Mafia Baby Mafia - Main thread.

[Emolga59]

I don't think that's a good idea at the moment, I already have a decent understanding of what shellbell's and kiko's roles could be, based on what they said prior (kiko saying shellbell 'safe' and shellbell summarizing heres) therefore I don't think we need to vote for one of them

Post automatically merged: May 29, 2021

I can see where you're coming from tho, it's just way too risky unless if I'm missing the idea here

 

[tessa grace]

I don't think that's a good idea at the moment, I already have a decent understanding of what shellbell's and kiko's roles could be, based on what they said prior (kiko saying shellbell 'safe' and shellbell summarizing heres) therefore I don't think we need to vote for one of them

Post automatically merged: May 29, 2021

I can see where you're coming from tho, it's just way too risky unless if I'm missing the idea here

thats probably the best idea
anyways, who to vote then?

 

[Equity]

I don't know if I can trust @kikotoot yet... Based on the first questions they've answered, kikotoot has been playing a lot of werewolf games whereas shellbell has only just heard of the game. So just like @Mistreil has said, either

1. shellbell is playing the "beginner" card: pretending to be new and revealing her ability early on to get on our side OR shellbell is genuinely good and is putting herself at risk.
2. kikotoot is truly on the 'good' side by genuinely caring about shellbell's concerns OR kikotoot trying to buddy up to shellbell by using an ability and by telling her she's 'safe'.

I'm not sure... one has more experience than the other at these kinds of games... a bit sus.

 

[shellbell]

i know this sounds risky but maybe we vote shellbell or kikotoot to determine the other's role?

if someone gets eliminated by vote, do we get to learn anything about them afterwards?

 

[Mistreil]

View attachment 378437
I'm good y'all

i--
I MAKE NO MISTAKES!

clearly my subconscious aka lazy copypasting wants to say shellbell is innocent! and since i make no mistakes, i shall stick to that.

im against eliminating kikotoot or shellbell -- on the chance that kiko is telling the truth, eliminating them would be a huge loss. shellbell is a bit safer to eliminate given what they said about their ability, but Because I Make No Mistakes aka this is completely unfounded, it would just effectively be getting rid of someone innocent. and durashellbell may come in handy at some point

we could do no elimination again, and hope we get more information tomorrow. as it stands its either 8 village - 2 mafia, or 7 villager - 3 mafia.

 

[shellbell]

shellbell is playing the "beginner" card

I'm really a beginner! look at me asking all these questions

 

[Emolga59]

if someone gets eliminated by vote, do we get to learn anything about them afterwards?

While I'm not entirely sure, it was like that for me when I played in the Renaissance mafia so it is possible

 

[rosetti]

Sorry for the late reply... I was too busy not venting my way through the race that I forgot to response!

RIP Kilza... I can’t believe they would do this to you. We will avenge you!

I don’t know how I feel about this, but I’ve noticed that @kikotoot was the only one who didn’t vote. This behaviour is kinda sus if you ask me... Care to explain yourself?

correct me if I'm wrong but I believe karma also didnt vote? interesting that u missed that but picked on kiko

it would be more fair to wait until we hear more from kiko so until then I'm happy with the no elimination again, this allows us to gather more information as there's no rush (I RLY DO BE PROMOTING STOPPING THE SWEAT/THE USUAL TBT MAFIA STYLE)

this.

I think should tell you all what my ability is (or does since I can't quote exactly what it is) since I think it's more beneficial if it's revealed, and doesn't really put me at risk. I'm basically like a battery, if you're out of power, I'll charge you up. But I don't know what powers my target has or whether they used it up or not. Last night I targeted rosetti at random and nothing happened as far as I can tell.

is there any reason u targeted me in particular shellbell :0
nothing did indeed happen, I plan for that to stay that way until a few more nights xoxo
aka I am completely useless until endgame LOL

 

[shellbell]

While I'm not entirely sure, it was like that for me when I played in the Renaissance mafia so it is possible

but we didn't learn anything from kilza's death right? is that because it was a mafia kill?

 

[Mistreil]

@shawo can you confirm if this is how eliminations work

or do we receive nothing

 

[shellbell]

is there any reason u targeted me in particular shellbell :0

no, like i said it was just random. i was convinced i was going to be offed by mafia last night and wanted to use my ability at least once.

 

[Emolga59]

but we didn't learn anything from kilza's death right? is that because it was a mafia kill?

Maybe, or it could be because she had no role at all (just a vanilla townie) and the no role reveals could also be possible

Post automatically merged: May 29, 2021

correct me if I'm wrong but I believe karma also didnt vote? interesting that u missed that but picked on kiko

I just checked and it seems like you're right abt karma not voting, I too, find this interesting
This could go either way, either they didn't realize karma didn't vote or there's something else...
I'm guessing it's the former though-

 

[IonicKarma]

correct me if I'm wrong but I believe karma also didnt vote? interesting that u missed that but picked on kiko

it would be more fair to wait until we hear more from kiko so until then I'm happy with the no elimination again, this allows us to gather more information as there's no rush (I RLY DO BE PROMOTING STOPPING THE SWEAT/THE USUAL TBT MAFIA STYLE)



is there any reason u targeted me in particular shellbell :0
nothing did indeed happen, I plan for that to stay that way until a few more nights xoxo
aka I am completely useless until endgame LOL

I... didn’t even realize there was a separate voting thread... I thought we were voting here through our posts...

 

[Equity]

I'm really a beginner! look at me asking all these questions

I want to give you the benefit of the doubt! Anything goes in this game though.

correct me if I'm wrong but I believe karma also didnt vote? interesting that u missed that but picked on kiko

it would be more fair to wait until we hear more from kiko so until then I'm happy with the no elimination again, this allows us to gather more information as there's no rush (I RLY DO BE PROMOTING STOPPING THE SWEAT/THE USUAL TBT MAFIA STYLE)

You are 100% correct, I was sure I had everyone based on IonicKarma's comment on this thread! Kind of sus too that they didn't vote, but they just said that they didn't realize there was a separate thread. However, I do like to hear from all sides for a more informed opinion! I agree with you that there isn't enough information though. I'm confused.

I wouldn't be against voting no eliminate until there's more information!

 

[IonicKarma]

I could be wrong but I’m pretty sure there are no vanilla townies in this game. I think everyone (except maybe mafia?) has a special role of some sort

 

[shellbell]

btw, if anyone wants a shot of durashellbell i'm all ears, since i don't know what any of you can do or cannot do, i'll just be targeting someone at random again to see if something happens.

 

[Equity]

I'm confused about these roles as well, aren't we all role playing one character and we're supposed to guess each other's character which is why the role wasn't revealed yet?

 

[shellbell]

or maybe ill use it on kiko since i know it will hit?

 

[IonicKarma]

If we don’t even get alignment after eliminating someone this seems borderline impossible for town haha...

 

[shellbell]

I'm confused about these roles as well, aren't we all role playing one character and we're supposed to guess each other's character which is why the role wasn't revealed yet?

same, im confused about this as well... are we racers or townsfolk