Coco out of the competition, but I should've seen this coming with how popular they both are. Regardless, here are my write-ups for the 3 who got cut.

Kyle
In all honestly, the wolves are one of my least favorite species overall. There's something about their weirdly long faces and the spikes on the backs of their heads that doesn't sit well with me. Kyle is one of my least favorites within the species, which is mostly due to his half-closed eyes. I'm not really a fan of this type of "lazy" eyes that Nintendo seems to like to give to a bunch of different villagers, but I can at least appreciate the fact that Kyle's design is based on the African wild dog. He used to be infamous in the NL community for having one of the worst house exteriors in the entire game, but he got a bit of an upgrade in NH. I get that he's supposed to be part of a band, and that's why his house is filled with instruments, but I kinda feel bad for him because it's pretty barren otherwise and he doesn't even have a place to sleep. I won't be sad to see him go.
120px-Kyle_NH.png



Kabuki
He definitely has the best design out of the three getting eliminated this round. He's very distinctive and I really like the pink detailing on the ends of his paws and at the tip of his tail, plus cranky is my personal favorite out of the 8 personality types. There are so many different cat villagers in the game that some of them inevitably get tossed by the wayside, but Kabuki has such a memorable design that he manages to stand out despite the overabundance of felines. His house design is simple yet cozy, and he actually has amenities like a bed and toilet that a real living being would need in their house (not really related, but do any of the cats have a litter box in their house? That would fit their theme better, but would also be kinda gross lol). Kabuki was also one of the villagers that had their default outfits improved the most between NL and NH; the yukata is perfect on him. I'm not sure what to add besides the fact that Kabuki didn't deserve the injustice of being cut yet.
Kabuki_NH.png



Biff
I used to be biased against the hippos in NL, but their improved NH model has changed my mind. Biff is very cute now, and his little tail is probably my favorite thing about him. I also think that his new red color suits him much better than the weird brownish hue that the used to be pre-NH. The gold shirt looks way better on him than that ugly shirt he used to wear too. His house exterior is aggressively red, which could be an issue for some people, and the interior has almost nothing inside. It's like he's living in an alleyway, which is kinda sad imo. Anyway, he's cute and I plan on having him in my town at some point because I still haven't decided on which jock I want.
Biff_NH.png


😭 I voted against this group, but still so so sad to see Biff and Kabuki go!
Also I agree completely about the wolf design - the head proportions are odd to me and why are they so spiky?Why do they have tails that are stiff spikes/ maces when the other animals with long tails have tails that move and wave so cutely.

this was a tough round, ngl. @saucySheep, I really let you down and will pay you a 10tbt apology fee. I guess I really love Agnes that much.
 
Well that was an exciting group of villagers! 😅 I will admit that I am sad to see Kyle go... 😢 Anyway, it is now @Pintuition ’s turn to post their seven nominees. 😊
Post automatically merged:

y'all, please protect my child Kabuki. I've been keeping up with this thread and thoroughly enjoy reading along so thank you so much for keeping me entertained :'D I'm really happy to see some less popular villagers having a chance to shine (even though everyone's sleeping on Colton smh)
Sorry about Kabuki... 😢 I’m glad you at least find this entertaining! 😅
 
Back
Top