Any 'popular' villagers you just don't like?
- Thread starter mapleleaf
- Start date
SheepMareep
Actual Magical Girl
Judy is ugly. When everyone was freaking out about her I just... no.... 0/10. Can not stand her design at all. I think they could of done away with the white area on her face/made it smaller more around just her mouth, or at least the eyeshadow that sticks out terribly. Her eyes are also way too much. I just... dont... like her... and I tend to love the pastel/cutesy characters
Last edited:
trashpedia
🌟🌊
I don’t think they’re ugly but I just find Merengue and Marina extremely overrated.
Krissi2197
wolf pack fanatic
Marshall tbh. When everyone went feral over him back in the NL days I was so confused as to why he was so loved. I dont mind him but I wouldnt go out of my way to try to get him!
Paperboy012305
Male Villager for Mario Kart on Switch 2!
Basically every single tier 1 villager except for Raymond and Diana. I can get behind them.
I don’t generally care for cat or wolf villagers, and a lot of them are popular. I’ve just never liked cats, and I usually boot them out of towns ASAP. I used to be scared of wolves as a little kid (and I still remember some of the fairly vivid nightmares), and while I’ve warmed to them over time, I don’t particularly like them (even though I seem to end up with them in a lot of my towns by chance).
Marshall is fine, but I don’t really get the craze. He’s not bad, and if I get him, I’ll try him out and see what I think, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to recruit him.
Marshall is fine, but I don’t really get the craze. He’s not bad, and if I get him, I’ll try him out and see what I think, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to recruit him.
Chicken Tender
arrivederci
Judy and Raymond..... i just........ i just cant get behind them.....
Sprinklebun
Senior Member
Stitches, Julian, and Muffy. I’ve had Muffy in my NL town for 2 years now. I’ve never been able to get rid of her, even though I can’t stand her. I really don’t like any of the sheep villagers, especially Pietro the clown ::shudder::
I think for me, it’s not that I don’t GET the hype over some of the popular ones, it’s just that they’re not quite what I like.
Marina, for example. I get it cause she’s pretty cute, she’s pink. But I’m not a fan of the octopi villagers myself.
Julian I get also. He’s a unicorn and I mean he is pretty. But again, not one I really want. Muffy i understand as well since I assume it’s mostly cause she’s a goth sheep lol it’s unique. So I guess for the main ‘popular’ villagers it’s that they’re unique. Stitches and Merengue are cute and unique as well.
But yeah, I’m not a huge fan of Muffy, Merengue, Julian...and really Pietro cause honestly he’s creepy lol sorry for that one. Again it’s probably cause he’s unique though
Marina, for example. I get it cause she’s pretty cute, she’s pink. But I’m not a fan of the octopi villagers myself.
Julian I get also. He’s a unicorn and I mean he is pretty. But again, not one I really want. Muffy i understand as well since I assume it’s mostly cause she’s a goth sheep lol it’s unique. So I guess for the main ‘popular’ villagers it’s that they’re unique. Stitches and Merengue are cute and unique as well.
But yeah, I’m not a huge fan of Muffy, Merengue, Julian...and really Pietro cause honestly he’s creepy lol sorry for that one. Again it’s probably cause he’s unique though
Last edited:
TortimerCrossing
♡ bad egg ♡
Raymond which is hilarious since he moved into my town! Aesthetically he isn't my type, but I will say his dialogue is amazing.
I wouldn't say there are many popular villagers I "don't like" but there are lot of them I don't really get the fuss about....especially a lot of the more straight forward conventionally cute ones.
I think I'm just more likely to find the dorky or oddball ones "cute" rather than the "cute" cute ones. (I'm like that with Pokemon too)
Also, I think Marshall is fine and I wouldn't be upset to get him but I'm not as mad about him as everyone else seems to be.
I think I'm just more likely to find the dorky or oddball ones "cute" rather than the "cute" cute ones. (I'm like that with Pokemon too)
Also, I think Marshall is fine and I wouldn't be upset to get him but I'm not as mad about him as everyone else seems to be.
spawnpoint
Take a chance! 🎲
Stitches, Merengue, Judy, Julian
Ohhhhh I have quite a few lol.
Flurry - i just think she's hideous. What even are those eyebrows?
Marshal - he's fine, but I don't understand the fuss? There are much cuter squirrels - Poppy, Mint, Blaire, Sylvana, Filbert...
Rosie - again, she's fine, but I don't get the fuss.
Judy - her name/personality/aesthetic just don't make sense to me. She seems like she should be peppy and have a different name.
Raymond - he's probably my least favorite of the 8 new villagers honestly. He just does not appeal to me.
Zucker - He's so....blah...to me.
Chrissy and Francine - their whole pop star aesthetic is just not my style
Ankha - again, she just is not my style.
Peanut - I just don't like her coloring.
The only "mega popular" villagers I really like are Diana, Stitches, and Audie. I also like Merengue, but she grew on me over time because she was my starting Normal villager in New Leaf. Julian is also growing on me - he was my smug camper I had to move in in New Horizons and he's actually pretty endearing.
Flurry - i just think she's hideous. What even are those eyebrows?
Marshal - he's fine, but I don't understand the fuss? There are much cuter squirrels - Poppy, Mint, Blaire, Sylvana, Filbert...
Rosie - again, she's fine, but I don't get the fuss.
Judy - her name/personality/aesthetic just don't make sense to me. She seems like she should be peppy and have a different name.
Raymond - he's probably my least favorite of the 8 new villagers honestly. He just does not appeal to me.
Zucker - He's so....blah...to me.
Chrissy and Francine - their whole pop star aesthetic is just not my style
Ankha - again, she just is not my style.
Peanut - I just don't like her coloring.
The only "mega popular" villagers I really like are Diana, Stitches, and Audie. I also like Merengue, but she grew on me over time because she was my starting Normal villager in New Leaf. Julian is also growing on me - he was my smug camper I had to move in in New Horizons and he's actually pretty endearing.
MarzipanDragyn
Determined Designer
So far, Marshal. I don't really see why he's so popular.
I mean, yes, his design is cute, but his personality makes him come off as full of himself and a bit of jerk.
Still, he's only just moved in, so I should probably just give him some time to warm up to everyone. It's hypocritical of me to judge a book by its cover. (Still, if he ends up not fitting well with the others, anyone's welcome to have him! )
I mean, yes, his design is cute, but his personality makes him come off as full of himself and a bit of jerk.
Still, he's only just moved in, so I should probably just give him some time to warm up to everyone. It's hypocritical of me to judge a book by its cover. (Still, if he ends up not fitting well with the others, anyone's welcome to have him! )
