Mafia August 2021 Mafia Game- Town Win!

[Geoni]

Idk why I said to Ace mog's EoD wasn't eek. I reread. I change my mind. It's eek if Volt is mafia for sure. Very first thing mog said at the start of the day was using not knowing it wasn't plurality. Ugh idk.

And man I can't help but think Ace really does have a lot of takes my reread is circling back into agreeing with and I am wrong for voting him and wanting him in a Thunderdome. I may unvote him. :/

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

Collection of quotes that pinged me for different reasons in my reread:

Spoiler

Wait shouldn’t it be locked now that it's night?

This felt potentially ignorance-tell/derpclear?

If your mafia then eliminate me

I WANT TO DIE

The way Armadillo manifested this. <3 Inspiring.

She said if you're the mafia vote me then voltairenism voted her and I thought that meant she was dead
However it turns out I was wrong, so ignore me

Same as above with the mechanics ignorance and how this suggests he was approaching the game by himself.

Probably from the mafia
Also armadillo you're not dead, I just thought you were for a second

Another similar quote.

mafia can only kill during night, I was just joking with armadillo

True, but I'm going to wait until we have more proof instead of blindly voting her off

I've already forgotten the context and why I have it in my collected quotes smh. Maybe an unteamed moment or something.

Ok disregard what I said about Bl00m going inactive after being accused, I literally missed the post amidst all the filler where she said she was low on battery and that it was 9 pm. I noticed it when I was looking at backlog to try to figure out the reason for all the votes going on.

rn it's Geoni and Armadillo being voted. The Geoni vote doesn't make sense to me really but from what I gather it was a random vote between non-active people. I'm not that big on the idea of tossing Geoni off without ever hearing from them. I will openly admit I'm biased towards keeping Geoni around past d1 because I know they are an experienced player and that feels way too valuable to just randomly discard. I hope that didn't sound mean?

The Armadillo vote I can understand somewhat given the chaotic energies - as I said before though I'm not sure what to make of that.

I'm also just really stuck on vote vs no vote still. I'm trying to be a bit more confident this game since the last one would have been won if I just voted instead of cowarding out. Has it been said anywhere if roles are revealed on death? If they aren't then I feel even more inclined to go for the no vote.

I also feel like mafia Sheep would know about flips? Not nearly as confident in this ignorance tell as much as Koopa's though.

koopadude was all careful, didnt want to hang someone unless we had enouh suspecion, and now it's 100% sure that either armadillo or b100 are mafia. how is that for a change of heart


there are doctors in this game, it depends on the setup. this game is rly like yours, except because you can't read body language, it's all based on throughout discussion and argument, so it is more stressful

Forgot why I quoted this too. Maybe I didn't like the attack on Koopa?

Yeah I think I'm going to keep my vote on nobody, but like tessa, i would like to hear more from other people in case I should vote for armadillo again.
Here's how I view everyone though it's subject to change:
Definitely not mafia:
Me
tessa
Geoni
Might be mafia, but I'm not too sure:
Voltairenism
Ace marvel
armadillo
mogyay
suspicious of:
B100ming
Let me know if I should move anyone. Basically since Ace and b100ming are yellow on @Geoni's more detailed list, I think we should vote one of those two.
Ace I'm less suspicious of, since he's not as active as b100ming, so there isn't much information we have but we have more with b100ming

@Koopadude100 curious as to how you feel about Ace currently, this really did come off as such a blind follow and what I imagine a lot of people got in an upset with you over.

wait what does NAI mean?

Ehh...the least telling of the derptells. But derpy nevertheless.

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

I don't want Koopa to be today's elimination.

I'm still feeling okayish about Sheep.

Tessa is maybe the least yellow of my yellows but man I can't shake off some underlying feeling about what I drilled her on earlier.

@mogyay reminder to vote for god's sake

I'm yet again back around to wanting to figure out one of Volt or Ace's alignments it just sucks because idk Ace does have some pretty agreeable tier rankings and thought process but he gives me and Tessa townreads so so easy.

