Mafia Bravely Default Mafia

[Ashtot]

Honestly, I'm not really seeing the scummyness that everyone else is seeing in Audino and it just comes off as people wanting to push on a newer player who is acting a little different or doing something silly that can be taken to use against them. Except Endless because he's shown he can argue even though 60% of it is hot air. And I've honestly got my eye on the people going after audino right now because I'm really not getting significant scumreads that people are getting. Oh wait nm people suck at giving them.

I agree with this, I talk about audino in the post I just made.

Also Ashtot and Trundle are just being pigheaded like always and voting emotionally/with that wack random vote kill when there's more to go on here. It's a decent day one for a game starting after such a long break.

Like a lot of people you tend to think that simply placing a vote means more than it actually does. There's nothing wrong with voting, because you can easily change it whenever you want. Sometimes it starts discussion which is generally a good thing. You also can't say that our votes are emotional when so far they've been completely rational. I generally support voting out inactives on day one in every game I play, Capella is someone I normally go for because she does nothing. That has nothing to do with my emotions, and has all to do with the fact that she hinders Town more than she helps it.

A lot of what I've said about audino here also applies to sonrio, and after looking at the voting thread sonrio is getting it even worse, for the dumbest reason: people are following Trundle's random vote strat because anything more actually requires effort and the people voting for sonrio aren't giving that.

I do agree that people are following Trundle's vote too easily. I don't think his vote is awful, but I don't see a huge reason for him to be voted for so far.

 

[unravel]

Already suspecting sonrio you know there 3 ways
1.) A stupid mafia player who thinks that his role is innocent if he is a mafia then that means you're a mafia as well
2.) Distracts a town because he doesn't have an ability or whatever.
3.) A third party and tries to frame you because he's your target or your role is "important"

- - - Post Merge - - -

And so I thought this is a troll mafia game but screw that

Ladies, calm yo **** I only posted 1 spam and my opinion about sonrio plus its day one you cant expect people contribute a lot this game is for fun and not to be taken seriously.

I want to see Tom post more since its day one we can't vote him just yet but I have a feeling he cud be a scum usualky he's inactive/contribute less if he's a scum also I suggest you guys read than asking summary.

 

[Blu Rose]

yay i'm actually here

sorry i'm just posting to say that i exist and i'll probably be able to post more tonight (i'm utc -4 rn)

 

[Nay]

Yea i guess the vote on sonrio was a bit hasty, runeraider does come off a bit standoffish but I like the idea of voting off inactives the first day. There's no objective evidence at all

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm falling asleep again sorry, just noting it here so my silence doesn't accidentally get stigmatized

 

[Pathetic]

tbh i'll probably forget about this game time to time. i'm not much of a peacekeeper, and i've only made about 3-4 spam posts that were uh, directed at the game. once again it was late so ofc i was probably off.

i only wanted u 2 to cut it out because you are 2 strong players nd u know better

 

[Geoni]

I want to see Tom post more since its day one we can't vote him just yet but I have a feeling he cud be a scum usualky he's inactive/contribute less if he's a scum also I suggest you guys read than asking summary.

Why not? What gives him a get out of jail free card?

 

[unravel]

Why not? What gives him a get out of jail free card?

You know what I've been thinking about this.

Already suspecting sonrio you know there 3 ways
1.) A stupid mafia player who thinks that his role is innocent if he is a mafia then that means you're a mafia as well
2.) Distracts a town because he doesn't have an ability or whatever.
3.) A third party and tries to frame you because he's your target or your role is "important"

4.) What if Sonrio is a jest and his objective is to get lynch <=== doesn't matter because it's not a threat.

I dunno Sonrio's playstyle it's been a long time errr I'm outdated lel

I'm also thinking to switch the vote to Tom but we got no reason why he have to vote him aside from "inactivity" and less contribute (scum playstyle before) unless the host is too evil if you get what I mean haha let's see if anything changes then might as well switch vote (welp it's 2 AM) gimme time and I'll read their post again

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Hi my name is Tom and I'm voting Trundle because his vote is dumb. Also I'm napping and may not be back on before vote ends so yolo

 

[Blu Rose]

What are the conditions for modkill? Is it still not voting a day or two in a row?

