Mafia American Politics Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

[PunchyTheCat]

No he didn't he was offline and I cracked into claiming a fake role bc thats what I thought was best. but no.

 

[Geoni]

Can we not already be twenty pages in pls?

Give me tonight to catch up. Idk if I will be able to be super active, depends on if my supervisor comes on site for the night, but for now I suggest not electing anyone with a decent amount of experience to be president because I'm not mafia so I think Dolby/glow/Ness are likely.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Let the record state that DADDY IS ON THIS THREAD RN

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well oops

- - - Post Merge - - -

Why did the thread die?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Why did the thread die?

 

[illunie]

the servers have honestly made me consider suicide

anyway, i still feel pretty unconviced by the whole dolby/punchy scenario. it feels like punchy let something slip and dolby is desparately trying to backpedal while he still can. i think its pretty clear based on punchys specific wording that dolby and punchys win condition is to get elected. the only question i have left is what will happen if they do win? i think its unlikely the whole game will end so early.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

the servers have honestly made me consider suicide

anyway, i still feel pretty unconviced by the whole dolby/punchy scenario. it feels like punchy let something slip and dolby is desparately trying to backpedal while he still can. i think its pretty clear based on punchys specific wording that dolby and punchys win condition is to get elected. the only question i have left is what will happen if they do win? i think its unlikely the whole game will end so early.

OMFG IM NOT THE OPPOSIE OF A LYNCHER WE'RE MASONS SMH

 

[illunie]

OMFG IM NOT THE OPPOSIE OF A LYNCHER WE'RE MASONS SMH

then why would you specifically state that your win condition was to get dolby elected, and vice versa, instead of just saying you trusted him due to your role as mason and thought he would be a good candidate? the wording is way to strange to just ignore

- - - Post Merge - - -

and if you really were masons, why would the chat be closed after just d0? it feels really odd that the chat would be closed the moment pres voting becomes irrelevant and for it to be unconnected

 

[PunchyTheCat]

then why would you specifically state that your win condition was to get dolby elected, and vice versa, instead of just saying you trusted him due to your role as mason and thought he would be a good candidate? the wording is way to strange to just ignore

- - - Post Merge - - -

and if you really were masons, why would the chat be closed after just d0? it feels really odd that the chat would be closed the moment pres voting becomes irrelevant and for it to be unconnected

I didn't know what I was doing, the second part is also a lie.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

then why would you specifically state that your win condition was to get dolby elected, and vice versa, instead of just saying you trusted him due to your role as mason and thought he would be a good candidate? the wording is way to strange to just ignore

- - - Post Merge - - -

and if you really were masons, why would the chat be closed after just d0? it feels really odd that the chat would be closed the moment pres voting becomes irrelevant and for it to be unconnected

I didn't know what I was doing, the second part is also a lie.

 

[unravel]

I can't find Glow's post about dolby and punchy link me pls ****ing server...

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Does day end when the last person sends in their vote?

 

[illunie]

I didn't know what I was doing, the second part is also a lie.

i distinctly remember someone saying the chat closed after d0, lemme find the quote

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I can't find Glow's post about dolby and punchy link me pls ****ing server...

go and read the OP

- - - Post Merge - - -

i distinctly remember someone saying the chat closed after d0, lemme find the quote

I did say that, it was a lie and it doesn't close after D0

- - - Post Merge - - -

i distinctly remember someone saying the chat closed after d0, lemme find the quote

I did say that, it was a lie and it doesn't close after D0

 

[N e s s]

After everything that has happened, I am leaning towards believing Dolby and Punchy as masons. However; this is not to say that I want them to be elected as president. Yes, it is true that they are basically confirmed town should one of them die, but I feel as if there are more valuable roles then masons that should be elected so they can be protected. Their argument right now is "Elect one of us as you have a bullet proof innocent child", but at the end of the day one of you will already be confirmed should the other die yes? One of you is more than likely going to be killed at some point, so one of you will eventually be confirmed. The way I see it, Punchy has already cooked both of your gooses by revealing you're masons. If one of you dies the other is confirmed, so mafia would need both of you dead to prevent either of you from being in the game too long.

also for christs sake make my god damn post tbt

 

[PunchyTheCat]

After everything that has happened, I am leaning towards believing Dolby and Punchy as masons. However; this is not to say that I want them to be elected as president. Yes, it is true that they are basically confirmed town should one of them die, but I feel as if there are more valuable roles then masons that should be elected so they can be protected. Their argument right now is "Elect one of us as you have a bullet proof innocent child", but at the end of the day one of you will already be confirmed should the other die yes? One of you is more than likely going to be killed at some point, so one of you will eventually be confirmed. The way I see it, Punchy has already cooked both of your gooses by revealing you're masons. If one of you dies the other is confirmed, so mafia would need both of you dead to prevent either of you from being in the game too long.

also for christs sake make my god damn post tbt

Why are you speculating on this?

 

[illunie]

I did say that, it was a lie and it doesn't close after D0

what possible reason could you have to lie about that lmao

 

[PunchyTheCat]

what possible reason could you have to lie about that lmao

bc I'm an idiot

 

[cornimer]

Tbh I might be ok with electing Dolby or Punchy if nobody else seems super town. They are the most likely to be town out of everyone
I like Ness' tone very much buuut he's also a really good player so I don't fully trust him

 

[illunie]

bc I'm an idiot

you cant keep refuting points with 'i made a mistake', at some point you have to give a reasonable explantion for why. responding to every argument with 'i made a oopsie he he xd' isnt going to get you any trust or help. i want you to tell me if you are just a mason or your win condition is to become pres, and if your answer is the former i want a real argument for why you said the things you did besides 'it was just a mistake'. im not trying to yell at you or get you lynched or smth, i just need an answer so that we can continue.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Does day end when the last person sends in their vote?

No, day ends at the scheduled time. Also, to answer a question that has come up through private messaging, you are allowed to change your vote if you really want to but it'd be more convenient if you just send in your vote when you are sure of who you are voting for.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

you cant keep refuting points with 'i made a mistake', at some point you have to give a reasonable explantion for why. responding to every argument with 'i made a oopsie he he xd' isnt going to get you any trust or help. i want you to tell me if you are just a mason or your win condition is to become pres, and if your answer is the former i want a real argument for why you said the things you did besides 'it was just a mistake'. im not trying to yell at you or get you lynched or smth, i just need an answer so that we can continue.

Dolby has said that we're a straight mason, and we are. No other catches.