 

[mogyay]

i dont even think its that stupid, it

Not much I have to say about this post other than I will assume mog will clarify herself and this comes off as Sheep simply trying to understand where someone is coming from, kinda NAI unless sheep turns around and uses it again mov for being confusing.

i already tried to clarify it though? i just think its weird to vote for someone, and being the final vote as well, just to instantly reply that you're not surprised by them being town?

also i'm just on my break, trying to read through everything. also sure, my wording was terrible but it was pretty obvious bloom couldn't be mafia with her vote on you, maybe she doesn't know your playstyle but it's still ballsy to place a vote on you is it not lol

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

geoni pls don't rush genius ok i will vote, i don't need u for god saking me

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

pls ignore my first sentence above the quote, im not sure what happened there

 

[Geoni]

It doesn't hurt to remind you since Dan said he'd modkill you if you failed to vote again is all. If you still need time to have confidence on a player do a placeholder like no-elimination?

 

[mogyay]

Kinda addressed this in my other reply to you but it's part of the larger equation. If I am being honest it has to run deeper, I think there were a large amount of potentially sketchy votes between b100 and Volt if it's t/t. From what you have been posting I assume you are questioning Tessa and should logically be looking at her partner being a non-voter or Volt voter? So idk why you are taking such a simplified approach if you think Koopa is town. I digress I think you get my point and I am already being bulky.

idk why ur being so defensive tbh, we're not all big brains like u and it makes sense to look at the ppl who killed town, idk why ur saying it's simplified, im trying to my best to help

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

It doesn't hurt to remind you since Dan said he'd modkill you if you failed to vote again is all. If you still need time to have confidence on a player do a placeholder like no-elimination?

i did.

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

anyway my break is over i didnt get through anything rly, ill come back at lunch

 

[Geoni]

Nevermind you placed a vote.

And what I'm saying about that mog is that if you townread Koopa, the only other living player who has blood on her hands is Tessa and Tessa would have to have a partner. Given you're voting Sheep you're already looking elsewhere however. *shrug* I'll let you do your thing and make your case for a Sheep elimination.

 

[mogyay]

What do you mean? Sheep is also another living player who voted blooming? I don’t particularly love tessa either but I thought i should place a vote for now

also sorry for being sensitive, I just don’t really appreciate all the comments coz it makes me feel useless and stupid, this is my first games in a few years so I’m just easing in and don’t want to get overwhelmed sorry.

in my maybe simplified opinion I don’t see how mafia couldn’t have lead or at least encouraged that vote since to me blooming had a lot of town tells, I don’t think it’s koopa which I’ll elaborate later

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

Is this sheeps first game? I thought they’d played before?

 

[Geoni]

Mog when I use the term simplified I don't mean like...stupid I mean it's one piece of the puzzle and hard to feel good about alone.

If anything I'm stupid because I just realize I had Armadillo and Sheep confused all day and thought Sheep had voted Volt and Armadillo b100. I need to reread some content from Sheep, I feel like I've been placated by a lot of their posts and interactions but b100 was LHF for sure.

And really? Even if I call it simplified taking a shot at someone on the b100 wagon isn't the worst idea in the world although I'm still cautious to base it on that alone personally it's a shot that can hit a wolf. I've been spamming walls all day and feel like it hasn't gotten me nearly as far in my understanding of people's alignments as I wished it would and it's probably overwhelming people. I'm a very train of thought person and I wall as a result.

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

Sheep's entire ISO in the spoiler below:

Spoiler

I don't even know how you're supposed to gather enough information to vote someone on d1... I will most likely also just vote no-one for d1 unless something dramatic happens. Days are 48 hours so there's still time but given it's d1 I doubt much will happen.

Both me and Mog have posted in the first few pages!

I'm very much actively in the game, I was just asleep when a lot of the conversation happened. I guess I should mention my time-zone is very weird due to being in EU. I'll try to post when I go sleep in the future so people know when I'm off being unconscious.

I just woke up so I'm not at full brain power or anything right now. Looks like a lot of filler when I skimmed. Armadillo and Bl00m are a bit weird but I'm not sure how much of that is just being new and excited to post? Bl00m did go silent after people expressed some light suspicion but that might be time-zones at play again. If we were voting just based on silence then I would be an entire hypocrite given what I just said about my own stuff.

