Mafia American Politics Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

[Dolby]

I think improbable role mafia still wounds me and that's why I bring the possibility up. But meh, it's my only possible hangup if anything. What's this about the survivor rolechange should you lose the election? Might as well ask while you're here.

It was to resolve the issue of it being impossible for us to win if neither of us were elected in Punchys fakeclaim. Again, not a part of our roles

Yeah, I really need to focus on reading people

 

[Biancasbotique]

You should all vote Vanessa because she is a #liar lol

 

[Dolby]

im pretty sure that thats what he was trying to say, its kinda unclear

Yeah, what he was saying there was that he wanted to change our fakeclaim to surv after we lost the election

 

[Biancasbotique]

Dolby and Punchy smh ...so scummy!

 

[illunie]

I'm reading that as the hypothetical bizarre roles he was thinking of bringing up?

from what i can tell from whats happened, punchy got flustered by being called out for being too buddy buddy with dolby, so they roleclaimed without checking with dolby first to try and show that dolby isnt maf, then when they realised what happened they backpeddaled and claimed to be masons. i dont know if punchy is saying that they wouldve said that they would convert to survivors if they kept up with the president win condition 'lie' or that they will convert to survivors after d0 as masons right now.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dolby and Punchy smh ...so scummy!

thanks for the annual one line opinion, see ya in 8 hours

- - - Post Merge - - -

im joking its a goof ha ha but please say more

 

[Dolby]

from what i can tell from whats happened, punchy got flustered by being called out for being too buddy buddy with dolby, so they roleclaimed without checking with dolby first to try and show that dolby isnt maf, then when they realised what happened they backpeddaled and claimed to be masons. i dont know if punchy is saying that they wouldve said that they would convert to survivors if they kept up with the president win condition 'lie' or that they will convert to survivors after d0 as masons right now.

- - - Post Merge - - -


thanks for the annual one line opinion, see ya in 8 hours

He was saying that he was going to claim that we were going to convert to survivors after the D0 election, not that we actually are

Yeah, I’m not going to be able to get thoughts out tonight, planning to tomorrow

 

[Geoni]

That clears things up. Lel you must be so annoyed rn Dolby.

Also you don't need to attempt to explain things to me in order to come off as helpful Rune.

 

[illunie]

That clears things up. Lel you must be so annoyed rn Dolby.

Also you don't need to attempt to explain things to me in order to come off as helpful Rune.

i was genuinely trying to explain, but if its not helpful i can stop

 

[Geoni]

Tbh I think Punchy is town but at the same time I don't trust him enough to vote for Dolby just bevause he says so

- - - Post Merge - - -

I don't have strong feelings on anyone based on last night's Toads-Dolby-Ness fued. I see some people are suss of how hard Toads is campaigning but he did the same thing in Kingmaker (granted, he was third party and had an agenda of keeping me safe, but I think that's just how he plays and it is not alignment indicative)

This entire post came across as wishy-washy.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm still catching up but this was the first post I saw when I opened the thread and it feels kind of filler-y to me, people could easily find this info for themselves by clicking on the number of posts this thread has (unless nobody else knew that, in which case, I guess this is ok) so to me this looks like one of those contributions made for the sake of looking helpful, like what Chele did the first time she was scum. Granted I know nothing about runeraiders play style

Hmm, interesting post though, and this was before the post I just quoted. If anything what they followed up with was just as fillery and this also seems like a very pushy thing for a player like Vanessa to do on day 1. Or 0 technically.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm still catching up but this was the first post I saw when I opened the thread and it feels kind of filler-y to me, people could easily find this info for themselves by clicking on the number of posts this thread has (unless nobody else knew that, in which case, I guess this is ok) so to me this looks like one of those contributions made for the sake of looking helpful, like what Chele did the first time she was scum. Granted I know nothing about runeraiders play style

Hmm, interesting post though, and this was before the post I just quoted. If anything what they followed up with was just as fillery and this also seems like a very pushy thing for a player like Vanessa to do on day 1. Or 0 technically.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ew a doublepost I hate this forum rn.

i was genuinely trying to explain, but if its not helpful i can stop

What are your scumreads?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also Chele what are your scumreads? You're one of my choices for president so I'd like to know what you read of people so far.