Sorry if it's in the OP, but I'm fairly sure it's not...

 

[radical6]

What are the conditions for modkill? Is it still not voting a day or two in a row?

Sorry if it's in the OP, but I'm fairly sure it's not...

Three strikes and you're out.

 

[Sonrio]

i already dislike trundle.

slamming a hard townread on Dad for the epic call out on trundles reasoning on me, you go daddy
also audino is getting scummier by the second. could it be they are mafia and are afraid ive found them out?!

- - - Post Merge - - -

i already dislike trundle.

slamming a hard townread on Dad for the epic call out on trundles reasoning on me, you go daddy
also audino is getting scummier by the second. could it be they are mafia and are afraid ive found them out?!

 

[Ashtot]

i already dislike trundle.

slamming a hard townread on Dad for the epic call out on trundles reasoning on me, you go daddy
also audino is getting scummier by the second. could it be they are mafia and are afraid ive found them out?!

- - - Post Merge - - -

i already dislike trundle.

slamming a hard townread on Dad for the epic call out on trundles reasoning on me, you go daddy
also audino is getting scummier by the second. could it be they are mafia and are afraid ive found them out?!

I fail to see how audino is scummy in any way. There's nothing that points towards him being scum so far.

You sound like you're just supporting Dad because he defended you and saying that audino sounds scummy as a way to get attention off of yourself.

 

[EpicGamer12]

The emotional voting moreso applies to Ashtot than you. But that reasoning for voting sonrio is just driving home my point that you're taking somebody joking and using it as a way to get them lynched, which is something scum has done in the past and in this case, a really pisspoor reason to lynch a player.

As we have learned from the past, joking in mafia isn't taken lightly.
Not to mention, the day hasn't ended yet. I can change my vote. How is wanting to get some conversation going a scummy thing to do?

 

[Geoni]

Hi my name is Tom and I'm voting Trundle because his vote is dumb. Also I'm napping and may not be back on before vote ends so yolo

This is so low energy, coasty, and ignoring what I've had to say about you so far. Keeping my vote on you because out of the regulars in this game that I don't townread, you're the one I'm going to be hard on because when we were mafia together you used your coasting playstyle to slide by and people know you work and they're prone to excuse you for that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

As we have learned from the past, joking in mafia isn't taken lightly.

Yes it is, have you never played a game with Superpenguin or Cory? People on tbt don't really take jokes so seriously anymore and your srs business defense of your choice shows that you're being a weak player. God help town if people sheep you.

 

[Ashtot]

Yes it is, have you never played a game with Superpenguin or Cory? People on tbt don't really take jokes so seriously anymore and your srs business defense of your choice shows that you're being a weak player. God help town if people sheep you.

I wouldn't say that it's taken lightly. People get ticked off but they try to ignore it when people joke around sometimes.

 

[Geoni]

People get pissed off but they don't slap scum on people for joking. Also Ash, was saying I had your back yesterday when somebody (Endless) came in from somewhere else acting high and mighty towards my tbt fam. But Endless has had his points since.

 

[Sonrio]

im sorry my posts dont fit your requirements to be anything meaningful trundle : )

- - - Post Merge - - -

I fail to see how audino is scummy in any way. There's nothing that points towards him being scum so far.

You sound like you're just supporting Dad because he defended you and saying that audino sounds scummy as a way to get attention off of yourself.

Saying the vote on me is hasty means he's realized why he could be scumread for it. Lynching a lurker makes no difference as all mafia could be playing and the rest town.

Are you familiar with wifom?

 

[Geoni]

We need to establish tifom

tea in front of me

 

[Sonrio]

banned

 

[Ashtot]

im sorry my posts dont fit your requirements to be anything meaningful trundle : )

- - - Post Merge - - -



Saying the vote on me is hasty means he's realized why he could be scumread for it. Lynching a lurker makes no difference as all mafia could be playing and the rest town.

Are you familiar with wifom?

I just realized that audino voted for you, so that's my bad. I don't think that anything he's posted is necessarily suspicious but his vote definitely is.