Post automatically merged: Aug 20, 2021

Also regarding my stance on the voting vs not voting: I'll have to think it over a bit more. I have a few IRL obligations coming up as we speak, but I will try to form an opinion next time I'm back to post.

Ok disregard what I said about Bl00m going inactive after being accused, I literally missed the post amidst all the filler where she said she was low on battery and that it was 9 pm. I noticed it when I was looking at backlog to try to figure out the reason for all the votes going on.

rn it's Geoni and Armadillo being voted. The Geoni vote doesn't make sense to me really but from what I gather it was a random vote between non-active people. I'm not that big on the idea of tossing Geoni off without ever hearing from them. I will openly admit I'm biased towards keeping Geoni around past d1 because I know they are an experienced player and that feels way too valuable to just randomly discard. I hope that didn't sound mean?

The Armadillo vote I can understand somewhat given the chaotic energies - as I said before though I'm not sure what to make of that.

I'm also just really stuck on vote vs no vote still. I'm trying to be a bit more confident this game since the last one would have been won if I just voted instead of cowarding out. Has it been said anywhere if roles are revealed on death? If they aren't then I feel even more inclined to go for the no vote.

Unfortunately I don't think anyone in here has any solid leads on who is and isn't mafia at this point. Also since you're awake do you have any elaboration on the knowing who is getting voted out remark or was that just you misunderstanding the rules? Like Volt said earlier if you think there is foul play going on somehow then sharing that is a good idea. I'm not personally very sure how serious your comment was but I guess I'll ask about it anyway since it's d1 so why not.



I'm pretty sure Ace would have told you this anyway but you can't trust someone in this game just because they're your friend. If you have that mindset then town will have a disadvantage due to you always blindly trusting your friend even if they end up being Mafia. Also it's against the rules to tell people your roles so you have no way of knowing if your friend is Mafia or not to begin with, unless actual proof ends up coming to light anyways. It's also against the rules to not play for the win so if your friend was Mafia they would have to eventually get rid of you anyway.

I hope that made sense? Ace feel free to throw me out the window for intercepting, I just thought it might be best to clear why that mindset is bad asap.

No worries at all. I didn't exactly make myself too well known at the start anyway because I'm not the best at small talk and that's what a lot of the posts around the first pages were.

I think we're still missing Geoni in their entirety and Mog has only posted the answers. Hopefully both of em show up before EOD at least.

@Damniel

Will roles be revealed on death? I should have asked this the second I originally wondered about it smh

I feel Armadillo has sounded more of a mix of confused town and hyperactive to me? I've tried looking at the posts but I don't see a whole lot of defending so much as just confusion. Also at the very least the thing I asked her about I did get an immediate answer to, I'm not sure how much that weighs against the point of avoiding questions.

One thing that did bother me earlier was B100m not responding to the explanation about not trusting friends at all. Maybe I'm reading too much in to it but it feels a bit like leaning on that friendship as a crutch. She has only really talked with Armadillo too, and even used Armadillo as a basis for her vote immediately. I hope I'm making sense at all. Of the two I almost feel B100m is more suspicious.

Post automatically merged: Aug 20, 2021

I'm not saying both of them are mafia, but the possibility of maf!b100m and town!Armadillo lingers in my mind after that.

Would no-vote still be the wisest after all?
Considering if we have a miss and someone gets done in by Mafia we lose two people which is two potential people with the detective role.

Oh I must have missed that post when I was scrolling through the backlog this morning. Yeah that's a fair point. I'll try to get over my lingering hesitancy when it comes to voting then. Absolutely zero idea who to vote for then though. The best idea I had was b100m earlier and even that wasn't the firmest.

I think I need to try and do a proper re-read of the entire thread again. It's unfortunately starting to be pretty late over here and I do not trust my brain to be cohesive much longer so that will have to wait.

Geoni has arrived now though so we should have some fresh takes soon, hopefully.

I'm awake again and will be re-reading the thread now.
I'm going to be going in to this day with the mindset that I will place a vote as I no longer feel that no-vote is as safe of an option as I initially expected it to be. I'll also be posting my reads along with it. Still a bit groggy as I just got up so I might take a bit but I will deliver.