 

[Chele]

Uhm guys I don’t think I can play this game, this year has been too hard for me and I keep just getting new things to have to do.
The reasons I won’t be available are...
1) it’s my Birthday (Feb 13) so I’ve gotta go out with friends
2) I keep getting homework
3) there’s no point to keep excusing myself if I drop in very rarely.
Thank you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also the forums are amazingly glitchy so that’s another reason why I can’t play

 

[illunie]

What are your scumreads?

rn i think the people most sus are bianca and toad sorta. bianca hasnt really posted anything of substance all game, even tho shes come in multiple times to check up. im not sure how experienced she is but it sorta feels like she wants to push an agenda but doesnt really want to commit to it. like this:

We should lynch both Dolby and Punchy

its super vague and provides no real info. its less of a scumread and more of a please talk more, but its still super sus

also, toad has been campaigning super hard for pres and has been super defensive towards anyone questioning him, while simultaneously not explaining his reasons for wanting to be pres, citing that he wants to provide an alternative to ness and dolby when there isnt even really need. only problem with him being scum is that it seems almost too obvious and destructive towards his chances of winning, and as ive stated before pres doesnt even seem that strong to risk being lynched for it

idk, kinda hard to make scum reads rn since theres no real reason to act scummy at all, itll become a lot easier when we reach d1

 

[Geoni]

Chele noooo :C

And yeah I have some similar thoughts on Toads, Rune. One interesting question to ask is this: what alternative do each of the candidates provide when compared? I legitimately can't decide between them because they have aired only a few suspects. Some more than others.

 

[illunie]

And yeah I have some similar thoughts on Toads, Rune. One interesting question to ask is this: what alternative do each of the candidates provide when compared? I legitimately can't decide between them because they have aired only a few suspects. Some more than others.

honestly, im kinda apprehensive about voting for players who are competent enough to be able to use the pres role effectively as maf, but if i had to pick out of the 'candidates' (which im assuming is dolby, ness and toad) id probably pick ness since it seems like hes the one most contributing to discussion and objectively looking at the, while toad seems to be more focused on not letting dolby and ness be pres rather than actually utilise the role for towns sake and im suspicious about dolbys motivation to become pres. overall, my choice for pres would be glow since they have made some pretty well thought out contributions to discussion and she may or may not be innocent child (if i could get a hard call on that itd basically be an insta vote for me)

 

[Geoni]

I don't think she was legitimately claiming that.

 

[illunie]

I don't think she was legitimately claiming that.

the way she said it sounded like at least a soft call

if ur town:

*you will see my alignment n1

idk that seems like a call to me, maybe the wordings just weird

 

[unravel]

go and read the OP

You can't just tell me to go read the goddamn op the reason why i ask for link so it would be MUCH DAMN EASIER and TBT server issue you cant tell me to go read the op ur just talking none sense in game I see 0% contributions from you all you did is calling out from lurking and people who didnt post the thread also ruining Dolby's plan rip "Mason" partner

...

Wtf did I just read "Punchy fake claim" and his condition or am I seeing things well this is interesting now I'm having doubts with the both of them but I know who to blame why we mislynch a town so early

 

[cornimer]

rn i think the people most sus are bianca and toad sorta. bianca hasnt really posted anything of substance all game, even tho shes come in multiple times to check up. im not sure how experienced she is but it sorta feels like she wants to push an agenda but doesnt really want to commit to it. like this:

Trust me, she does this D1 every game regardless of alignment. You gotta wait a few days to tell with her

- - - Post Merge - - -

rn i think the people most sus are bianca and toad sorta. bianca hasnt really posted anything of substance all game, even tho shes come in multiple times to check up. im not sure how experienced she is but it sorta feels like she wants to push an agenda but doesnt really want to commit to it. like this:

