Mafia American Politics Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

it’s not totally weird. ik as a detective id choose people that i have trouble reading, not necessarily just going with the top tier players

that could be the thought process in the possible oracle

I guess that's true, but I'd probably, and assume most others would, choose someone more universally sussed like Vanessa, Toads, Rune, someone who wouldn't be killed by mafia before someone with as little activity as Locket
 
Just comparing Locket's ISO from this game to Day 1 Caxnival rustles my jimmies
 
****ing hell so much thing to catch up reveal the messages now guys and now im having doubts with toads and vanessas claim but if i were to pick who to lynch its Toads man hes most suspicious of all anyway

- - - Post Merge - - -

Wtf 3 millers what is **** is going on in here
 
Alright look. I'm going to play Devil's advocate here and say that I don't think that Toadsworthy is mafia right now. I certainly do not trust him at all, in fact I even think that he is a 3rd party role. But I mean come on would Toads really be this bad as mafia? I've played with him as scum twice before and he has been far more deliberate then how he has played in this game.

All I can say is that I doubt toads would play scum this way.
 
Alright look. I'm going to play Devil's advocate here and say that I don't think that Toadsworthy is mafia right now. I certainly do not trust him at all, in fact I even think that he is a 3rd party role. But I mean come on would Toads really be this bad as mafia? I've played with him as scum twice before and he has been far more deliberate then how he has played in this game.

All I can say is that I doubt toads would play scum this way.
So what you're basically saying is that we should sus Vanessa?
 
what r u the differences u noted

to me she seemed more invested in caxnival mafia

Well, one thing I noticed is that she has been relatively a lot more reserved so far in this game than how she played during the first day of Caxnival. She made a reads post incredibly early that contained people she was suspicious of, which she has done the same in this game, but we're nearly 5 real time days into the game and she has yet to provide a sus on a single player. She even stated in her reads post that she would talk about her scumleans later, which she never did.

And as you said, she felt far more invested in that game than this.

- - - Post Merge - - -

So what you're basically saying is that we should sus Vanessa?

And no, that is not what I'm saying. Her and Toads are in the same boat.
 
Well, one thing I noticed is that she has been relatively a lot more reserved so far in this game than how she played during the first day of Caxnival. She made a reads post incredibly early that contained people she was suspicious of, which she has done the same in this game, but we're nearly 5 real time days into the game and she has yet to provide a sus on a single player. She even stated in her reads post that she would talk about her scumleans later, which she never did.

And as you said, she felt far more invested in that game than this.

- - - Post Merge - - -



And no, that is not what I'm saying. Her and Toads are in the same boat.
I thought you said that you thought one was scum and one was town
 
Also, if we do choose to lynch Locket, it will help us determine if we should listen to any further messages. (If Locket is lynched and revealed to have been mafia (or another Miller) then we can trust the messages. Otherwise, we know that the messages were false, unless we have some kind of "insane" role going on.)
 
theres no way theres three millers right? thatd be insane.
If Rune is maf I think he just slipped that Locket is town lul, alongside Vanessa/Toads

I think we can all learn that everyone in politics is corrupt and will probs return maf :)
 
Also, if we do choose to lynch Locket, it will help us determine if we should listen to any further messages. (If Locket is lynched and revealed to have been mafia (or another Miller) then we can trust the messages. Otherwise, we know that the messages were false, unless we have some kind of "insane" role going on.)
pretty sure an insane oracle is a little too crazy, i mean sure its possible but probably not

- - - Post Merge - - -

If Rune is maf I think he just slipped that Locket is town lul, alongside Vanessa/Toads

I think we can all learn that everyone in politics is corrupt and will probs return maf :)
i meant that i thought it would be super unlikely for there too be three millers, since if locket was town and both vanessa and toads were telling the truth there would be three separate millers.
 
also probably a bad time to say that I'm traveling to visit family tomorrow for the weekend. If you have questions for me, I will get to them in the times I can take to get away from family lol
 
pretty sure an insane oracle is a little too crazy, i mean sure its possible but probably not

- - - Post Merge - - -


i meant that i thought it would be super unlikely for there too be three millers, since if locket was town and both vanessa and toads were telling the truth there would be three separate millers.
But it's just weird how you assumed she was innocent despite the 'report' saying she was guilty.
In addition, this 'report' was sent by an anonymous person correct @Bianca?? Or did you straight up receive a report saying she returned mafia aligned.
 
Back
Top