Notes.

voltairenism - Not a lot of content surprisingly. The Tessa bit interests me due to the fact shouldn't Tessa acting different be a good thing if she has been on a mafia streak? No reads posted either for some reason despite having been online. I find this silence a bit weird.

thetessagrace - If I understand correctly the whole Armadillo dealio was more because she wanted to start discussion and didn't want to enable the no-vote route. Feels like a pretty strong move to make, in fact too strong for mafia so it reads more as towny to me.

b100ming - I'm seeing a tiny bit more independence now, which I like. However I'm not really picking up on a solid response to being one of the running votes now. Volts question went ignored in fact despite the voting situation. Most likely reading too much in to it but after Armadillo got more read as confused town I started seeing more posts about being confused from her.

Geoni - I admittedly have deathtunneled people in my spectating before for being too in control and that is something I am consciously trying to not repeat without good reason. Right now Geoni seems to be pushing town along on a path that does not bother me. I see a lot of helping the newer players try to explain themselves or form their own opinions, for now none of that has seemed overtly manipulative to me. I'm currently reading Geoni as town.

Ace Marvel - I mainly know Ace as an aggressive player from my past spectating, however he is doing low-effort this time. I will note Ace dodged the question Geoni asked regarding Tessa/Volt entirely and I also notice that this is the point where I see more of the familiar Ace aggression pop up. In fact, the Tessa/Volt bit did not even come up in his reads afterwards at all.

Armadillo Lover - I read her as confused town for now. The display of emotions so far has seemed on par with something you'd see out of a new player. Outside of the emotions I've not seen much content though and I will be keeping this in mind going forward. I don't expect an essay from a new person though.

Koopadude100 - I lean a bit in the not-trusting direction as of now. There's a whole bunch of flipflopping going on that often leans on other players. I cannot place if this is new town behaviour or new mafia behaviour in trying to play it safe by appealing to everyone. One instance that very much stuck out to me was him saying B100m was the best vote however then immediately going:

"however Ace marvel is also suspicious too, so I recommend voting them."

That's... a pretty weird flipflop to me. I understand it most likely has to do with Geoni having a big impact, but the willingness to push aside his own thoughts on the best vote just to start slightly pushing someone elses vote leaves me feeling a bit strange. ... and then in his next post Ace is okay again. I can't keep up man.

Also I noticed I was missing from his reads. Human error I suppose as I do not see what he could gain from this, unless we assume this is an attempt to frame me as maf via putting distance between us if he gets voted out and ends up being maf?? Feels a bit too advanced for a new player.

Mog - Literally null and I'm half expecting a rep to happen. The only even remote connection you could make in her case is one of her only posts using friendly language towards cabin mates in the event. I believe during the last game happening during a team event one of the mafia member used similar language. This is a non-point though, imo.

Conclusions as of now.

Geoni. Armadillo. Tessa.
Volt. Ace Marvel. b100ming. Koopa

mogyay.


Who am I willing to vote?

Koopa is bothering me the most honestly with the flipflopping.
B100m I am fine with voting. I don't feel as strongly rn though. It's better than a non-vote.

Volt+Ace I am needing extra content from before I'm fully open to voting.

Post automatically merged: Aug 21, 2021

I cannot find the post anymore but @Geoni asked about someone being EU I believe and I can confirm that would be me in my weird EU timezone.

Post automatically merged: Aug 21, 2021

I will also now go grab a bite to eat so if someone replies to my notes/reads expect a reply in 40mins.

I'm placing my vote on B100ming for now. I'm still in favour of voting over not voting and she has the leading player vote.
Do not consider my vote final, however.

I've been hoping Volt would crop up. I touched on it in my notes but I did find it weird to assume Tessa being weird = Maf when Tessa has been playing Maf a lot in the past games so anything unusual should be more towny by logic.

Don't have a lot of time today to dedicate to posting, mostly just peeking in to see what happened.

Not all that surprised about the b100m flip in the end tbh
I guess Armadillo being killed saves us the trouble of arguing over the last minute swap from adamantly no-voting to voting volt.