Trust me, she does this D1 every game regardless of alignment. You gotta wait a few days to tell with her

- - - Post Merge - - -

I feel like nothing has happened other than the Dolby/Punchy scandal. And I totally don't think Glow was claiming innocent child, I took it as saying that she'll be nightkilled N1 if she is town, which she herself confirmed here:

excuse u fishy mcfisherson i was just saying that bc i will be dead n1

My only slight sus rn is Runeraider just because of the fillery post I mentioned earlier and because of how much he was questioning Punchy/Dolby, like he went back and forth with them forever and kept asking the same questions imo and I can see that as town trying to catch a slip but I can also see that as scum trying to make them seem sus and prevent us from actually scumhunting. But like I said, this is a small sus.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I feel like nothing has happened other than the Dolby/Punchy scandal. And I totally don't think Glow was claiming innocent child, I took it as saying that she'll be nightkilled N1 if she is town, which she herself confirmed here:

excuse u fishy mcfisherson i was just saying that bc i will be dead n1

My only slight sus rn is Runeraider just because of the fillery post I mentioned earlier and because of how much he was questioning Punchy/Dolby, like he went back and forth with them forever and kept asking the same questions imo and I can see that as town trying to catch a slip but I can also see that as scum trying to make them seem sus and prevent us from actually scumhunting. But like I said, this is a small sus.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Alright, I think I've caught up, for the most part.



I'm a bit confused. Is your WC still getting Dolby elected as President, or are you claiming that you are a straight mason that has a normal WC? (Sorry if this doesn't make much sense, I'm a bit ill atm.)

We are Masons that have a normal WC

- - - Post Merge - - -

Where's the PUNCHY IS CLEAR thing Kat had in rhom now?

 

[N e s s]

So I've even screwed over twice now with the servers and the site on works for me on mobile. Wanted to write a reads post last night, boom database error. So, here is a brief copy paste of my google doc.

PunchyDaHufflepuff: Somewhat confirmed town? Him and Dolby are apparently masons together, which I can believe.

Amazonevan19: Said “I’m nobody important so i don’t want presidency”, not sure what to make of this but I have several theories. Somewhat townish, more null.

Biancasbotique: Acting a bit aloof i guess? She’s not putting in a lot of effort like she did in the last game (improbable role mafia), so she isn’t really doing anything of help at this moment. Null.

VanessaMay18: Slight town-leaning, mostly based off of tone. Need to read into more.

Glow: Stated that “N1 you will know my alignment”, kinda think this was a reference to the fact that she dies on N1 almost every game.

Dad: Haven’t had enough time to analyze his posts.

Dolby: Somewhat confirmed town? Him and PunchyDaHufflepuff are apparently masons together.

Locket: N/A

Toadsworthy: He seems to be proposing that he is a good alternative to me and Dolby for president when I don’t really see why... wants Vanessa as president for no apparent reason. Suspicious, but i’m not incredibly suspicious of him since I’ve seen this kind of behaviour from him before.

Chele: Haven’t had enough time to analyze her posts.
Hikari: Has seemingly been coasting, but that might be because she’s a returning player after like 5 years.

Byngo: Haven’t had enough time to analyze her posts.

Runeraider: Leaning town, his posts feel more genuine if anything. I’ve liked the purpose behind his several posts, as they don’t have any kind of malice behind them. Although, I kinda feel as if some of his posts have been a little bit fillery, along with how he’s focused on Punchy/Dolby right now when they’ve already explained everything.

Jacob: Weakly suspicious of right now, mentioned 4 players (Vanessa, Locket, Byngo and Amazonevan19) as players he wanted elected as president for little to no reason. This is a bit closer to his town play though, so this read may change in the future.

Tina: Townleaning, kinda felt as if the 180 on Dolby was a townish thing to do.

ITookYourWaffles: Slightly suspicious, mostly because their content seems a bit wishy washy. Will elaborate more later.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I'm not really liking Runeraider, I thought my first or second post explained it well.