Responding to quotes in a bit but I have some thoughts and possibly things I'd like to hear more about.

1. Ace/Volt

I'm not the biggest fan of the meta based vote just because it feels a bit opportunistic to me to use an off-site meta reason like that so close to EOD while no-one except Volt and Ace know how true it is. Volt was still very much missing at this point too so all we ever had to go off of was Ace. Granted Ace wouldn't have known Volt was going to miss EOD entirely, but I still just do not like the play. I guess I'd like to hear more about what everyone else thinks of his?

2. Mog

Why did Mog not vote at all? She was here 4 mins before EOD and even remarked on how close to EOD it was and did not vote still. There are earlier posts by her that state her disdain for not voting alongside a post earlier of her stating she knows she has to vote. Mog has also already been here since the day started and didn't comment on not voting at all?? I find all this really weird.

Post automatically merged: Aug 23, 2021

No solid guesses, just concerns.



Argue was too strong of a word so that's my bad. I more so meant I felt people were going to bring it up inevitably due to how extreme of a change it was for her to go from preaching no-vote for 2 (irl) days and then last minute switching.

I guess that's fair enough. Asking for old game examples of the behaviour on tbt would risk being out of date. I still don't enjoy the play for reasons I already stated. Can I ask why you didn't post about it earlier on though?

Also regarding my b100m vote;

If I had voted for who I actually wanted to yesterday it would have been Koopa. No-one else seemed to be that interested in voting for him though so it was stuck between b100m, Volt and No-Vote. As I've mentioned I did not feel comfortable switching my vote to Volt for an off-site meta reason I had no way of confirming. I do agree I don't like the whole gut-instinct thing going on though.

Right now? Ace, Mog, Koopa. One of the bunch, mostly due to my recent concerns. Nothing that has been said has exactly made me feel any better about them. I feel maybe Mogs response seemed to have some emotion behind it, at least but idk.

I genuinely would like more content from all of them though, but there isn't a lot of talking going on. Koopa especially for me since a lot of my feelings about him stem from the flipflopping yesterday.

I'm also working on several non-game related papers but I can do some back-and-forth real quick.

I've not spectated a Mog game before since that would be before I got interested in the Mafia scene on tbt I believe? Good to know regarding the emotion bit; I am not the best at emotions admittedly either.

Regarding Volt. I'll be honest and say I don't know. Volt does also fall somewhere in the low neutrals at highest, but I feel Volt hasn't been the weirdest out of everyone here. The gut thing is still really weird but Volt seems to have chilled out on it after the night a bit.

There's a post about it before EOD, a pretty long one. Mainly boils down to not enjoying how he kept swapping votes based on other people, sometimes even conflicting himself mid post.



I am literally about to go crash so forgive me but my brain is not keeping up here in regards to what you mean. Feel free to explain it to me like I'm 5 years old so I can see it tomorrow when I wake up and feel really dumb.

Post automatically merged: Aug 23, 2021

All that said I am going to go pass out now, I'm sorry to any NA people for my difficult awake patterns.
If you have anything you want me to respond to just ping me and I'll get back to it when I'm awake.

Okay so I'm really tired and this is like the second bulkiest player in the game rn in terms of post-length but from what I understand at a first glance is that Sheep had a higher amount of sus on Koopa compared to b100 but b100 was a compromise with others because Koopa didn't seem to be happening and it'd have been a wasted vote. I think if Volt or Ace are mafia there's not enough to make me think they can't be teamed with either one of them given there's been some light questioning thrown towards the two of them but it never reaches the point of them being voted and there's been progression away from Volt in particular afaict.

I'm not voting this right now though, the amount of diversity in angles they are approaching the game from and indication that they've been reading every single thing posted. And yeah from what I've read here it sounds like this is Sheeps first full game and they only replaced and had a short time in one more game, they can reclarify their experience with mafia. They are really great if brand new.

The only problem to be found with Sheep's EoD it's that they didn't try to lead others off b100 very forcefully and vote who they truly wanted to see eliminated and go hard but to be fair they'd have been contending with the loudness that is...me. :/

Day 1 was much more involved from Sheep than Day 2 and maybe all I'd like to hear is what @Sheep Villager found in Volt to stop finding her weird and towny, all I can remember is that Sheep liked that Volt calmed down about the vague gut-based vote on Tessa.

Sheep can do what they want but out of their three they're looking at voting (Ace/mog/Koopa) Koopa feels like the lowest swing and I'd be more interested in seeing Sheep case Ace or Mog here as day approaches its end.

 

[Geoni]

SMH I'm just walling again and again.

Okay I need to go to bed which means I won't be back until there's very little time to change the course of the votes. 2/7 of us voting so far is no bueno. I still stand behind wanting to see either Volt or Ace flipped because I've had the deepest feelings about them and I'd have a much easier time solving the game if either flips red and I can root out the partner. That's when I start becoming more accurate. Tessa is an outside option if nobody ends up wanting to see Volt or Ace flipped.

I said I was tempted to swerve and unvote Ace after ISOing him post-attack but I wanna see what he has to say first. If I unvote Ace I'd probably just lean back towards the Volt world.

I still have some qualms about all three of Sheep/Mog/Koopa but I really think Sheep's ISO is super consistent and least likely to be operating on TMI compared to the other two. Mog shows a lot of effort compared to some others on this Day 2 but man I just really disagree with her takes/conclusions so far but I find it hard to want to see someone eliminated just because I disagree with them. And I'm holding my breath on how serious I want to townread Koopa over some 'ignorance/derp tells'. Again Koopa, not calling you derpy or ignorant as a person just that you are not knowledgeable about forum mafia in other words have an ignorance on mechanics early day 1. Dumbtell is still the worst but 'derptell'/'ignorance-tell' still feel harsh as alternates.

Last wall ya'll have to endure for D2 I promise. Maybe.

 

[voltairenism]

come on i even woke up early for this. hope to hear more from koopa, sheep and ace

 

[Sheep Villager]

Just posting to confirm I'm awake again. I need to do some cooking but I'll be back in 45~ ish to give my thoughts.
I have read the thread up to this point now though and already have some thoughts going on.

 

[Ace Marvel]

I brought it on the first place because I think a more experience player would be the one to catch on armadillo's softing cop


ace i was bussing my teammate on d1 last game make up your mind

Im talking behavior wise, not action wise.

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

@Ace Marvel what about my posting is chill and why does 'chill' equate to me being town? Has there been any moment at all this game when you have looked at something I said and said to yourself, "There's no way this post couldn't come from wolf Geoni." Especially considering my wolf range is incredible, if I can be cocky and say so myself. Especially considering you reinforced a Volt wagon that I led using that meta while having seemingly no paranoia about me. Wouldn't it be safe to assume that wolf you would have liked to get town Volt out of the picture while keeping the contentious b100ming alive into d2 and I have a right to question your sheer lack of paranoia about me?

Also I don't think Ace has ever been wolf when I'm town so I can see him falling back on placating me/keeping me off his radar. Having a moment for sure.

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

Who would you vote right now?

From what I remember you are more play more aggressively, and you have been mafia before in games I have played with you, so I don't think you would play this solve way without actually going strong after someone if you are mafia.

Why would I have paranoia when the day went let's not vote anyone, I could have use that to my advantage and say oh yeah lets not kill anyone and it was free shot to find the cop, I don't agree with that, you started the wagon because no one was voting them, but my vote was because other reasons.

Tessa read is not a micro read is based on meta that I know how they played mafia with me, and if I remember something Tessa had a hard time was blending in and I help her with that, so is not surprise to me that Tessa would do the same this game, but doing it in thread means no team to do it privately and be coached.

 

[Ace Marvel]

Back to Mog I think is eek, because I said I was against not voting someone out, and then Mog didn't and the reason being not wanting to kill new players. Not votings give us not info, and you are allowed to not vote once, so that is a tool people can use to their advantage if mafia.

 

[tessa grace]

alright i just woke up to this chaos but i gotta vote before school starts and i cant even read it all :0

 

[mogyay]

Back to Mog I think is eek, because I said I was against not voting someone out, and then Mog didn't and the reason being not wanting to kill new players. Not votings give us not info, and you are allowed to not vote once, so that is a tool people can use to their advantage if mafia.

what does eek mean?

also i'm not for voting no one, i never said that, someone was going to be killed regardless and i didn't have enough certainly volt was mafia so i chose not to vote, completely different from advocating a no vote. also i said it wasn't logical to not vote new players, but i said we should be careful because they're an easy target and look what's happened so i think i was correct to say it honestly

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

and also that's just my uwu personality lmao, i even said at the time it was dumb reasoning, i'm not saying we should just forget they exist, but it's just a bit suspect to go from one to another

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

also volt had a vote in the last 5 minutes, i was around eod so i could have made a decision but i literally had 5 minutes and i'm not a strong player, obviously in hindsight i should have chosen to save blooming and maybe with more than 5 minutes to spare i would have but i just didn't wanna risk it

 

[Sheep Villager]

And I'm back to post thoughts.

1. Ace
I'm even less of a fan of his behaviour than I was yesterday. I flat out do not like the approach of 'everyone doing bare minimum so I will also do that', especially when coming from someone who earlier on yesterday expressed desire to not see the game die. He also straight up ignored the question I had about why he waited so long to post re: volt on d1. All this almost comes off as borderline coasting to me and I'm not sure how typical something like that is for Ace. I at least cannot remember right off the bat ever seeing something like that given how aggressive I remember him to be. Volt has now also commented on the meta thing and called it in to question a bit, which additionally does not inspire trust in Ace for me.

2. Koopa
Koopa is not my d2 vote unless it's between him and one of my current more town-read people. I don't feel a Koopa flip would be as valuable right now as Ace/Volt due to how Koopa has been playing this game. First flipflopping and then going silent and not providing anything at all. All of this is still very 'safe' behaviour where he doesn't have to speak his own mind on things. I think solving if Koopa is confused town or scared mafia will have to wait until d3 if they don't get nk'd. I'd really liked to have heard his thoughts on things before anyone else voted.

3. Mog
If we want to be conspiracy theory for a bit it could be possible Mog/Koopa are teamed due to Mog being so consistently on the side of new players that it wouldn't raise suspicion for her to not suspect Koopa ever. Before I dwell too much on that I would like to see the current Ace/Volt debacle resolve somehow. Also she did promise some explanation that involves Koopa so that's something I want to see.

4. Volt
Some of the reason I'm currently not as suspicious of Volt as I am of Ace does stem from the behaviours Ace has exhibited. I guess I should consider the possibility both of them are mafia though as despite everything going on they haven't interacted a lot? I don't feel Volt d1 had anything weird going on besides the gut thing. Post quality on d1 being low does not surprise me since the filler was admittedly a bit all-consuming (at least to me) and made early d1 posting hard. I'd like to see some actual reads posted by Volt? Not having any out despite it being d2 is a bit strange.

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

Regarding my game experience since there has been some confusion:
Started spectating mafia on tbt around end of Marioverse Kingmaker, first full game I read was the Karen mafia one.
I repped for the dethy that happened before this one but was only around for one day. This is my first actual player game.

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

Current reads

Geoni, Tessa
Volt Mog Koopa
Ace

 

[tessa grace]

I think I agree with the ace vote, walking to
my next class atm so I'll quickly vote.

 

[voltairenism]

i was going to vote ace but now that everyone is doing it i dont want anymore

 

[Ace Marvel]

i think id rather volt over blooming but also im usually incorrect

Post automatically merged: Aug 21, 2021

bad logic but wouldnt she at least show up if shes mafia lol

okies even if its not a formal rule i will try to be more mindful in future, ty for letting me know !

Post automatically merged: Aug 21, 2021

im rly derailing the convo with 4 mins left

You were here EoD, so you could vote.

I think my final read list

Geoni
Tessa
Sheep
Mog
Koppa
Volt

GG town.

I won't be able to be here a lot to defend myself and must of you are voting me anyway.

 

[voltairenism]

lets all cfd tessa

 

[Sheep Villager]

lets all cfd tessa

Do you need more antacid for your gut?